Brooklyn and The Butcher
148 E Market St, New Albany
(812) 590-2646
Customers' Favorites
Filet Mignon Oscar Style with Baked Potato
Top Sirloin Steak and Baked Potato
Freedom Run Farm Lamb Meatballs
Brooklyn's Whipped Potatoes
Brooklyn's Shrimp Cocktail
Bananas Foster Cheesecake
Nutella Chocolate Cake
Twice Baked Potato
Ahi Tuna Tartare
Charred Octopus
Menu
Photos
+89 photos
+88 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Our waitress was great, service was good. My group said their food was good. For me the temperature on my baked potatoes was like warm. You could tell they warmed it and it sat until the other food was done to serve. Suggestion, when someone orders a baked potatoes and ask to be served with the others, cook it last. But overall loved the atmosphere and would go back.
I was kind of disappointed. This food was not as good as I remember it being last time. My steak was very gristley. Was cooked right med/rare. Then after we were done eating we sat for at least 25-30 minutes unattended. No one checked on us. All of our drinks were empty for a while. It took a while to get our leftovers together and to get the check. I didn't say anything to the server or anyone that works there but I don't think I'll be back.
Very disappointing! Everything was slow-our drinks being ordered, then coming out wrong, then getting our food ordered and then needing to ask how much longer it would be (we had already been there an hour and 15 mins). The salmon dishes were over-cookeed and dry. My steak was chewy and my baked potato was cold. We were there for the $35 Thursday specials but even at that price, it was disappointing.
You May Also Like
Bella Roma - 134 E Market St
![]()
Italian, Vegetarian
MESA, A Live Dining Show - 216 Pearl St
![]()
Personal Chefs, Cooking Classes