This place lies. We completed an order for a customer through DoorDash and we asked specifically if the entire order was there and they said yes, the customer was upset with us because according to the pizza place, we picked up all the pizza. Thank goodness they remade it for the customer because the customer thought we stole the pizza when really, it was a Store that was too busy and didn’t want to make the extra pizza for the customer… due to the fact, I would never order here.
David Whitmore
To Go had the right sugary deliciousness of candy and soda to get my nieces and nephew super hyped before going home to their respective parents.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
GTA Memer
I wish I could give a 0 But 60 dollars for 2 pizzas and cheese sticks and we got our order wrong we didnt get our pizza after 25 minutes when it was supposed to be done I'd rather go to Papa John's
Jinny White
Best Pizza around!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Breta Ruckman
Husband ordered a "Create Your Own" Pizza. We've been Godfather Pizza Lover's since the 70's (in NC) & Everyone Knows one of the BIG Differences is the SAUCE!! Could Not Believe that When We Got All the Way Back Home...There was BARELY ANY SAUCE ON IT!! I, Actually, Took a Bite 2 inches from the Crust & You could look up into the Pizza & there was NO SAUCE!! Don't know what's happened over the Last Year & a Half, but with the Other Location Closed...it's NO MORE Godfather's Pizza for Us & our Friends and Family, Here! So Sad! ?BTW, My Husband wanted to ask a few questions about the Wings & the Man, (Owner?) Shut him down with the "same" one-word answer, each time, very rudely. Just one more reason to solidify our choice to "Drop the Whole Stop" from our Errands.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cory Alexander
Was needing a vape and decided to stop in this station. I looked at the vapes and decided on one. Purchased it and I never left the store. I tried the vape out and it was super nasty. The guy was obviously watching every thing I did so he knew I didn't do anything to it.I turned around and asked him if he would exchange it and he said No sorry buddy with a big smile on his face.
Service: 1
Andrew Chapman
Some of the best pizza to be found is made here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Wings
Don Barbour
My personal favorite for Pizza in Elizabethtown. It's located in a convenient store and there are tables in the back but I generally carry
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Golden Crust Classic Combo Pizza, Golden Crust All Meat Combo Pizza, Mozza Loaded Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, Original Crust All Meat Combo Pizza, Pepperoni Roll, Bone in Wings
Carey Adams
Fast for lunch with a big selection.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Golden Crust Classic Combo, Golden Crust Classic Combo Pizza, Wings, Thin Crust Classic Combo, Original Crust Humble Pizza, Thin Crust Classic Combo Pizza, Original Crust Classic Combo Pizza, Golden Crust All Meat Combo Pizza, Mozza Loaded Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, Golden Crust Super Taco Pizza, Original Crust All Meat Combo Pizza, Thin Crust Veggie Pizza, Loaded Cheese Sticks, Bone in Wings
This place is awful pizza greasy enough to start a fire. Employees (except the older woman) charge whatever they are feeling that day. I bought the same thing for lunch 5 days in a row. I got charged five different prices. The final straw I bought a calzone and a monster. Calzone rang up $3.50 the monster rang up $5.30. When I told him monsters were clearly priced $2.99 in the cooler. He proceeded to get nasty with me and accused me of lying. I live a mile from this store and will never stop here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Aaron Clark
They don't like to answer the phone and they love to shut down early. Called to order pizzas on Saturday night 8:45. Said they were closed. I asked what time they close he said 10pm. I was like ok well it is only 8:45. He said 30 minutes to clean up. Again i said it was only 8:45, he said something in Arabic and hung up on me. Not sure I will be supporting this establishment any longer. Not a good way to treat an extremely loyal customer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
JaySerf
Pie was not that great. It tasted like gas station pizza, dough is very chewy. Wings I got where very dry, the side of sause helped some but it was still very dry.Pie was freshly made just poor ingredients used for base and dough. The cheese was ok, over all not worth it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Patricia “Trisha” Robinson Gay
Depends on the time of day and who's in there...the owner not so much but the two women I know make the place personable, happy and friendly...best pizza in the county/
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Robinson Gay (Trisha)
Depends on the time of day and who's in there...the owner not so much but the two women I know make the place personable, happy and friendly...best pizza in the county/town
This place lies. We completed an order for a customer through DoorDash and we asked specifically if the entire order was there and they said yes, the customer was upset with us because according to the pizza place, we picked up all the pizza. Thank goodness they remade it for the customer because the customer thought we stole the pizza when really, it was a Store that was too busy and didn’t want to make the extra pizza for the customer… due to the fact, I would never order here.
