9 Best Ice Cream Shops near North Webster

Sheila's Sweet Treats & Diner Ice Cream Shop • $
511 S Main St, North Webster

“We have lived in the area for about 3 months and this was out first time here for breakfast. The food was wonderful, the service was like being in a family place and the prices were even better. We will be making this top of our places for breakfast!“

4.3 Superb32 Reviews
Ritter's Frozen Custard Warsaw Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
3845 Lake City Hwy, Warsaw - 8.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brownie Sundae
Banana Split
Turtle Sundae
Glaciers

“I used to work here so i know the staff prioritizes cleanliness and food safety guidelines. Awesome treats. Had to quit because i was taking full advantage of custard on my break and probably almost got diabetes. Your dog can get a "pup cup" (vanilla with a dog treat) so its very dog friendly. Maybe cat friendly too if you into that.I recommend doing oreo and marshmallow glacier.Great place for puppy dog and kids.“

4.6 Superb35 Reviews
La Michoacana Ice Cream - Ligonier Ice Cream Shop • $$
113 S Cavin St, Ligonier - 11.2 miles

“Amazing service paired with amazing house-made ice cream! We had four flavors between us and they were all delicious, rich and creamy and thick. The value for cost was amazing, about two dollars a 'scoop'—those two dollars earned a generous and genuinely delicious dish!“

4.6 Superb20 Reviews
Tippy Dance Hall Ice Cream •
293 EMS T25 Ln, Leesburg - 4.12 miles
4.7 Superb12 Reviews
Joe's Ice Cream Supreme Shop Ice Cream Shop • $
1201 S Huntington St, Syracuse - 6.16 miles

“Joe's is a staple for summertime in Syracuse / Lake Wawasee. They source their hand dipped ice cream from a great spot - it's always tasty.They have razzles, which are equivalent to Blizzards or McFlurries, and you can pretty much customize them to your liking. We appreciated them taking our unique combo requests this weekend.The high school aged kids that typically serve you are always well trained and quick at their work.Usually a long line between 8-9pm on a holiday weekend.“

4.3 Superb32 Reviews
Flavor Freeze of Warsaw Ice Cream Shop •
2950 Frontage Rd, Warsaw - 8.61 miles

“I say if you haven't tried this place you should try it man they're great. Not only do they have homemade ice cream but the prices are right the people are great and I just love the shakes and they give you a straw big enough to suck everything through. I think everybody should try this because if you do that custard place up the roads going to have a bad bad time keeping up“

4.3 Superb10 Reviews
Social Ice Cream and Sandwich Shop Ice Cream Shop • $
904 Park Ave, Winona Lake - 9.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Social Ice Cream Menu

“This place is outstanding. The Ice Cream was great. This was the first time I have come here since it has become Social.The team here is so nice and really helpful.I have not had any of the sandwiches, but I have heard they are great as well.“

4 Good48 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Fast Food • $
700 S Huntington St, Syracuse - 6.74 miles

“Hannah is a very special girl at the Syracuse DQ store.I had forgotten to order a birthday cake and unfortunately DQ does not deliver. But Hannah went above and beyond and helped me get on door dash and order a birthday cake to be delivered. Door dash doesn't allow for special occasion writing to be put on cakes, but Hannah, AGAIN, wrote down a special message to place on the cake. GO HANNAH!!!!!!!!!!!“

3.7 Good34 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
852 Parker St, Warsaw - 8.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Very Skinny Hamburger the Booger as Thin as the C Heese
Butter Burger Cheeseburger Selling How Flat It Is
North Atlantic Cod Filet Sandwich w Cheese Curds
Spicy Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Bacon Deluxe Butter Burger
Strawberry Fields Salad
North Atlanec Cod Fit
Crispy Fish Sandwich
Butter Cheeseburger
Ice Cream Sundaes

“The cod was from God. My Lenten observance brought me here to Warsaw, Indiana, but my experience was hardly penitential. The service was as cordial as the curds were crispy. The aesthetic of this Culver’s blended tile and carpet, brick and drywall, friendship with fascination. Was I in the middle of Indiana, or Cape cod? My group of eight was well satiated and now prepared for the next leg of our voyage toward Ohio. Thank you Culver for being the lighthouse of hope in my tempest of hunger.“

3.7 Good88 Reviews

North Webster’s Other Flavors