Agave & Rye New Albany

324 E Main St, New Albany
(812) 993-8226

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Sister of the Plain Jane Quesadilla
Birria Grilled Street Tacos
Tortilla Chips \u0026 Queso
Agave & Rye Chopped Salad
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Crispy Brussel Sprouts
Tortilla Chips & Queso
Grilled Birria Burrito
Birria Irish Nachos
Carne Asada Eggroll

Menu

Featured items
The Sugar Daddy of the Plain Jane
Melted Aged White Cheddar between grilled Flour Tortilla and Consommé-Dipped CornTortilla, Seasoned Ground Beef, Queso, Lettuce, Sour Cream, Salsa, White Cheddar
Birria Street Tacos(3)
Slow-Braised Beef with Guajillo Chilies, Oaxaca Cheese, Cilantro, Onion, Dipping Consommé(3 tacos included with each order)
(3) Chicken Tacos
Herbed Chicken, Guacamole, Pickled Red Onion, Tinga Sauce
Tres Leches Cake
Caramel, Strawberries
Elote
Cotija Cheese, Serrano Aioli, Tajin, Cilantro, Lime (cut from cob) (v | GF)
The Rooster
Crispy Chicken, Mac N Cheese, Nashville Hot Sauce, Sweet Pickles
Tortilla Chips & Queso
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Queso(V | GF)
Epic Grilled Smash Burger
Two Smashed Burger Patties, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Oaxaca & White Cheddar, Dill Pickles, Tomato, Ketchup, Comeback Sauce, Queso Dipping Sauce
Loaded Tots
House-Made Tots, Sweet & Spicy Bacon,Queso con Chorizo, Aged White Cheddar,Pico, Crispy Carrots, Cowboy Candy, Chilede Arbol.
Birria Grilled Burrito
Large Flour Tortilla filled with Slow-BraisedBeef, Mexican Rice, Oaxaca, Queso, Sweet &Spicy Bacon, Chipotle Crema, Birria DippingSauce
Pollo (3)
Herbed Chicken, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Oaxaca Cheese, Onion, Dipping Consommé(3 tacos included with each order)
Verduras Street Tacos (3)
Shiitake Mushrooms, Fresh Roasted Corn, Julienne Red Peppers & Onions, Oaxaca Cheese, Spicy Chipotle Dipping Sauce (v)(3 tacos included with each order)
The Happy Pappy
Pork Carnitas, Mexican Rice, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Aged White Cheddar, Queso, Guacamole Love Cushion
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Dijon Aioli, Sliced Almonds, Cotija Cheese (V | GF)
Sweet Corn Fritters
Serrano Aioli
The Plain Jane
Seasoned Ground Beef, Shredded Lettuce, Aged White Cheddar, Diced Tomato, Sour Cream (GF)*If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell
The Alderman
Carne Asada Steak, Street Corn Salad, Cotija Cheese, Spicy Chile de Arbol Salsa (GF)*If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell
The Bomb
Carne Asada Steak, Chopped Bourbon- Poached Shrimp, Mac N Cheese, A&R Spicy Chili & BBQ Jam, Tobacco Onions
Vegan Jackfruit and Mushroom Birria Stye Street Tacos (3)
Vegan Jackfruit & Mushroom Birria Style, Vegan Cheese, Onion, Vegan Dipping Consommé
The Swipe Right
Herbed Chicken, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Aged White Cheddar, Salsa, Sour Cream (GF)*If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell

Chips & Dips
Tortilla Chips & Queso
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Queso(V | GF)
EPIC Queso
Epic-Sized House Queso, Tortillas
Tortilla Chips & Guacamole
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Guacamole(V | GF)
Tortilla Chips & Chunky Salsa
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Chunky Salsa(V | GF | VG)
Pick 3
Choose Any 3 of Our House-Made from Scratch Dips
EPIC Queso con Chorizo
Epic-Sized House Queso, CrumbledChorizo, Cilantro, Chunky Salsa, Tortillas
Tortilla Chips & Salsa Roja
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Salsa Roja(V | GF | VG)
EPIC Layered Queso
Epic-Sized House Queso, Refried Beans, Guacamole, White Cheddar, Pico, Sweet & Spicy Bacon
EPIC Queso Birria
Epic-Sized House Queso, Braised Birria, Cilantro, Chunky Salsa, Tortillas
Tortilla Chips & Carolina Reaper Salsa
HOTT!House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Carolina Reaper Salsa(V | GF | VG)

