Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street
$ • Pizza, Gluten-Free Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street
Customers' Favorites
Bottelo Chicken Cheese Bread
Pineapple and Ham Pizza
Extra Large Breadstick
Pepperoni and Mushroom
Lunch Specialty Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Craft Your Own Pizza
My Combination Pizza
New York Style Pizza
The Vinny Pizza
Recent Reviews
354 ratings
Share your opinion about Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street
We are from NYC and this is the best pizza just like from NYC. Excellent sauce cheese pepperoni and good oil on top. The best!!! You have to go there . hugh slices too. Good and hot too mouth watering pizza
A half pepperoni, half custom pie arrived with the line between them blurred, custom toppings spilling onto the pepperoni side like the cooks lost track of where one order ended and the other began. What did land correctly showed real promise: a crust with good char, a snap to the bottom, and toppings that tasted fresh rather than phoned in. But a pizzeria that can't execute a basic half-and-half split is asking customers to overlook a fundamental miss. Craft was there. Attention...read full review
The employees were extremely rude
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 3AM |
| Friday | 11AM - 3AM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 3AM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 12AM |
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street offers a truly awesome dining experience with hospitable staff and great food. The massive pizza slices feature unique toppings and a perfect thin, crispy crust. The 22-inch "Goodfella" with extra pepperoni and light sauce is a standout, fresh and piping hot. The restaurant also accommodates gluten-free diners with salad options. The people working here are so nice and considerate, providing wonderful service. The pizza has to be one of the best, with a perfect chewy and crusty crust, flavorful sauce, and delicious pepperoni. Customers also enjoy the fantastic breadsticks and meatballs. While the small space has limited seating, the quality of the food makes it worth the visit, especially for those who prefer the ambiance of the larger distillery district location.