Custom Cakes near New Albany, IN

“My husband stopped in on the 23rd, to grab a couple desserts for Christmas. They have so many options, it made it hard to decide which to go with… so we got two. Ultimately, we ended up going with a peanut butter pie, and a raspberry cheesecake. They were both amazing, but the peanut butter pie is some of the best I have EVER had, and we love peanut butter pie. I wasn’t there at the ordering,/pick up, but he said whoever helped him was super nice. Def going to Check them out again soon, and try some other things!“

“Truly the best bakery in Louisville!! Abigail and Griffen are the most personable and fun people, they always cater to your needs and give you the best result! Abigail ran a class for my friends and I and gave us the best experience! Cannot recommend this place enough!!“

“Amazing and delicious bridal cake and cupcakes from Sweets By Millie. I ordered two months ago for my sister Kentucky Derby Themed Bridal Party this past weekend. The online ordering process was easy. My sister loves carrot cake w/ bourbon buttercream and said everything tasted moist. You will not be disappointed by Sweets by Millie. Thanks again!“

“On the recommendations from U of L hospital staff we stopped by here for local donuts and coffee. I couldn't recommend this place more, great donuts and better staff. They appreciate and take care of first responders! Thank y'all so much!“

“Ordered a cake for my daughter’s birthday and it was delicious! Everyone loved it! Cake was moist and not overly sweet. The butter cream was the perfect sweetness too! I will definitely be ordering more cakes in the near future .“

“We had a custom cake made for our daughter’s birthday party, and it literally became the showstopper of the party. Dara matched the icing colors to the invitations we had, and everyone kept complimenting how fancy it looked. Then when we ate it everyone gushed how great it tasted. 11/10 I will definitely be hitting her up for more cakes!“