NEW YORK PIZZA COMPANY
2354 Frankfort Ave, Louisville
(502) 963-5756
Customers' Favorites
Buy Two Get Third Pizza Free Pepperoni XL Large 20 Pizzas 3 XL Large Pizzas
White Pie with Ricotta - Romas NY Style Thin Crust - XL Large 20 Inch
Meat Pie Meat Lovers 20 XL Large NY Style Thin Crust
Quattro Formaggi 4 Cheese XL Large 20 Pizza
Salad Meat Margherita White Pie
Creamy New York Cheesecake
Sausage & Mushroom Pie
Mascarpone Cheescake
Sweet Sausage Pizza
Large Italian Salad
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The pizza is lit. Service is efficient and dude is super nice. I really wish the ranch was better and did not care for the type of cheese on the white pizza but other than that I cannot complain- I love all the other slices. The texture/chew/crunch of the crust is perfectly balanced, the flavor is spot on, and the options, value, and recipe are right on point. I stopped going to The Post when I found this place- this pizza exceeds Spinellis, The Post- better than any other NY...
As a former native NYer, I was hopeful. We each had a slice. The service was extremely slow. We waited a good 30 mins for our slices. They don't have a large oven for slices but small individual ovens for single slices. Although we got there a little after opening, we had to wait for many slices to be heated before us. The single person working up front was IMO over whelmed. He had to answer phone, talk to people about slices, take orders, cook slices, pour beer and bring...
So I really wanted to give this place a 5 because food was amazing! They did give us the wrong dessert is the only thing. So I would give a 4.5 if I could:) Ordered via DoorDash and that went well. Great pizza!
You May Also Like
El Mundo Frankfort Ave - 2345 Frankfort Ave
![]()
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian
Please & Thank You "FRANK" - 2341 Frankfort Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Bakery, Cafe, Coffee