Butterfingers
CLOSED$$ •
About Butterfingers
Butterfingers Reviews
98 ratings
![Restaurantji Rating]()
Menu
Add a Menu
People in Munster Also Viewed
Jodi's Italian Ice Factory-Hammond
Sandwich Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Cheesesteaks
Tasty Treats Bakery
Bakery, Cupcakes
Cakes By Karen
Bakery, Gluten-Free
Butterfingers is a charming restaurant known for its exceptional service and high-quality food. The peach pie is a standout, with a deep-dish crust filled with fresh, flavorful fruit. The bakery and deli sandwiches also impress, evoking memories of grandma's kitchen. The place is clean, quiet, and comfortable, with a pleasant atmosphere. The staff is thoughtful, generous, and well-informed. While prices may be a bit steep, the freshness and taste make it well worth it. Customers recommend the chicken salad sandwich on a croissant, as well as the brownies, quiche, and lemon cupcakes. The desserts, such as the chocolate chip cookies and mini cupcakes, have received mixed reviews, but the overall food quality is excellent, with fresh and homemade items.