Insomnia Cookies

1622 W University Ave, Muncie
(765) 551-4377

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+43 photos
+42 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Wanted a cookie cake for my birthday. My dear husband said “oh we need to try this place in Muncie!” Great! Website looked great, and I imagined an array of cookie cakes we could grab and go. Nope. $32 for a cookie cake - takes 25 minutes to bake AND they don’t even decorate it. No happy birthday icing - nada. Well they did give me a sticker. I’ll just grab a $20 one at Walmart next year that they’ll at least decorate. Was it still yummy? Yes, but overall disappointed...
Don't let Brody deliver. Ask for someone else. Said my delivery had arrived and sent me a pic of a different apartment door and cookies were nowhere to be found. Screen shot text, door dash, and insomnia for proof. Lady on the phone was fantastic and fixed the problem. Forgot to catch her name. Moral of the story is don't let Brody deliver.
Insomnia Cookies is pure cookie heaven! Every time I go in, I’m greeted by the friendliest, happiest people—it’s like they know I’m about to make the best decision of my day. My cookies are ALWAYS hot, fresh, and so melt-in-your-mouth delicious that it should be illegal. Seriously… these things are dangerously addictive! If you haven’t tried them yet, run (don’t walk) and thank me later. 🍪🔥

More Reviews