42 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cedar Lake

“I have ordered Rosati's pizza delivery many times. Delivery was excellent however our pizza tonight was definitely not up to the regular standards. The crust was soggy, it was light on sauce, and could have cooked a few minutes more. I will continue to order Rosati pizza as I feel it is the best in the area. Maybe just a difficult night for the cook.“

“Best pizza around! You've gotta try the thin crust pizza! Bacon bits and cheese, I know it sounds plain, but it's anything but that with their sweet sauce!❤️“

“The owners/employees.. Sooo Friendly! This alone makes me want to go back. The sauce in that pizza puff VERY GOOD! The sandwich was more like 15 inches long instead of 12 inches. The food comes on a cardboard pizza circle and in a pizza bag The way it's supposed to be! Thanks!“

“Excellent food. However ordered today. Portions have changed. Don’t do that. Up the price instead. Still a fan.“

“I was greeted politely and professionally, the pizza was cooked to perfection, the bread sticks were absolutely cooked perfect, and then I was also offered the new cheesey bread sticks with one of each of the sauces for the birthday celebration and those need to absolutely be a permanent fixture on the menu. The staff is the bomb at St John.“

“We love this place! The food is always hit and delicious and the servers are always friendly!“

“Best pizza EVER! The new owners are the best and really care about the quality! They have the GOOD CHEESE! Go get ya some!“

“Pizza was delicious, they have crumbled sausage! Outdoor dining, was pretty full. servers did a good job covering everyone.“

“I just had the most delicious dinner. I was treating myself for my upcoming birthday with some Rosati's. I ordered a thin crust pizza with grilled chicken, tomato and spinach. It was absolutely amazing. For my birthday, they sent me an email for a free dessert so I picked out these delicious cinnamon dough nuggets (I don't remember what they're called) which are kind of like elephant ears but a smaller version and it came with delicious cinnamon roll type frosting to dip them in. Talk about scrumptious. I am in absolute heaven after eating. Didn't eat all of it, of course, although I wish I could have eaten it all at once. It was that good.
Thanks Rosati's for an excellent dinner. ?“

“Great mushroom white pizza!“

“Pizza Cellar is amazing!!!! What a hidden treasure in Crown Point. Their pizza has high quality ingredients and was not greasy. I ordered the thin crust and a deep dish. They both had generous toppings and the crust was great. 10/10 recommend!“

“Antipasto salad was plentiful and delicious at$11.99. We split that before sharing a small Meat Mania thin crust pizza.
Sausage meatball bacon pepperoni.
Sandy liked it but it bacon was a little overwhelming for me , probably go with the sausage and onion thin crust next time .

Parking: Plenty of parking and lots of handicap spots as well.“

“Always great pizza and delivery time today was faster then expected“

“My son and I love this place. Our server Katrina is wonderful - She even ran our leftover pizza out to my car after I left it on the table in a to go box- She's a real cutie too ;)“

“We had the most delicious cauliflower crust pizza tonight! It is our weekly treat for eating healthy and boy did Faustino's come through! A big thanks to Lori and her team for making such a fantastic dinner for us tonight! We highly recommend Faustino's...hands down...AWESOME!“

“Sanfratello's is a culinary gem that exceeds expectations in every way. The diverse menu offers a delightful journey through Italian flavors, catering to both traditional and adventurous palates. Each dish is crafted with care, using fresh, high-quality ingredients that burst with flavor. The attentive staff adds to the warm and inviting atmosphere, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Even when the meal comes to an end, Sanfratello's dedication to excellence shines through. Their thoughtful approach to packaging leftovers in heat-resistant containers ensures that the culinary journey continues even after you leave the restaurant.“

“We had a wedding rehearsal dinner here tonight for almost 50 people. I could not have asked for a better experience. Everyone attending was from out of town and they all raved about the food. The staff was wonderful, and the service was great. But the food stole the show. So much great food and everything was delicious. And there was so much food. I would highly recommend you call and use them if you need a place for an event. Or just call and get their great food to take home. If I could give them 10 stars I would.“

“ordered route 2 pizza last night for dinner. Got a medium cheese pizza(kids), a medium sausage and spinach pizza, and two steak tacos, on corn, with cilantro, onions and cheese. I have got to compliment their AMAZING tacos. They were huge and the steak was so tender. I usually don't get steak out because i always get steak too tough or not enough flavor. This place is a pizza place but man their tacos are my favorite now. And the pizza, just as amazing with the right amount of toppings and didn't skimp on the cheese. I wanted to leave a review as I'm reheating my pizza in my air fryer right now, which comes out just as amazing as yesterday. Thanks route 2! My family really enjoyed dinner last night!“

“Always love stopping here for my pizza set ups. Easy to make great pizzas at home for a fraction of what ordering out costs. Friendly people work here to help you out! Never disappointing.“

“GREAT pizza...period! Simple decor, nice people and service. One of Chicagoland areas best pizza carry out.“

“you hungry for real great food, that's cool, me too, you should go here!!! you're welcome. staff is really nice as well.“

“The porter my partner had was quite good, but my Santa's Boot was only okay. I enjoyed my fried chicken sandwich quite a bit and the additional spice dusting on the bun added just the right amount of heat. Her chicken stromboli was very good, enough for leftovers later that evening. Second time we've been here and we'll likely come back.

Parking: It's almost easier to get here coming off of I-65 as opposed to coming off of US 30.

Kid-friendliness: Kids are restricted after 9 pm per a notice on the door.

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair entry should not be a problem and the tables are spaced enough for good access.“

“My husband and I have been ordering from Doreen’s pizza for 14+ years. We’ve ALWAYS gotten the perfect pizza! Super delicious!“

“First, the service was very good. The bartender was quick to pick up on whether we wanted a drink or we wanted a menu. The food was great, as always. I have to eat something when I come in here. I just can't pass it up.

