Dairy Belle Ice Cream Store - Schererville

Dairy Belle is one of the best hometown ice cream shops in NWI.

Will forever now share a special connection to this place. Thank you for bringing people together by sharing a little joy.

Great soft serve and specialty ice cream options

I love Dairy Belle with all my heart. It deserves 5 stars. It’s my favorite ice cream place in the world! HOWEVER, there is one employee AT THE SCHERERVILLE LOCATION who is consistently rude every time we deal with her. She has been working there for maybe two years, has glasses, tattoos and piercings and is older than the other employees there. She is short with you, gets annoyed if you stray from anything that’s not simple (customizations, multiple toppings, etc.) we get scared that we’re gonna get her every time we come and have to mentally prepare ourselves for rudeness. She also called my dog fat one time! She practically throws your items at you. She was working Sunday 7/27/25 8:30pm. Love dairy belle, but they got to work on employee attitudes, or I guess just this employees attitude. Never had a positive experience with her of all the years we’ve been going here.

Easily the best ice cream in the area.

Fast service and very friendly

Everything is good, just seems a little pricey.

They forgot the fudge on a brownie fudge sundae. It was just a bowl of vanilla ice cream with brownie chunks.
That's not as good as it sounds.
Almost $7 phft

The best ice cream on earth.

Best ice cream and fast service! We come here all the time with my family

Excellent but no prices are posted on the outside drive up menu. That’s unusual

This is a great little ice cream shop that’s been around for years — a real neighborhood gem. I would’ve given it five stars, but the cashier seemed to be having a serious “grumpy pants” kind of day.

That said, the ice cream was solid, and I’d definitely go back. Just a little tip for next time: smile a bit, Miss Grumpy Pants — it’s ice cream, not jury duty!

Dairy Belle is new to us and we love this place! Something about the ice cream, yummy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cone

So I love their ice cream. If I was rating the ice cream it would be five stars. But if you get ice cream do not get it strawberry flavored or flavored anything. The flavoring in the strawberry ice cream is horrendous. Worst artificial flavor ever. Stick to vanilla and chocolate coated 😆

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Whoopie Pie

To the Karens getting upset at this place let me put this in perspective for your understanding.( yeah I'm talking about you Jennifer and you Priscilla) This business is amazing the owners and the workers are amazing they work their rear-ends off every morning to make the delicious treats and wonderful food that mostly everyone enjoys. if you prefer the same old boring crap from corporate chains then go there except MDs their ice cream machine is out of service. Stop getting all butt hurt about this place that tries their hardest everyday to make the business successful. I stop here everyday and get food desert or just to pick up a sweet treat for the middle of the night it is the best place to get everything food wise.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5