13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Crown Point

“Call it Dante’s, call it Gators. This place is a legacy to the area. The bartenders are experienced and their personalities are the best! Shout out to Cheryle and Wade. From the chicken family pack to the pizza, Gators food is excellent as well. If a band is playing on the weekend, this place will be busy and you are sure to have a fun time. 😁“

“We love this place! The food is always hit and delicious and the servers are always friendly!“

“Great food! Great atmosphere! Great owner! Would definitely return“

“Why a $2 transaction fee on a prepaid travel card? Did not question it. Just took it off the tip. Our waitress was lucky to get what she got. I understand juggling multiple tables is part of the job but you shouldn't have to ask for a to-go box AND bill on more than one occasion as she goes back n forth by our table waiting on other customers. The food was hot and delicious. The beer tap might need a cleaning. Love the marinara sauce and the taste of the Italian sausage on the pizza but way too much cheese. So much cheese like they had extra and just plopped it in the middle of the pie. The thin crust on the pizza was a 10/10. Perfect thin crust.
Our dinner consisted of a meatball sub (12.59), mountain dew (2.99), 14 inch thin crust pizza with Italian sausage, mushrooms and green peppers (25.09) and a 23 ounce craft brew (8.00) for a total of 48.67. There was 3.41 tax and a 2.08 transaction fee. We tipped $8.00 (15%). We left satisfied and full. Food was well prepared.“

“Pizza Cellar is amazing!!!! What a hidden treasure in Crown Point. Their pizza has high quality ingredients and was not greasy. I ordered the thin crust and a deep dish. They both had generous toppings and the crust was great. 10/10 recommend!“

“My son and I love this place. Our server Katrina is wonderful - She even ran our leftover pizza out to my car after I left it on the table in a to go box- She's a real cutie too ;)“

“Delicious pizza, wonderful owner! One of the best pizza sauces I’ve had. If you live in the area or are traveling through, I definitely recommend you stop here.“

“We finally went to S & T and bought the 12 inch thin crust sausage pizza set up. 3 pizzas for $26! We made one last night and added green pepper and pepperoni it was delicious!! I assembled the other two and they are ready to go in the freezer for next time. What a great concept and savings on take out. Highly recommend!“

“My whole family loves this place. The food is always amazing and customer service is friendly and helpful“

“Excellent food and craft beers. They don't know how to handle large groups and splitting bills unfortunately. Never seen a place that doesn't easily allow each family to pay individually, so creates a large unnecessary headache when paying. Servers were good. The venue and food is very good. Just their inability to handle payments puts a complication on the night.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Took a night vacation fom Illinois and ordered delivery to Hilton Garden Inn Merrillville and the pizza came HOT AND FRESH😍 like it was fresh from the oven! Delivery was fast and delivery driver was so sweet! Great pizza!! So glad to have an Aurelio's in Crown Point!!“

“Dear Aurelio's Staff,

I am writing to express my sincere gratitude for the exceptional service we received during my husband's surprise 60th birthday party at your Winfield location. From the initial planning stages to the final touches on the decorations, your team was incredibly accommodating and helpful, going above and beyond to ensure everything ran smoothly. The level of personalized attention was truly remarkable.

The party was a resounding success, largely thanks to your dedication. The food was absolutely delicious – a delightful array of options that catered to all tastes. The breadsticks were perfectly crisp, the salad refreshing, and the Mostaccioli was a particular hit. The pizza, roast beef, and the carefully curated selection of beer, wine, and soft drinks completed a truly superb spread. I was especially impressed that you were able to accommodate my request for my husband's favorite beer, even though it's not typically on your menu – that extra effort truly made a difference.

Having 50 guests and managing to stay under $20 per person was a pleasant surprise and a testament to your efficient and cost-effective catering services. More importantly, the party was a memorable and joyous occasion, exceeding all expectations. My husband had the best birthday celebration he’s ever experienced, and for that, I am eternally grateful.

Thank you again for your outstanding service and for helping to create such a wonderful and unforgettable event.

Sincerely, Victoria“