Hilby’s Bar and Grill
$ • Bars, American, Bar & Grill
Hours:
1718 I Ave, New Castle
(765) 529-9711
About Hilby’s Bar and Grill
Customers' Favorites
Hilby’s Bar and Grill Reviews
Share your opinion about Hilby’s Bar and Grill
Went here with a group of friends and had one of those nights you talk about for years. The food was absolutely top notch — seriously, do not skip the fish sandwich, it was next-level OMG! The vibe was fun, welcoming, and energetic without feeling chaotic. I felt accepted. Karaoke took the night to another level with the competition, and had everyone laughing, singing, and just having a blast. You can tell the staff and owners truly take pride in this place — the service...read full review
Had the absolute BEST burger I’ve had in a looong time! Great atmosphere and really affordable. 100% will be back
Recently took my son to Hilby’s at the stroke of midnight for his 21st birthday. It was a wonderful first experience. The Ladies were wonderful and the atmosphere was great!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 1:30AM |
| Saturday | 12PM - 1:30AM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
People in New Castle Also Viewed
Hilby's Bar and Grill offers a welcoming atmosphere with friendly staff, including the new owner who treats customers like old friends. The food is fresh and delicious, with no need for sauce on the steak. The bar serves reasonably priced drinks, and the music is a mix of classic rock and karaoke. Recently, customers celebrated special occasions like a 21st birthday, enjoying the great atmosphere and an amazing drink menu. The place is kid-friendly, making it suitable for families, and is considered way better than other bars in town. It is known for being clean, having a good vibe, and consistently serving food that never disappoints. The restaurant has undergone updates, including a new grill and fresh paint, making the environment even more inviting. The menu features outstanding food, and the staff go out of their way to accommodate guests of all ages and needs. Special events like Date Nite Wednesdays and 70’s disco night are offered, with the owners happy to assist with reservations and theme ideas. The venue includes karaoke and pool, attracting genuine people without troublemakers. Casual dress is encouraged, and prices are very competitive. Overall, Hilby's provides excellent service and a place to relax without hassles or waiting, making it a top choice for a good time.