Good ice cream, not very friendly. No smiles and we’re given dirty looks when we walked in.
Domenico Venezia
Service was awful. Owner was rude and the place smells like there’s toxic mould which is in line with the quality of service we received
Lisa M.
I had a double: one scoop of butter pecan and one of black raspberry. I would order the butter pecan again; it was creamy good with decent bits of nuts. I did not care for the black raspberry. It reminded me of a red raspberry jelly; it was syrupy sweet. My friend got the same two flavors and disagreed with me on the latter but I'm writing the review!
Justin Wood
Pumpkin ice cream was delicious.
Luke B.
The ice cream is home made and delicious. Very pleasant young lady remembered us from our last visit. Very cozy "ice cream shop" setting.
Andrew R.
I recently had the pleasure of visiting Nashville, Indiana, a small town located in Brown County. It was a delightfully quaint place, and I especially enjoyed the local ice cream shop. If you ever find yourself in the area, I would highly recommend taking a trip to Nashville and trying the ice cream for yourself. You won't regret it!
Nick Wesley
No complaints about the food or service, but hard to find it open. We visited on a Sunday afternoon, sign said closed and they cant post hours. While not inherently wrong, there are other places nearby that are more consistent with their hours.
Jada Ford
It was my first time going to Nashville, IN and I was with my boyfriend when we went. We are both black. We went into the shop and the old man yelled “We are CLOSED”, but there were people eating ice cream in the shop. It was pretty clear that the old man discriminated against us by not allowing us to get ice cream when there were people sitting and walking in and out eating ice cream. Shame on you.
Great service and offered to make any flavor in dairy free as long as I called ahead. Had strawberry in a chocolate coat today. Delicious!
Ryan A.
Neat little place to stop in for a treat after walking through downtown Nashville. Lots of flavors to choose from with an old-fashioned feel to it. It wasn't too busy when we were there. Employees were cordial but not overly friendly - pretty sure they were ready for us to make our choice as quickly as possible so they could get back to their break. Not rude, but not a five-star experience either. But the ice cream was really good - definitely will consider stopping back in if the craving hits me next time we're in town.
Richard C.
After we ate lunch elsewhere so we decided on dessert from Fearrin's. I had the regular old plain chocolate and she had the mint chocolate chip. They say their ice cream is home made and I have to believe them. The taste was very creamy! Not at all like what you get in a box at the grocery store. It was superb tasting. There is currently one table with four chairs indoors and several located outside. Need an ice cream fix? This is your go to spot in Nashville.
David Riggleman
I got the Black Raspberry ice cream and enjoyed it. It was very soft and creamy and the portion sizes weren't unreasonable for the price. However, in terms of the specific flavor, it wasn't the best I've had, hence the reason for the loss of one star.
J Halli
It was my first time going to Nashville, IN and I was with my boyfriend when we went. We are both black. We went into the shop and the old man yelled “We are CLOSED”, but there were people eating ice cream in the shop. It was pretty clear that the old man discriminated against us by not allowing us to get ice cream when there were people sitting and walking in and out eating ice cream. Shame on you.
No complaints.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good ice cream, not very friendly. No smiles and we’re given dirty looks when we walked in.
Service was awful. Owner was rude and the place smells like there’s toxic mould which is in line with the quality of service we received
I had a double: one scoop of butter pecan and one of black raspberry. I would order the butter pecan again; it was creamy good with decent bits of nuts. I did not care for the black raspberry. It reminded me of a red raspberry jelly; it was syrupy sweet. My friend got the same two flavors and disagreed with me on the latter but I'm writing the review!
Pumpkin ice cream was delicious.
The ice cream is home made and delicious. Very pleasant young lady remembered us from our last visit. Very cozy "ice cream shop" setting.
I recently had the pleasure of visiting Nashville, Indiana, a small town located in Brown County. It was a delightfully quaint place, and I especially enjoyed the local ice cream shop. If you ever find yourself in the area, I would highly recommend taking a trip to Nashville and trying the ice cream for yourself. You won't regret it!
No complaints about the food or service, but hard to find it open. We visited on a Sunday afternoon, sign said closed and they cant post hours. While not inherently wrong, there are other places nearby that are more consistent with their hours.
It was my first time going to Nashville, IN and I was with my boyfriend when we went. We are both black. We went into the shop and the old man yelled “We are CLOSED”, but there were people eating ice cream in the shop. It was pretty clear that the old man discriminated against us by not allowing us to get ice cream when there were people sitting and walking in and out eating ice cream. Shame on you.
Best ice cream I have ever tasted!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great service and offered to make any flavor in dairy free as long as I called ahead. Had strawberry in a chocolate coat today. Delicious!
Neat little place to stop in for a treat after walking through downtown Nashville. Lots of flavors to choose from with an old-fashioned feel to it. It wasn't too busy when we were there. Employees were cordial but not overly friendly - pretty sure they were ready for us to make our choice as quickly as possible so they could get back to their break. Not rude, but not a five-star experience either. But the ice cream was really good - definitely will consider stopping back in if the craving hits me next time we're in town.
After we ate lunch elsewhere so we decided on dessert from Fearrin's. I had the regular old plain chocolate and she had the mint chocolate chip. They say their ice cream is home made and I have to believe them. The taste was very creamy! Not at all like what you get in a box at the grocery store. It was superb tasting. There is currently one table with four chairs indoors and several located outside. Need an ice cream fix? This is your go to spot in Nashville.
I got the Black Raspberry ice cream and enjoyed it. It was very soft and creamy and the portion sizes weren't unreasonable for the price. However, in terms of the specific flavor, it wasn't the best I've had, hence the reason for the loss of one star.
It was my first time going to Nashville, IN and I was with my boyfriend when we went. We are both black. We went into the shop and the old man yelled “We are CLOSED”, but there were people eating ice cream in the shop. It was pretty clear that the old man discriminated against us by not allowing us to get ice cream when there were people sitting and walking in and out eating ice cream. Shame on you.