Penny and Pearl's Bakeshop

106 Fairfax Ave, Louisville
(502) 890-6004

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Glutin Free Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

Dozen Variety Sandwich Cookies

Chocolate Potato Chip Cookie

Half Dozen GF Chocolate Chip

Oatmeal Vanilla Bean Sammie

Brown Butter Snickerdoodle

Creme Brulee Key Lime Pie

Half Dozen Chocolate Chip

Crème Brûlée Chocolate

Half Dozen Snickerdoodle

Photos

+31 photos

+30 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Pennyandpearls

Doordash

Recent Reviews

Tried the oatmeal creme pie and it was really good! The cookie part was very buttery and a bit crispy. Definitely hit the spot! Cost was 3.25 or 3.50...seemed high for one cookie that wasn't very big so a star down for that.

July 2026

First and foremost, can someone work on bottling up the sweet smell of sugar that hits you as soon as you walk in? Yum. As for the cookies, divine. I got three different ones: the brookie, chocolate chip, and creme brulee. I always judge on the 'basics', which means the chocolate chip cookie has to be good. And it was. So good in fact, that I got in line for another. Perfectly crisp edges, soft & chewy center, and a hint of sea salt. Oh! And the best part, IT WAS...

June 2026

So sorry not sorry I don’t have any photos !
Seriously good cookies ! Yum and Yum ! We had the peanut butter, chocolate chip and key lime .
All were good , but that key lime cookie (baby) ! Delicioso!!! Perfection in cookie form ! I’m am almost always disappointed when it comes to sweets but not here . It’s smells amazing when you walk in and staff is friendly . 10 out of 10 recommend!!

June 2026

More Reviews

Restaurants in Louisville, KY

Penny and Pearl's Bakeshop

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Penny and Pearl's Bakeshop