Parking: There is a lot of parking, but you may have to walk.“

“The manager that was on duty wish I would have got his name. Was excellent, he was doing everything he could to make sure that place ran smooth. He was working everything. I could tell he didn't have the greatest staff around him, so he was trying to pick up where most of them were lacking. If it wasn't for him running that place it would be failing I know for sure. So if he's not the owner that man deserves the world when it comes to that store.“

“This place is going downhill fast. I emailed Aurelios in Schererville about an experience 3 wks ago they NEVER got back to me.... we take my mom here every time we visit her. We've had issues yesterday 5.12.24 and the time before as well. I complained about getting the cookie my mom loves because it was brought to the table and was entirely melted ice cream and whip cream so melted you could pour it like water. Yesterday the pizza was entirely burnt and so hard . If they do something wrong and you complain about it believe you will pay for it if you return. This was our pizza yesterday that we asked them to cut in squares. Happy Mother's day to us.“

“Pizza here is definitely tasty. A little doughy so it’s not the typical thin crust tavern style you find at a lot of small shops.

It’s inside a gas station. Order in person or over the phone. Pay at the gas station cashier. Bring back your receipt to the pizza counter to grab your pizza.

It was fast and friendly service. Clean and smells amazing inside.

I got the beef and onion along with a specialty pizza, the taco pizza.

I enjoyed the taco pizza. Very tasty except it’s a hard one to warm up the next day due to the lettuce and tomato.

The beef and onion was decent. It doesn’t have a strong flavor. Just enough to make you wanting more. Again, lots of dough so it fills you up quickly.“

“Do you know who the owner is? Then I may say no more. Nothin but LOVE“

“I've been a long time fan dating back to when they were in Calumet city. I've used them for catering several times with great success. always enjoy stopping in to grab something to eat as well. I do miss the bone-in pork chop sandwich but I can understand how selling that might be a bit of a liability. LOL all in all, the place never disappoints“

“We ordered 2 Fiesta size sausage pizzas(one with green peppers and one with onions) and they were absolutely delicious! I called to place the order for pickup and the young lady on the phone was such a pleasure to talk to! We live in Valpo and usually order from the Aurelios in Crown Point because the one in Valpo is less than good. You guys at the Winfield Aurelios are fantastic and you will be our new go to pizza place! Thanks for making our day(8/4/24)!!!“

“I have not had Aurelio’s pizza in a long time and was hoping for the same taste I remember. While the toppings tasted great, the crust was just not the same as I remembered. I was a little disappointed. I did try the wings and they were actually really tasty.“

“Never received my order... when I called the store to ask about my refund... the manager who came to the phone was very rude and disrespectful, told me I was not getting a refund and hung up on me...I am NOT going to let this go...I will be contacting your Corporate office and Never ordering from THIS establishment EVER again... I just want my money back. SN...THIS WILL NOT BE OVER UNTIL I GET MY REFUND“

“A group of us came here for the first time tonight and will definitely be back. Our server Brent did a great job with our party, our food was great and my espresso martini was amazing!“

“Came in and the place was completely empty, sign said "seat yourselves" it felt kind of awkward but someone came out to greet us a few seconds later. Staff was super friendly and nice! I brought my grandmother and she wanted to split her meal with someone who wasn't able to come to the restaurant in person, so they brought out half of her meal and waited until we were almost done with the other half freshly made and packaged! Lake perch was great! Not like other restaurants that try to serve ocean perch as lake perch. The Nashville hot chicken strips were a little disappointing they didn't have any heat to them, but the chicken was cooked perfectly and the breading was really good so it made up for it! Mac n cheese was delicious, I was even impressed with the fries! None of them were soggy or over salted! I'm sad I couldn't have tried them sooner!“

“Never had a bad dish at Livios til tonight. We each had fried perch, the waitress commented how big it was. I ate one piece and couldn’t eat anymore. Had a funny taste to it. Hope we don’t get sick!“

“I use to order Italian Fiesta, once I had Rosati’s….. OH MY GOODNESS!!!!! THEIR PIZZA IS BY FAR THE BEST!! It’s not greasy, you have a lot of flavor & ITS AFFORDABLE! They’re about 1mile from my house so I pick up or get delivery! I AM HOOKED!!! CUSTOMER FOR LIFE!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“Always a great time and great food and environment.“

“Good pizza. Sauce is sweet but not too sweet (i don’t like super sweet pizza sauce. The bread crust had a different texture than most other pizzas. kinda like a overly heated flour tortilla. Still was good pizza and was cheaper than other gourmet pizza spots. Only 15-20 minute wait for 2 large pizzas. Staff was nice and cashier girl was hot“

“An intimate setting for size. I will say their menu is extensive. You could bring a diverse group here and most would find something they wanted to eat. The pizza I had was ok, I have a feeling it would have been better on a larger sized crust. The fettuccine was good enough I suppose but the Alfredo sauce was sweet which wasn't quite my thing. If I could have done it over again I would have ordered something different. The staff was wonderful which I feel like was really the best part of the experience. If you are looking for a location to eat and don't want to get tied into a set menu this place could help you out in a pinch.

Parking: Plenty of parking for the space.“

“Since moving here, I've tried 3 other pizza places.. they were ok...
And today I tried this for the 1st time and it was the Best so far! I feel like the owners might be from Chicago because this was Chicago pizza 🍕 😍🍕😍“

“Best Pizza In The Region! Friendly Staff!“

“I love the pepperoni pizza here! You get a giant slice ? for a reasonable price. You can tell the owner takes pride in his food. A couple bread sticks & marinara sauce go well with it too! In my opinion, this pizza is better than a lot of the other pizza places in NWI.“