Big Munchies
Shrimp Rangoon
Diced Shrimp, Cheese & Cowboy Candy Filling, Sweet Chili Sauce
Birria Irish Nachos
Slow Roasted Birria (beef), Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Queso, Oaxaca Cheese, Crispy French Fries, Cowboy Candy, Tobacco Onions
Loaded Tots
House-Made Tots, Sweet & Spicy Bacon,Queso con Chorizo, Aged White Cheddar,Pico, Crispy Carrots, Cowboy Candy, Chilede Arbol.
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Dijon Aioli, Sliced Almonds, Cotija Cheese (V | GF)
Mac and Cheese Beignets
Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Habanero MapleDipping Sauce
Sticky Cauliflower Bites
Sesame & Ginger Sauce, Crispy Wontons, Cilantro (V)
Sister of the Plain Jane Quesadilla
Large Flour Tortilla Stuffed with Seasoned Ground Beef, Oaxaca and Pepper Jack Cheeses, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Mac N Cheese, Chipotle Crema. Served with Ranch and Chunky Salsa
Nashville Hot Chicken and Waffle Beignets
Fried Chicken, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, and Mac N Cheese-Filled Beignets. Dipped in Nashville Sauce and Topped with Diced Pickle Relish and Spicy Crispy Carrots. Served with Ranch and Habanero Maple Syrup.

Little Munchies
Elote
Cotija Cheese, Serrano Aioli, Tajin, Cilantro, Lime (cut from cob) (v | GF)
Sweet Corn Fritters
Serrano Aioli
Carne Asada Eggroll
House Carne Asada, A&R Teriyaki Sauce, A&R Spicy Chili & BBQ Jam, Baby Corn, Water Chestnuts, Cilantro, Green Onion, Carrots, Red Bell Pepper, Lo Mein Noodles
House-Made Sea Salt Tater Tots
Served with White BBQ Sauce (v | GF)
Refried Beans
Mac N Cheese
(V)
French Fries
(V | GF)
Mexican Rice
(V | GF | VG)

Epic Tacos
The Plain Jane
Seasoned Ground Beef, Shredded Lettuce, Aged White Cheddar, Diced Tomato, Sour Cream (GF)*If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell
The Sugar Daddy of the Plain Jane
Melted Aged White Cheddar between grilled Flour Tortilla and Consommé-Dipped CornTortilla, Seasoned Ground Beef, Queso, Lettuce, Sour Cream, Salsa, White Cheddar
The Swipe Right
Herbed Chicken, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Aged White Cheddar, Salsa, Sour Cream (GF)*If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell
The Happy Pappy
Pork Carnitas, Mexican Rice, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Aged White Cheddar, Queso, Guacamole Love Cushion
The Filthy Fajita
Carne Asada Steak, Sautéed Mushrooms,Caramelized Onions, Red Peppers, MexicanRice, Chipotle Crema, Queso
The Bomb
Carne Asada Steak, Chopped Bourbon- Poached Shrimp, Mac N Cheese, A&R Spicy Chili & BBQ Jam, Tobacco Onions
The Rooster
Crispy Chicken, Mac N Cheese, Nashville Hot Sauce, Sweet Pickles
The Alderman
Carne Asada Steak, Street Corn Salad, Cotija Cheese, Spicy Chile de Arbol Salsa (GF)*If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell
The Green Goddess
Brussels Sprouts, Roasted Corn, Cilantro Chimichurri, Spicy Crispy Carrots, Hard and Soft Corn Tortillas
The Queen E
Crispy Mahi Mahi, Malt Vinegar French Fries,Chipotle Remoulade, Pickled Red Onion, RadishHabanero Slaw, Guac Love Cushion, Crispy Puffy &Soft Flour Shell
The Love Shack 2
Pork Carnitas, Corn Salad, Agave BBQ Jam, Crispy Tobacco Onions, Refried Bean Love Cushion
The Bang Bang
Crispy Cauliflower, Corn Fritters, Queso, Spicy Crispy Carrots (V)
The Crown Jewel
Butter & Garlic Lobster, Shiitake Mushrooms, Mac N Cheese, Truffle Oil & Shavings, Shaved Green Onions
The Big Thumper
Peppercorn Kangaroo, House Tater Tots, Corn Salad, Brie Fondue, Pickled Red Onion
The Skywalker
Kung Pao Fried Chicken, Lo Mein Mix, Agave BBQ,Creamy Ranch, Spicy Crispy Carrots, Puffy & Soft FlourTortillas
The Gangsta
Slow-Braised Birria Beef, Mexican Rice, Roasted Corn,Queso and White Cheddar, Chipotle Serrano Crema,Cilantro, Tajin Lime
The Rico Suave
Grilled Herbed Chicken, Cowboy Caviar, Sour Cream,Chunky Salsa, Cilantro, Guac Love Cushion

