9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Rensselaer

“Great Pizza! loaded toppings and perfect sauce.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“loved the pizza by far the best I've had from a small tiwn“

“Very nice place and super cozy! Wood fired pizza was amazing.“

“Don't know about the pizza. Saw the sign for fresh fried chicken and stopped on the way to Valparaiso. Everyone was super helpful. Chicken was fried while I waited, so it was extreemly hot and had to wait for it to cool down. 3 pieces with 2 big fried potato wedges for under $7 is a pretty good deal to me!“

“Went in for dine in and my total was 77.96 paid 60 cash then paid 17.96 on my card today I get email stated that they changed my total so called and there were 3 charges made and also to mention they left there self a tip without my knowledge!!! Pizza was disgusting also wings weren't cooked and pop tasted like soap myself and my family were throwing up and had diarrhea!! When i called store about the change in my total he said "doordash did it" we dined in so door dash couldnt have charged me then he continued with lie and accuses after lie and accuses! Then hung up on me!!“

“Hands down the best pizza in town, and Beth and her staff are some of the friendliest and kindest folks around! Highly recommend! 5 stars! Delicious food and wonderful people!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“First the good: beautiful fireplace and dining area. A wedding was going on which seemed to distract everyone but overall the place is beautiful and it has a separate banquet room for special occasions like the wedding!
The food is pretty expensive at least for the steaks. Everything else seems moderate but there was a lot of a la carte and add ons as well. It was easy to be $50 or more per person!
The food was delicious and cooked to order.“