To Go had the right sugary deliciousness of candy and soda to get my nieces and nephew super hyped before going home to their respective parents.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I wish I could give a 0 But 60 dollars for 2 pizzas and cheese sticks and we got our order wrong we didnt get our pizza after 25 minutes when it was supposed to be done I'd rather go to Papa John's
Best Pizza around!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Husband ordered a "Create Your Own" Pizza. We've been Godfather Pizza Lover's since the 70's (in NC) & Everyone Knows one of the BIG Differences is the SAUCE!! Could Not Believe that When We Got All the Way Back Home...There was BARELY ANY SAUCE ON IT!! I, Actually, Took a Bite 2 inches from the Crust & You could look up into the Pizza & there was NO SAUCE!! Don't know what's happened over the Last Year & a Half, but with the Other Location Closed...it's NO MORE Godfather's Pizza for Us & our Friends and Family, Here! So Sad! ?BTW, My Husband wanted to ask a few questions about the Wings & the Man, (Owner?) Shut him down with the "same" one-word answer, each time, very rudely. Just one more reason to solidify our choice to "Drop the Whole Stop" from our Errands.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Was needing a vape and decided to stop in this station. I looked at the vapes and decided on one. Purchased it and I never left the store. I tried the vape out and it was super nasty. The guy was obviously watching every thing I did so he knew I didn't do anything to it.I turned around and asked him if he would exchange it and he said No sorry buddy with a big smile on his face.
Service: 1
Some of the best pizza to be found is made here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Wings
My personal favorite for Pizza in Elizabethtown. It's located in a convenient store and there are tables in the back but I generally carry
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Golden Crust Classic Combo Pizza, Golden Crust All Meat Combo Pizza, Mozza Loaded Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, Original Crust All Meat Combo Pizza, Pepperoni Roll, Bone in Wings
Fast for lunch with a big selection.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Golden Crust Classic Combo, Golden Crust Classic Combo Pizza, Wings, Thin Crust Classic Combo, Original Crust Humble Pizza, Thin Crust Classic Combo Pizza, Original Crust Classic Combo Pizza, Golden Crust All Meat Combo Pizza, Mozza Loaded Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, Golden Crust Super Taco Pizza, Original Crust All Meat Combo Pizza, Thin Crust Veggie Pizza, Loaded Cheese Sticks, Bone in Wings
this is my favorite pizza on Etown , i love
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is awful pizza greasy enough to start a fire. Employees (except the older woman) charge whatever they are feeling that day. I bought the same thing for lunch 5 days in a row. I got charged five different prices. The final straw I bought a calzone and a monster. Calzone rang up $3.50 the monster rang up $5.30. When I told him monsters were clearly priced $2.99 in the cooler. He proceeded to get nasty with me and accused me of lying. I live a mile from this store and will never stop here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
They don't like to answer the phone and they love to shut down early. Called to order pizzas on Saturday night 8:45. Said they were closed. I asked what time they close he said 10pm. I was like ok well it is only 8:45. He said 30 minutes to clean up. Again i said it was only 8:45, he said something in Arabic and hung up on me. Not sure I will be supporting this establishment any longer. Not a good way to treat an extremely loyal customer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Pie was not that great. It tasted like gas station pizza, dough is very chewy. Wings I got where very dry, the side of sause helped some but it was still very dry.Pie was freshly made just poor ingredients used for base and dough. The cheese was ok, over all not worth it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Depends on the time of day and who's in there...the owner not so much but the two women I know make the place personable, happy and friendly...best pizza in the county/
Food: 5
Service: 5
Depends on the time of day and who's in there...the owner not so much but the two women I know make the place personable, happy and friendly...best pizza in the county/town