Grilled Street Tacos
Birria Street Tacos(3)
Slow-Braised Beef with Guajillo Chilies, Oaxaca Cheese, Cilantro, Onion, Dipping Consommé(3 tacos included with each order)
Pollo (3)
Herbed Chicken, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Oaxaca Cheese, Onion, Dipping Consommé(3 tacos included with each order)
Vegan Jackfruit and Mushroom Birria Stye Street Tacos (3)
Vegan Jackfruit & Mushroom Birria Style, Vegan Cheese, Onion, Vegan Dipping Consommé
El Camarón Street Tacos (3)
Diced Shrimp Gobernador, Sautéed Poblano & Onion, Tomato, Oaxaca Cheese, Dipping Consommé
Verduras Street Tacos (3)
Shiitake Mushrooms, Fresh Roasted Corn, Julienne Red Peppers & Onions, Oaxaca Cheese, Spicy Chipotle Dipping Sauce (v)(3 tacos included with each order)
Pork Carnitas Street Tacos (3)
Pork Carnitas, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Oaxaca Cheese, Onion, Dipping Consommé

Mamacita's Baby Tacos
(3) Fish Tacos
Chopped Crispy Mahi, Guacamole, ChipotleCrema,
(3) Chicken Tacos
Herbed Chicken, Guacamole, Pickled Red Onion, Tinga Sauce
(3) Carne Asada Tacos
Carne Asada, Pickled Red Onion, Pico, Salsa Roja, Oaxaca Cheese
(3) Chorizo Tacos
Chorizo, Queso, Guacamole, Pickled Red Onion, Crispy Carrots, Salasa Roja
(3) Veggie Tacos
Fried Cauliiflower, Queso, Pickled Red Onion, Pico,Guacamole, Black Beans
(3) Pork Carnitas Tacos
Pork Carnitas, Guacamole, Pickled Red Onion, Salsa Roja, Cotija, Tortilla Strips

Not A Taco
Agave & Rye Chopped Salad
Crispy Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, White Cheddar, Corn, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Black Beans, Peppercorn Buttermilk, A&R Spicy Chili & BBQ Jam, Tobacco Onions
Birria Grilled Burrito
Large Flour Tortilla filled with Slow-BraisedBeef, Mexican Rice, Oaxaca, Queso, Sweet &Spicy Bacon, Chipotle Crema, Birria DippingSauce
Epic Grilled Smash Burger
Two Smashed Burger Patties, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Oaxaca & White Cheddar, Dill Pickles, Tomato, Ketchup, Comeback Sauce, Queso Dipping Sauce
Grilled Brunch Burrito
Ground Chorizo & Seasoned Ground Beef, House-Made Tots, Scrambled Eggs, Oaxaca, Queso, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, White Cheddar. Chile de Arbol, Chorizo Dipping Gravy
Grilled Crispy Chicken Burrito
Chopped Crispy Chicken, Mac N Cheese, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Queso, White Cheddar, Agave BBQ Jam, BBQ Ranch Dipping Sauce

Yum
Tres Leches Cake
Caramel, Strawberries
Funnel Fries
Powdered Cinnamon Sugar, Chocolate Dipping Sauce

Drinks
Diet Coke
*Item may differ than pictured. In most locations we serve fountain drinks in a 16 oz. cup.
Coke
*Item may differ than pictured. In most locations we serve fountain drinks in a 16 oz. cup.
Sprite
*Item may differ than pictured. In most locations we serve fountain drinks in a 16 oz. cup.
Minute Maid Lemonade
*Item may differ than pictured. In most locations we serve fountain drinks in a 16 oz. cup.
Sweet Tea
Iced Tea (Unsweetened)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+50 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+49 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Bayoue Baddie, Crown Jewel, Shrimp Ragoon, and a drink that sent me to a small piece of heaven! The first (bayoue baddie) had alligator, with the best taste you can find! Second was (Crown Jewel) this was just as you'd expect with lobster that changed my mind over any seafood I've ate!! Next, was a shrimp that I devoured in about a minute and a half..! Last a creamsicle drink as mentioned above! Phenomenal job to this restaurant, you guys are amazing and thank you for...
November 2025
Robert at the New Albany location. Was super nice and accommodating. He took care of us from start to finish!! Will definitely be back and would recommend this place to others people forsure!!
November 2025
The food and service was amazing! Such a unique selection of tacos. I got three of the vegetarian options and all were delicious, but would highly recommend The Easy Ranchero. My boyfriend ordered the meat options and would highly recommend The Crown Jewel. The deviled eggs and dips were also great. We really enjoyed the Hot Lips mocktail and could drink it all day. All the staff were amazing and helpful, Robert and Leah were their names if I remember correctly. Hopefully we can...
November 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

OUTCAST fish & oyster bar - 207 E Main St
Seafood, Cocktail Bar
Aladdin's Mediterranean & Middle Eastern Cuisine - 37 Bank St
Middle Eastern, Mediterranean, Vegetarian
Brooklyn and The Butcher - 148 E Market St
Steak House, Seafood, Cocktail Bar, Vegetarian

Agave & Rye New Albany

324 E Main St, New Albany, IN 47150
(812) 993-8226