AJ's NY Pizzeria
301 Poyntz Ave, Manhattan
(785) 587-0700
Customers' Favorites
Manhattan Margherita Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
AJ's Grilled Cheese Pie
Al's Grilled Cheese Pie
The 18th and 8th Pizza
Jalapeno Popper Pizza
The Big Apple Pizza
Margheritta Pizza
Pepperoni Bricks
BBQ Chicken Pie
Menu
Photos
+45 photos
+44 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Great pizza by the slice, amazing salads, even better garlic knots, craft beer options, back patio with an incredible mural. There’s a lot to like about AJ’s. If you’re craving pizza and beer, this is the place.
So let me start by saying it's a college town. It's at the edge of that part of town verses smack dab in the small tight streets. The staff were very friendly . Now it was slow when I came in so not sure how they are when it's a game night or weekend which I'm sure they are slammed. Now Hunter took my order and was so helpful and informative and didn't let my eyes be bigger than my stomach lol. Jackson was friendly and listen to me chatter and explain...
Cool place that serves a decent pie. The lack of use of a pizza oven is the only reason it gets 4 instead of 5 stars.
If you expect NY style, it's expected it's done on a flat steel pizza oven, not a conveyor belt oven. The smooth metal adds the best crust treatment. These guys miss that one element which is huge.
If you expect NY style, it's expected it's done on a flat steel pizza oven, not a conveyor belt oven. The smooth metal adds the best crust treatment. These guys miss that one element which is huge.
You May Also Like
Applebee's Grill + Bar - 3rd & Poyntz 100, Suite P-5
![]()
Sports Bar, Burgers, American
Finn's Neighborhood Pub - 317 Poyntz Ave
![]()
Pubs, Dive Bar, Bar
Bourbon & Baker - 312 Poyntz Ave
![]()
American, Cocktail Bar, Bakery, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian