Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats
21 S Main St, Sullivan
(812) 638-2997
Customers' Favorites
Birthday Cake
Menu
Photos
+41 photos
+40 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Wow, I just stopped in for the first time and got a brownie and a wedding white cupcake to try. And let me just say that cupcake was the best I’ve ever had. SO good. I haven’t tried my brownie yet but I’m sure it’ll be delicious. Just had to hop on here and rave about how good that cupcake was. Will definitely be back.
She made a beautiful birthday cake exactly howy six year old wanted it. She was easy to work with and creatively interpreted the key features my daughter wanted. The only person I could find willing and able to bake a delicious rainbow layered cake.
I've used Alyssa 2x for birthday cakes & both times have been great! I also love visiting her shop for a quick treat & yummy fountain pops! Better than the gas station for sure!!
You May Also Like
Petty Pit Stop - Sullivan - 4 W Washington St
![]()
Salad, American, International, Vegan
The Square Pub - 30 W Washington St
![]()
Pubs, Salad, Burgers