Papa Jay's BBQ
6379 IN-16, Monticello
(574) 278-6030
Customers' Favorites
Pulled Pork
Rib Plates
Half Rack
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Had the ribs for the first time today and omg they were amazing!! Fell off the bone, perfectly seasoned and didn’t even need bbq sauce!! Can’t wait to try the pulled pork and rib tips!! You guys are amazing!!
The ribs fell off the bone and since he offers sauce on the side, you can taste the actual meat!! And he gave me a sample of a rib tip that was seasoned so well that sauce wasn't needed! Absolutely must try!!
First time we have been able to swing through around lunch time for fantastic ribs and pulled pork! This did not disappoint. Give this place a try next time you are going through Buffalo Indiana! The sides are sweet potatoes and green beans today. Well worth the money.
You May Also Like
El Lago Taco & Tequila Bar - 5313 NW Shafer Dr
![]()
Mexican, Beer Bar
Bill and Babes - 5658 S Main St
![]()
Bar & Grill, Seafood, American, Pizza