Pizza was delicious! Big fan of the thinner style crust! Breadsticks and cheese were great as well. The ice cream can’t be beat!
Megan Gaddis
So far, I've had a smash burger, tried their chicken filet pizza, and some salted caramel ice cream at Fat Santa's and they were all VERY good! I will definitely be back to try more of their menu!
Josh Houchin
Soggy bun feels like it got soaked in grease than there was a hair on the top of the bun
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Madeline Meadows
I decided to try Fat Santa's since the menu changes and recent new ownership. So far, I've tried the veggie pizza, cheesy bread, and cheese curds. All of it was well made and very tasty. I was impressed with the veggie pizza and would die for the cheesy bread. I recommend it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MetalMama Michele
Pizza is delicious! Love the sauce and crust.
Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Burnette
My son and I went and tried out the place since the new owner, Kyle took over! The food, cleanliness, server, vibe everything was great! Kyle was so sweet and he’ll do great things here!
Ward Hessig
This review is for Fat Santa’s Pizza & More under the new ownership. Like many others, I had sworn I would never go back after my past experiences with the previous owners — it was honestly awful, and I couldn’t find a nice thing to say about it back then. That has completely changed. I can’t say enough good things now, and the new ownership clearly figured it out and deserves the recognition.
I placed an online order and paid online, which was simple and easy. I built my own pizza and added several customizations, like heavy sauce and a couple others. I also ordered two different Strombolis — a chicken parm Stromboli and a regular Stromboli — and customized both of those as well with things like heavy mushrooms, light peppers, and extra sauce...etc. partly to see if I’d actually get what I ordered.
To my pleasant surprise, everything was done exactly right. They are definitely not stingy with the toppings. The pizza and sandwiches were ready right on time, the customizations were perfect, and everything was hot and delicious — which is a huge turnaround from before, when the food was almost inedible.
I can’t really speak to the atmosphere since I only went in to pick up the order, but I was greeted by a friendly staff member, and the pickup experience was smooth. Honestly, I can’t say anything bad at all. The food was delicious, the portion sizes were great, and EVERYTHING was fantastic, not good...great.
The only tiny caveat — and this is purely personal preference — is that I usually prefer a thicker crust pizza. Their style is thin crust, but for me to say a thin-crust pizza was delicious really says something… and it absolutely was.
If anyone has been hesitant to go back, I highly recommend giving Fat Santa’s another try. It really feels like they’ve turned things around, and it’s nice to have them here in Santa Claus. Good job new owners.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ward Hessig
This review is for Fat Santa’s Pizza & More under the new ownership. Like many others, I had sworn I would never go back after my past experiences with the previous owners — it was honestly awful, and I couldn’t find a nice thing to say about it back then. That has completely changed. I can’t say enough good things now, and the new ownership clearly figured it out and deserves the recognition.
I placed an online order and paid online, which was simple and easy. I built my own pizza and added several customizations, like heavy sauce and a couple others. I also ordered two different Strombolis — a chicken parm Stromboli and a regular Stromboli — and customized both of those as well with things like heavy mushrooms, light peppers, and extra sauce...etc. partly to see if I’d actually get what I ordered.
To my pleasant surprise, everything was done exactly right. They are definitely not stingy with the toppings. The pizza and sandwiches were ready right on time, the customizations were perfect, and everything was hot and delicious — which is a huge turnaround from before, when the food was almost inedible.
I can’t really speak to the atmosphere since I only went in to pick up the order, but I was greeted by a friendly staff member, and the pickup experience was smooth. Honestly, I can’t say anything bad at all. The food was delicious, the portion sizes were great, and EVERYTHING was fantastic, not good...great.
The only tiny caveat — and this is purely personal preference — is that I usually prefer a thicker crust pizza. Their style is thin crust, but for me to say a thin-crust pizza was delicious really says something… and it absolutely was.
If anyone has been hesitant to go back, I highly recommend giving Fat Santa’s another try. It really feels like they’ve turned things around, and it’s nice to have them here in Santa Claus. Good job new owners.
Dan Huddleston
Got pizza for pick-up, new to the areas, had family down and ordered 3 large with multiple toppings. Pizza was really good and price was phenomenal. We will be back. Thank you!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Clint Allbright
We ordered four drinks a 12” Santa Supreme pizza a 12” Stromboli Pizza, 6 piece breadsticks and for the boys a bacon smash cheeseburger and a double smash cheeseburger. The boys ate their burgers but did complain they were not that great. The pizzas were subpar at best. There was no flavor with any of the toppings and was definitely not worth the $81.18 we paid. I definitely will not recommend this place to anyone I know. I will also add that the staff is rather lazy.
We stopped here last night with our small children for dinner. Waited an hour, they had misplaced our food and packaged it instead of bringing it to the table. Both pizzas were wrong, and the mini corndogs were ice cold. We didn’t wait for our food to be remade, we asked for a refund and left. Highly disappointing.
Angela Chapman
My family had wonderful service. Friendly and helpful. The pizza was hot with great mozzerella cheese. Very pleasant place. Will return again.
