My Sugar Pie
$ • Bakery, Vegetarian, Coffee Shops
Hours:
40 E Pine St, Zionsville
(317) 733-8717
About My Sugar Pie
Customers' Favorites
My Sugar Pie Reviews
Share your opinion about My Sugar Pie
Very sad to post this review. We love the pies here. The service is another story. We placed orders for two pies to be shipped. We also called them on the day they were to be shipped to confirm that everything was good to go. Then no pies arrived, no one responded to our calls for 4 days. We called again and we’re told the shipping order never happened. The only thing they offered was a refund. Poor service. This is when you have an opportunity to make it right. Why didn’t...read full review
4th of July pie is so good.
as a pie baker myself, I am always critical of pie. crust was amazing and the pie was superb. we are on a road trip and made a detour to stop here. Totally worth it. yum
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 8AM - 4PM |
| Wednesday | 8AM - 4PM |
| Thursday | 8AM - 4PM |
| Friday | 8AM - 4PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 4PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
People in Zionsville Also Viewed
My Sugar Pie is a charming little shop that serves delicious pies baked with love. The pies are handmade in actual glass pie pans, adding a personal touch to each one. Customers can enjoy a nice sitting area inside and outside, making it a cozy place to visit. The shop offers a variety of flavors, including Peach & Blueberry, Rhubarb, and Sugar Cream Pie, which is a regional specialty that many find very good. The buttery flaky crusts perfectly complement the sweet fillings, creating a delightful combination. Pies are so tasty that visiting this bakery can be a special outing, and it is recommended to order in advance for holidays like Thanksgiving. The real whipped cream available for purchase adds an extra touch of indulgence. The place is family-run, and visitors often meet friendly staff, making the experience even more personal. While the pies are a bit on the pricier side, the reusable glass pie dish makes it a good deal. Overall, My Sugar Pie is a lovely spot for anyone looking for great crusts and heavenly pies.