Pizza Restaurants near New Paris

1 Old Time Pizza

4.2 Good 111 Reviews

19152 Co Rd 46, New Paris

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food, great people. Definitely stop in & get some great food.”

2 Noble Roman's

68310 IN-15, New Paris

• Delivery

“Not only is this a great place to grab pizza for lunch but you can also order pizza packs for supper. They also offer a great variety of wings and breadsticks for full meal deals. I really enjoy the chicken bacon ranch, a nice twist on a traditional pizza”

3 Venturi

4.6 Superb 153 Reviews

123 E Lincoln Ave, Goshen · 5.76 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“today was our first time going and it was sooooo good! the service was amazing she explained about some of the items, which I appreciated, and uugh it was just so good! Will definitely go back!”

4 Pizza Depot “Millersburg”

4.6 Superb 75 Reviews

104 N Jefferson St, Millersburg · 6.97 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food is 100% amazing. The cleanliness is above and beyond. The staff there are the sweetest people you'll ever meet. The customer service is fast. The prices are reasonable. There always checking on you while dining in. There so amazing. I highly recommend trying There food if you haven't yet. We are regular customers. And as long as there in business. They will continue to get our service. Thank you Pizza Depot of Millersburg. You guys Rock. Thank you for always going above and beyond.”

5 The Fold Goshen

4.4 Superb 126 Reviews

219 S Main St, Goshen · 5.6 miles

“The pizza is great, my favorite is the buffalo chicken bacon ranch or New York White. All of the appetizers are good, but I think the cheesy garlic bread is best. A solid selection of beer that updates occasionally, plus great bartenders like Molly and Spencer who mix excellent drinks. The staff is always friendly and welcoming.”

6 Down Under

4.4 Superb 108 Reviews

801 N Huntington St STE 12, Syracuse · 6.58 miles

• Take-Out

“First time being here in a bout 15 years. Had the French dip and French onion soup, it was very tasty! My girlfriend had the prime rib special and which was also very tasty! Super tender. Such a cool, slick environment. A good cocktail as well. Definitely recommend! We will be back.”

7 Paesello's Pizzeria

4.5 Superb 73 Reviews

1915 Elkhart Rd, Goshen · 6.66 miles

• Take-Out

“I love the Pizza. I love local owned business they always have the best food. The owner is a great guy. The staff is always cordial. Our weekly choice.”

8 Volcano Pizza / Concord Commons

4.4 Superb 90 Reviews

3704 E Mishawaka Rd, Elkhart · 10.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Not bad, pizza was good. I'm just a Lil different. Guess it's the Chicago in me, never been a fan of ground sausage(reason for 3 stars). Will say taste and crust was very good. Meatball Sub was good also. Will I eat here again, Sure.”

9 Momo's Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 91 Reviews

503 South Huntington Street, Syracuse · 7.32 miles

“I do love this pizza . I’ve had it 4 times. Tonight was the only time it was Meh. I only write this because I had family in from out of town. We ordered 2 extra large ones and the pizzas didn’t fill the boxes. They were considerably smaller pizzas and less substantial than the other times we gotten it. The owner wasn’t the one who made it. Maybe better training for those when the owner isn’t there? But I’ve had 3 really great experiences. I know I will again.”

10 Pizza Hut

4.1 Good 83 Reviews

1112 South Huntington Street, Syracuse · 7.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“So we went into Pizza Hut tonight food was good like always but the older guy that was in his thirties wouldn't sell us beer because he didn't have a liquor license I'm pretty sure it's the establishment that has the liquor license and as long as you're over the age of 21 you can sell it. I think someone needs to talk to this employee ( Josh )this isn't the first time we've had this experience. UPDATE!!! JOSH thank you for your great service tonight we gave it another shot and you went above and beyond we will be back!!”

11 Pizza King

3.9 Good 86 Reviews

719 S. Huntington St, IN-13, Syracuse · 7.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had fast & great service !! Pizza was excellent !!!”

12 Elmo's Pizza & Subs

3.9 Good 28 Reviews

1001 W Pike St, Goshen · 6.03 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is my go to spot since I don't cook and I happen to live right down the street. It's always good and if there's any issues they take care of it right away. Great employees and service and always good quality. Way better than your average fast food chain and great prices.”

13 Gerace's Pizzeria

3.8 Good 84 Reviews

Waterford Mills Plaza, 65529 Indiana 15, 65529 IN-15, Goshen · 2.79 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great old school pizzeria! I had a meatball sub and it was delicious. The portion was huge and had just the right amount of cheese and sauce. I will definitely be back for a pizza in the near future. Trust me, try this place you won't be disappointed.”

14 Chubbies Pub And Grub

4.0 Good 166 Reviews

1201 S Huntington St #1934, Syracuse · 7.92 miles

• Take-Out

“I've seen ads for this place in the lake magazines, but only recently did we decide to go and meet some old friends there. It's a bowling alley, not much else to say. The food is decent and the staff are friendly. We don't go bowling much, so all in all, it was fun!”

15 Pizza Hut

3.6 Good 48 Reviews

103 Concord Mall Dr, Elkhart · 10.81 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I drove 36 miles to get a Pizza Hut pizza and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had in my entire life it was really crowded, which I didn’t really like and no one was wearing a mask, but the waiter was attractive and she’s watching me. Write this review right now”

16 Papa Johns Pizza

3.6 Good 78 Reviews

301 N Main St, Goshen · 5.95 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Went in this last Friday to get my pickup order I had called in. Soon as I walked In I seen a guy with tattoos all over his arms wipe BBQ off a ready to bake pizza with no gloves on… then licked his two fingers, the one finger went all the way in his mouth, and licked another part of his hand, the dug his hand into the meat and continued making coustomers pizzas. Disgusting! Absolutely disgusting… not a single person at this place had a pair of gloves on… sad…sad…sad… this was the Goshen location by the way right down town ..310 north Main Street.”

17 Papa Johns Pizza

3.2 Average 32 Reviews

4024 Elkhart Rd, Goshen · 8.85 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I’ve only had a few minor issues here, NEVER gotten sick from their food but have gotten the wrong crust a few times. The staff seems extremely nice every time I am in there except for one lady who I believe is a manager. She is always rude and gets mad if you don’t tip on a pick up order. (Older lady with dark short hair) Very unprofessional I don’t see how she is a manager at all I guarantee people quit because of her. I would give five starts if I didn’t have TWO encounters with her that were both unpleasant but other than that everyone else is amazing. The food is good.”

18 Little Caesars Pizza

3.3 Good 57 Reviews

4568 Elkhart Rd, Elkhart · 9.52 miles

• Delivery

“yes I do and so is my fiance marty's bishop and Loretta Penney. 4-8-20. it's pizza and servings too. seriously.”

19 Massimo's Pizzeria

3.1 Average 71 Reviews

1003 N Main St, Goshen · 6.59 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Massimo's is a little hole in the wall pizza joint that makes the best pizzas I've ever had, hands down. I only visit Goshen once a year for an annual event, but I make it a point to get pizza here every visit. Outstanding quality.”

20 Little Caesars Pizza

3.1 Average 104 Reviews

720 Lincolnway E, Goshen · 5.12 miles

• Delivery

“I have been coming to this location for a little over a year now. The manager here is great and she makes sure she takes care of the customers. My orders are always correct and my food is fresh. I recommend giving this place a try. Great staff and great food. Will continue to frequent the location!”