Pizza was delicious! Big fan of the thinner style crust! Breadsticks and cheese were great as well. The ice cream can’t be beat!
So far, I've had a smash burger, tried their chicken filet pizza, and some salted caramel ice cream at Fat Santa's and they were all VERY good! I will definitely be back to try more of their menu!
Soggy bun feels like it got soaked in grease than there was a hair on the top of the bun
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
I decided to try Fat Santa's since the menu changes and recent new ownership. So far, I've tried the veggie pizza, cheesy bread, and cheese curds. All of it was well made and very tasty. I was impressed with the veggie pizza and would die for the cheesy bread. I recommend it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is delicious!
Love the sauce and crust.
Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My son and I went and tried out the place since the new owner, Kyle took over! The food, cleanliness, server, vibe everything was great! Kyle was so sweet and he’ll do great things here!
This review is for Fat Santa’s Pizza & More under the new ownership. Like many others, I had sworn I would never go back after my past experiences with the previous owners — it was honestly awful, and I couldn’t find a nice thing to say about it back then. That has completely changed. I can’t say enough good things now, and the new ownership clearly figured it out and deserves the recognition.
I placed an online order and paid online, which was simple and easy. I built my own pizza and added several customizations, like heavy sauce and a couple others. I also ordered two different Strombolis — a chicken parm Stromboli and a regular Stromboli — and customized both of those as well with things like heavy mushrooms, light peppers, and extra sauce...etc. partly to see if I’d actually get what I ordered.
To my pleasant surprise, everything was done exactly right. They are definitely not stingy with the toppings. The pizza and sandwiches were ready right on time, the customizations were perfect, and everything was hot and delicious — which is a huge turnaround from before, when the food was almost inedible.
I can’t really speak to the atmosphere since I only went in to pick up the order, but I was greeted by a friendly staff member, and the pickup experience was smooth. Honestly, I can’t say anything bad at all. The food was delicious, the portion sizes were great, and EVERYTHING was fantastic, not good...great.
The only tiny caveat — and this is purely personal preference — is that I usually prefer a thicker crust pizza. Their style is thin crust, but for me to say a thin-crust pizza was delicious really says something… and it absolutely was.
If anyone has been hesitant to go back, I highly recommend giving Fat Santa’s another try. It really feels like they’ve turned things around, and it’s nice to have them here in Santa Claus. Good job new owners.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This review is for Fat Santa’s Pizza & More under the new ownership. Like many others, I had sworn I would never go back after my past experiences with the previous owners — it was honestly awful, and I couldn’t find a nice thing to say about it back then. That has completely changed. I can’t say enough good things now, and the new ownership clearly figured it out and deserves the recognition. I placed an online order and paid online, which was simple and easy. I built my own pizza and added several customizations, like heavy sauce and a couple others. I also ordered two different Strombolis — a chicken parm Stromboli and a regular Stromboli — and customized both of those as well with things like heavy mushrooms, light peppers, and extra sauce...etc. partly to see if I’d actually get what I ordered. To my pleasant surprise, everything was done exactly right. They are definitely not stingy with the toppings. The pizza and sandwiches were ready right on time, the customizations were perfect, and everything was hot and delicious — which is a huge turnaround from before, when the food was almost inedible. I can’t really speak to the atmosphere since I only went in to pick up the order, but I was greeted by a friendly staff member, and the pickup experience was smooth. Honestly, I can’t say anything bad at all. The food was delicious, the portion sizes were great, and EVERYTHING was fantastic, not good...great. The only tiny caveat — and this is purely personal preference — is that I usually prefer a thicker crust pizza. Their style is thin crust, but for me to say a thin-crust pizza was delicious really says something… and it absolutely was. If anyone has been hesitant to go back, I highly recommend giving Fat Santa’s another try. It really feels like they’ve turned things around, and it’s nice to have them here in Santa Claus. Good job new owners.
Got pizza for pick-up, new to the areas, had family down and ordered 3 large with multiple toppings. Pizza was really good and price was phenomenal. We will be back. Thank you!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered four drinks a 12” Santa Supreme pizza a 12” Stromboli Pizza, 6 piece breadsticks and for the boys a bacon smash cheeseburger and a double smash cheeseburger. The boys ate their burgers but did complain they were not that great. The pizzas were subpar at best. There was no flavor with any of the toppings and was definitely not worth the $81.18 we paid. I definitely will not recommend this place to anyone I know. I will also add that the staff is rather lazy.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Great spot for lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Stromboli and pizza. Glad we stopped in!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
We stopped here last night with our small children for dinner. Waited an hour, they had misplaced our food and packaged it instead of bringing it to the table. Both pizzas were wrong, and the mini corndogs were ice cold. We didn’t wait for our food to be remade, we asked for a refund and left. Highly disappointing.
My family had wonderful service. Friendly and helpful. The pizza was hot with great mozzerella cheese. Very pleasant place. Will return again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Too long just for a burger 20-30 min rate
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Loading...