Michael's New York Style Pizza
907 Kentucky Ave, Paducah
(270) 443-0300
Customers' Favorites
Vegetarian Pizza Large with Added Jalapenos on Half
Mushroom and Green Pepper Pizza New York
Pepperoni and Italian Sausage Pizza
New York Style Pizza Large
Meat Lovers Personal Pizza
Jerry's Italian Beef Sub
Lunch Special Pizza Slice
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
Extra Cheese Pepperoni
Tomatoes and Spinach
Menu
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Five stars for Michael's pizza. Their pizza is authentic New York/Neapolitan style pizza. The quality of the fresh handmade dough, sauce, cheese and toppings-all delicious and spot on. Service is always good and friendly. I usually do take out and seems a couple slices never make it home!
My step dad is from New York, and he'll tell you it's the closest you'll find to back home. Also pretty cool the owner had to adjust the recipe to get the same authentic New York crust to rise right in Kentucky
Best pizza I’ve ever had. No exaggeration. Nothing else even comes close. The entire staff is also super friendly. Paducah is so lucky to have Michael’s! Order some pickles, too!??
You May Also Like
The Coney Express - 814 Jefferson St
![]()
Food Trucks, Hot Dogs
Branch Out - 713 Kentucky Ave suite 101
![]()
Vegan, Burgers, Donuts, Tacos, Pet Friendly
Moosie's Grub Shack - 1019 Broadway St
![]()
Hot Dogs, Burgers, Barbeque