Maddie Rae's Bakery & Custom Confections
9224 Metcalf Ave, Overland Park
(913) 649-6700
Recent Reviews
Sort by
The frosted sugar cookies will not leave you disappointed. I consider myself a bit of a cookie snob. I won't eat a cookie unless it tastes good... these are amazing. I've ordered them twice now for two different baby showers and the guest always rave about delicious they are. 10/10, will continue to be a repeat customer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was walking by and spotted some goodies in the window and turned around and went in! The lady working said she was the mother of the baker and she was very nice! PB chocolate fudge cookie was soo good havent tried the rest yet but im sure they are just as good! Will definitely come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Staff was very friendly gave her recommendations and what were customer favorites. They had free samples of the lemon cookie which made me buy two! The blueberry muffin and snickerdoodle also tasted great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great experience and such delicious cookies. I would highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The goods from Maddie Rae’s are absolutely delicious! At first, I was sad to see Connie‘s was gone, but once I went in and experienced the 180° difference in hospitality from Maddie’s, combined with the deliciousness of their bakery retreats, I was sold.
I think the brownies are the best I have had. They made me a custom Dave Ramsey cookie cake for my kids to celebrate their last night at FPU!!
I highly recommend this bakery for your celebrations or daily sweet cravings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing little place for a cup of coffee and a cinnamon roll. Tried cinnamon roll, and peanut butter cookie best I have had in the Kansas City Area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Updating my review. Previous review was when it was Connie's Cookies. I gave them 2/5 stars. My husband picked up some sugar cookies from Maddie Rae's one day. They were so good! They were like the soft frosted ones you get at the grocery store but better! I definitely need to go back and try some other cookies.
The cookies were okay. I purchased a peanut butter cookie and a chocolate chocolate chip cookie. The peanut butter cookie tasted like something I could make at home. Paying that much for a cookie, I kind of expected some kind of wow factor. My son had the CCC cookie and he ate about 1/4 of it. He is like a human garbage disposal so it's saying something if he won't eat it. Maybe it's a preference thing, because we like soft cookies and these were crunchy throughout. We have gone to Crumbl when we've wanted a cookie lately and you definitely get what you pay for among above and beyond, quality customer service. I didn't have a bad customer service experience; the cashier was courteous and I'll leave it at that. This cookie shop just isn't to our personal liking, but I wouldn't suggest going off my review as a reason not to try it because they do have some very positive reviews specific to their cookies. I'm just leaving my honest opinion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The BEST baked goods I have ever had. Maddie’s frosting is the best. And I dream about the red velvet cake and cinnamon rolls. If I could give more stars I would. Seriously worth checking out if you haven’t!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I came to Maddie Rae’s Bakery for my gender reveal and baby shower. She was very professional and worked with me to create the perfect cake and cupcakes. Both were beautiful and delicious. I would absolutely go to her for any event.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cookie are delish but I really Love the cinnamon rolls! They are simply the best IMO. I enjoy visiting with Maddie, Angie and even Kent whenever I visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Iced Sugar Cookies
Restaurantji Recommends
Me and my Dad went to get some desserts and were not dissapointed. The people there were very kind and easy going and the cookies were amazing as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm a commercial cleaner who was working on the building and we were able to taste these absolutely amazing cookies!!!! So soft!!! We will be getting these aging!!!! Thanks guys!!!
The cookies were darling and tasted great! Many compliments from our graduation party guests!
Glad to see that Maddie Rae's hasn't changed the sugar cookie recipe from Connie's. They are the best cookies in town. Puts those from the pink box store to shame.
I absolutely love the sugar cookies, but had to give one star. Used to have a counter where I could stop in and get treats (especially when picking up my dog from the vet). Ever since COVID, they are only open maybe 2-3 days during the work day. And then the one time my schedule aligned with theirs, I went in and found out they no longer have items for sale in store. You have to order in advance. I just wanted a cookie, but never throw parties or have an occasion that would require an advance order. So disappointing. Might as well not have a storefront because your store basically doesn't exist or want my type of business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Loading...