Papa John's in Louisville

“Papa John’s on Shelbyville Road in Louisville consistently delivers great pizza and excellent service! The staff is always friendly, and the restaurant is well-kept, creating a welcoming atmosphere for carryout or quick service. Whether you’re grabbing a pizza to go or dining in, you can expect a smooth and pleasant experience.

The pizza is delicious and made with fresh ingredients. Their signature crust is always perfectly baked, and you can count on the pizza being hot and flavorful every time. The menu offers a variety of options, including specialty pizzas, wings, and breadsticks, so there’s something for everyone. I love the consistency of the quality, and the garlic butter dipping sauce is a must-have!

The location is conveniently located and easy to get to, with plenty of parking. Ordering is simple, whether through the app, website, or in person. The staff is always efficient, ensuring orders are prepared quickly.

I’ve always had positive experiences here, with orders being accurate and timely. Whether it’s for a quick meal or a family gathering, Papa John’s on Shelbyville Road is my go-to pizza place. Highly recommend for great pizza and outstanding service!“

“Haven't had Papa John's in years. Decided to get just a basic pepperoni pizza. Man, going to show my age but this pizza tasted exactly how you'd expect a Ninja Turtle pizza to taste or that juicy gooey pizza from the Goofy Movie. Secret is asking for them to top it with extra sauce. I'm drooling now thinking of it.“

“I highly recommend eating at this Papa Johns location. The pizza, wings, and brownie I ordered for me and my son was delivered hot and fresh and tatsed delicious. They also delivered it before the estimated delivery time which was a plus.
Thank you!“

“I like their new auto system when you call. It actually got all my information correct. (Which is better than their call center has ever done.) I miss when the store employees used to answer and take orders, but the new automated system is a big improvement from the call center people with heavy accents.“

“Even tho I had my order made wrong first
I gotta give a shout to the man who legit was manning this establishment on his own, no one to pick up the phone, toss the dough, check the register, and serving the people besides HIM, and he was cool enough to fix my order at the spot with obstacles but at the spot, later the delivery hopping but this dude was still moving. Shame on management and owners but praise to the real hard workers keeping the place actuallya running!!! And by the way NOTHING BUT SMILES AND GOOD ATTITUDE“

“Better ingredients...just kidding. The pizza was delicious. It had a decent amount of toppings, and was reasonably priced. My only complaint is that they make you pay extra for the pepperoncini that they used to give you for free. The staff was friendly and the store looked clean. What else can you ask from a restaurant?“

“Don’t order from here on bardstown road because I order pizza at 11:37 pm they close at 12 am and it was February 5 and it was a block away from my house to be delivered and they canceled and I had a tip and everything this papa John’s needs new mangers and the owners of the store has to do better come on “

“I was the last customer of the night 6-5-25. The management and staff were incredibly helpful and kind. Little did they know we had seven kids back at the suite. The food of course was hot, fresh and delicious. I appreciated the consideration and communication.“

“ALGONQUIN COMMUNITY UNITED, ACU Inc..like to thank Rochelle & Bobbie…for leading by example…Excellent service & clean establishment…ACU & the children appreciate Papa John for having people like them …that genuinely love to serve the community…Thx for contributing in helping making are community great again!!!!???“

“Imagine a cozy little pizza spot that feels like home the moment you step inside. The place is buzzing with life, laughter filling the air, and that mouthwatering smell of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese wrapping around you like a warm hug. The walls are decked out with fun pizza-themed art, giving the place a relaxed, welcoming vibe. Families are gathered over shared pies, friends are cracking jokes, and you can feel the happiness in every corner.

Now, let’s dive into the pizza itself. The crust is just the right kind of magic—soft yet perfectly crispy around the edges, with that slightly charred finish that makes every bite irresistible. The sauce is rich and flavorful, like a perfect blend of ripe tomatoes, garlic, and herbs, giving it that homemade taste. The cheese is gooey and stretchy, melting in all the right ways. Whether you’re into a classic pepperoni, loaded veggies, or something unique like BBQ chicken, the toppings are always fresh and generous. They even have quirky options, like a spicy jalapeño and honey combo that’s surprisingly addictive. It’s not just a pizza spot—it’s a place that turns every slice into a piece of joy, keeping you coming back for more.“

“The Papa John's on outerloop and new cut road is very new and very nice lighting is excellent 👌

Vegetarian options: There pizza dough only has 4 ingredients so way better off than that little guy pizza that says pizza 3 times in a row in TV commercials

Parking: Come by they so new no wait time faster than fast pizza made on arrival is the only way to order we always order once we have arrived in the parking lot“

“Papa John's is my go-to for pizza night! Their pizza is always good, with fresh toppings and that signature garlic sauce. Pro tip: use their app! They always have deals and coupons, which makes it a pretty good value. I usually do takeout to save a few bucks, and it's always ready quickly. If you're looking for a solid pizza, Papa John's is a good choice. 🍕“

“Carson is the greatest employee that this papa johns has ever had. The store would absolutely not be the same without him. He also very handsome and is really cool. He makes the best pizzas you could ever eat. When I walk into the store and see Carson it absolutely makes my day.Will is also a great employee. His dog pictures were great.Will be ordering from here again!“

“Probably the best pizza experience I've had in a while! Ordered extra cheese on one pizza and they gave us extra cheese our others as well! Only ordered 4 extra pepperchinis and got a whole container full. Ice cold 2 liters and our delivery driver was so sweet he waived our tip! THANKYOU so much!“

“This is a beautiful place to enjoy, take kids, and learn about the mammoth cave area. It is in a national park and FREE to go in and experience something new. The park is beautiful too. Nice trails. Cave tour costs money but you can spend a few free hours seeing everything else. The city it is in is awesome too. Like mom and pop town you will feel right at home and very peaceful Rock Cabin Camp is great too. Tell Ralph Jenni said Hello.“

“Papa John's now does gluten free pizzas; and they are delicious. I ordered the vegetarian without olives- they included a garlic dipping sauce, which makes it even better. The manager and staff here are incredibly caring, and friendly; as is their delivery person, or Doordash person. I will definitely order from here again.“

“Very pleased with my recent purchase. The food was hot and fresh. I made a mistake when placing my order (I selected the wrong type of crust). Even though it was my error, they replaced the pizza free of charge. They even let me keep the original pizza. That level of service is rare nowadays. We'll definitely be back. Also, I got a large 1 topping, a medium cheese, a papadia, chicken bites and garlic sticks for under $35. Can't beat the value.“

“I put my order in online, then they have a tracker that lets you know exactly where your order is in the production stage all the way to ready for pickup! You also can pay by card or pay cash when you pickup.(cash isn't an option on any of the other apps I use)“

“Solid pizza 4 out of 5 visits. Usually moderately busy, lots of door dashers are waiting for orders, especially in the evening or on the weekends.

Currently large 1 toppings for about $.9.00
Why go to little Caesars?“