Pizza Mavens

2957 Leitchfield Rd, Elizabethtown
(270) 982-5566

Recent Reviews

Robin Turner Reeder

I called in an order for pick up. “Robbie,” said it would be 15 minutes. I arrived in the parking in 10 minutes and sat there for 35 minutes. I finally called and asked how much longer it would be on my order, and he said it was ready. I needed to come in and pick it up. The last time I had been to Maven’s was when you had to sit in the car, and they would bring it out to you. I guess that’s why I sat in the car so long. When I went inside, Robbie was very rude. I asked him

Nick Smith

Giving it five stars due to the fact its the closest I've had to NY and NJ style pizza. Great flavor and quick. Nothing in E-town compares.

Mary Susan Meredith

Super friendly service. Must try.

Colleen Tannock Hershour

This is our second time there this week! I would highly recommend this place! I’m from NJ, and everyone knows Jersey has the best pizza! This is as close as you’ll get to Jersey pizza. It’s so good!!!

Mike G

Very good pizza - crust, sauce, toppings. Owner also very personable. Nice to have found a good local pizza place.

Zanda G.

I'm a fan! I brought home a large double dough supreme style pizza tonight as I wanted to try pizza from somewhere different than a chain. It is huge! And I loved the dough. It does remind me of the New York Style pizza. One slice and I was full so I'll be meal-prepping lunches with my left overs. Ha. I also ordered the burrito bites. The family loved those and they definitely were not what I envisioned but it went over quite well.

Kathy L.

We wanted to try something new and different from chain restaurants. We heard about Pizza Maven since they opened and wanted to try something new. We figured we would order when we got there and had an idea of what we wanted. We wanted the works pizzas and pizza bread, but we wanted to ask which topping we can get on the pizza bread. They allow 3 toppings and there was a variety to choose from. We placed our order and paid and was told it would be a 15-20 minutes wait. So we waited out in the car, we could have waited inside, their seating was open. About 15 minutes and a couple other customers came and picked up their orders and we saw them putting boxes in the warmer and figured ours was next. Our pizza was almost done and waited about 5-10 mins more and our pizza was ready to go! Everything was hot! The cheese smelled amazing! It was a lot of toppings on the pizza and the cheese was delicious and different from the standard mozzarella. It took us a couple of days to finish the pizza since it was HUGE! The pizza bread was crispy and delicious. For 2 people was more than enough and we were happily full!

Cris Guzmán

Highly recommended. Super quick. Free delivery. Fresh and quality ingredients. Great lunch and ever party night. Amazing specials throughout Football season. You will want to order again!!!

RON Fisk

The best pizza in town. Hard working friendly staff.

Chaz Ott

Delicious! Not a chain. Loaded with toppings. Get the double dough. Highly recommended. Large is huge.

Tanner Thomas

I decided to try this place on a whim and I'm so glad that I did. This is now my pizzeria of choice. The dough is cold-fermented and made in house. The cheese and other toppings are premium quality. The sauce is made in-house as well. The pizza is cooked in a proper brick oven. 10/10 you can not make pizza better than this. Pizza Maven's has achieved perfection.

Scott Woods

Always great Pizza from Pizza Mavens

Kandyce Cloud Walters

First time trying it out and Pizza Mavens did not disappoint ! My order was ready when I got there (smelled delicious) and the staff was friendly. Will definitely be back again

RL Young

BEST PIZZA EVER. We were on a road trip and just happened to exit off the Interstate for dinner. We had a supreme pizza and no joke it was the best pizza we have ever had. The crust was crispy and delicious and all the toppings were fresh and generous. I’m sad we live 2 states away and can’t visit this place frequently!

jason devers

Better Pizza than any of the large chain restaurants. I will order again but I will ask for extra sauce on my pizza next time. I do that anywhere I order though. ? good pizza, check them out!

Load More