New Albany Tavern

$ • Beer Bar, Sports Bars, Burgers

About New Albany Tavern

New Albany Tavern provides a great atmosphere with friendly and attentive staff. Guests frequently enjoy the excellent service, especially from bartenders who are knowledgeable about the bourbon and whiskey selections. The restaurant is known for its wonderful food and perfect drinks, making it a popular spot for groups like book clubs. Visitors appreciate the variety of meals, including the Knocker Burger and the "Danfredo," and the chance to try new bourbons, such as True Story. The menu features well-executed pub fare, including the Railroad smoker Mac and cheese. Guests enjoy appetizers like the portobello fries, which are lightly breaded and fried just right. The new location has a cleaner look, with booths on one side and bar stools on the other, plus large doors that open to let in fresh air. There is also upstairs seating for private parties. The Tavern offers table service, which has been positively received, and the service is prompt and helpful. Overall, it is a welcoming place with good food, great drinks, and attentive service that keeps people coming back.

New Albany Tavern Reviews

4.3

60 ratings

75%

10%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about New Albany Tavern

Write a review

February 2026

We had not been since Fall, and the server remembered us!
Consistently quality food and service 😃 2/6/26

October 2025

Came in for lunch to try a new spot and you all knocked it out of the park Wyatt our server/bartender took care of us amazing attention to detail Brad had the club I had the wings everything can out perfect hot fry’s hot wings in both senses of the term
Ordered the tiramisu dessert for my 96 year old grand mother who said it’s like I was in Italy And ate the whole thing in one
Sitting ( this is after her pre prepared meal from the care facility ) ...read full review

Read All Reviews(60)