Best pizza in Agawam! We really are loving the wings - they have an amazing golden BBQ sauce. Their portion are large and good for the price. Salads and pizza are especially large.They can be abrasive when you order on the phone, but are pretty polite in person.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Jon Sousa
Great food! Great value! ??
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Robert
Great price, fast and courteous meal brought to table, it was delightful!!Thank you Nicky's Pizza !!!!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gina Lombardi
Just have to say,This is the best pizza I have had in years, I'm am so picky with pizza,about the crust and the sauce,and WOW! I had the heart shaped Valentines Pizza which I thought was a super cool thing to do,And it was delicious..Then just had a pizza for the 2nd time from you and you didn't disappoint!!! I'm so happy to finally have a perfect tasting PIZZA! #CustomerForLife#666 not liking that tho.lol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Pizza Slice of Pepperoni Pizza, Small Pizza, Pepperoni Slice
R P.
Keep in mind, this place is cash only but they do have an in the restaurant. We stop here for a bite to eat since we're new to the neighborhood. The food was pretty good and decently price. We will definitely will be coming back. Update: we did a party size pizza and it was great, there was plenty of food leftover. This looks to be one of our new spots.
June Reyes
Great pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Guy Tano
Best authentic pizza around. Eat here frequent. Always busy, that tells ya
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Colleto
Great place for a slice of pizza, a staple of the Agawam community, and overall good people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ray Asselin
Ordered a Tuna grinder slice of pizza order of curly fries .the most disgusting food I ve ever had I don't know how they are in business. The Tuna looked like it was thrown in a blender to an Oatmeal consistency eww.the curly fries were so greese soaked inedible and the sluce was undercooked and sauce tasted like Ketchup wow this is the worst I ve ever had sad no quality control ?
Been coming here for years. Without a doubt, my favorite pizza shop in town. Great food, with a welcoming staff that remember your name and great you a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Crust Pizza, Pizza by the Slice, Pizza Slice of Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Slice, Chicken Tenders, Clam Chowder, Veggie Slice, Curly Fries, Roast Beef, Buffalo Wings, Small Pizza, Pepperoni Slice, blt, Sausage, Steak Bomb, Small Medium Pizza, Calzone, Steak and Cheese, Large Cheese Pizza, Cheese Curds
These are such nice people the food is probably still the cheapest around and as good as any other place you'll try..got delivery as always cam quick and hot!! Thanks for always making it quick and delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna Drewnowski
A great Italian restaurant for delicious pizza, grinders and much more. Been in business for years!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marjorie Stradinger
OKAY, so the five stars wouldn't be about ambiance. But it's about EVERYTHING ELSE that is more important! Give me tablecloths and fine china with moderately good food, and I will RUN to Nicky's Pizza every time, even with their vintage tables and modest decor. It's clean and comfortable enough. So...First of all, the food is incredibly delicious and memorble. The pizza sauce is so amazing I want to go back for all of their pasta dishes. Everything is homemade, and I think they must be hiding an Italian grandmother back there somewhere, cooking up an authentic savory storm. The crust is fabulous, including their cauliflower crust. No pizza in the area even comes close to being this good on quality products (NO CANOLA EVER), taste, and preparation.Second, we tried the homemade clam chowder. Wow. If this is the example of New England chowder, it ROCKS.Third, this place gives family-owned and family-run a good name. Nicky hires his family. Tony, his son, and the spokesperson at the counter, couldn't be friendlier or more efficient. You feel like family even as a customer. He will chat, but his eye is always scanning, making sure every order is perfect. And by the time he introduced me to Giani, Pat, Enzo and problably someone i missed (maybe that grandmother), I was sure it was a happy family. It says something about a man whose relatives want to work with him.We haven't indulged in fried pickles, poutain, fried dough, or much else--but we will. I don't know why, other than the 8 mile drive, I don't go here more, but I will now that I have re-visited and recalled how good it all is--and very affordable!They only deliver in Agawam and Feeding Hills--not Enfield sadly, and they only take cash, so we imagine that is one reason their prices have stayed so low.Try Nicky's Pizza. It's a hands-down winner.
Best pizza in Agawam! We really are loving the wings - they have an amazing golden BBQ sauce. Their portion are large and good for the price. Salads and pizza are especially large.They can be abrasive when you order on the phone, but are pretty polite in person.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Great food! Great value! ??
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great price, fast and courteous meal brought to table, it was delightful!!Thank you Nicky's Pizza !!!!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just have to say,This is the best pizza I have had in years, I'm am so picky with pizza,about the crust and the sauce,and WOW! I had the heart shaped Valentines Pizza which I thought was a super cool thing to do,And it was delicious..Then just had a pizza for the 2nd time from you and you didn't disappoint!!! I'm so happy to finally have a perfect tasting PIZZA! #CustomerForLife#666 not liking that tho.lol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Pizza Slice of Pepperoni Pizza, Small Pizza, Pepperoni Slice
Keep in mind, this place is cash only but they do have an in the restaurant. We stop here for a bite to eat since we're new to the neighborhood. The food was pretty good and decently price. We will definitely will be coming back. Update: we did a party size pizza and it was great, there was plenty of food leftover. This looks to be one of our new spots.
Great pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best authentic pizza around. Eat here frequent. Always busy, that tells ya
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for a slice of pizza, a staple of the Agawam community, and overall good people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a Tuna grinder slice of pizza order of curly fries .the most disgusting food I ve ever had I don't know how they are in business. The Tuna looked like it was thrown in a blender to an Oatmeal consistency eww.the curly fries were so greese soaked inedible and the sluce was undercooked and sauce tasted like Ketchup wow this is the worst I ve ever had sad no quality control ?
Food: 1
The absolute best pizza i ever had huge too
Restaurantji Recommends
Been coming here for years. Without a doubt, my favorite pizza shop in town. Great food, with a welcoming staff that remember your name and great you a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Crust Pizza, Pizza by the Slice, Pizza Slice of Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Slice, Chicken Tenders, Clam Chowder, Veggie Slice, Curly Fries, Roast Beef, Buffalo Wings, Small Pizza, Pepperoni Slice, blt, Sausage, Steak Bomb, Small Medium Pizza, Calzone, Steak and Cheese, Large Cheese Pizza, Cheese Curds
Excellent customer service; Delicious food; Delightful environment. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
These are such nice people the food is probably still the cheapest around and as good as any other place you'll try..got delivery as always cam quick and hot!! Thanks for always making it quick and delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A great Italian restaurant for delicious pizza, grinders and much more. Been in business for years!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
OKAY, so the five stars wouldn't be about ambiance. But it's about EVERYTHING ELSE that is more important! Give me tablecloths and fine china with moderately good food, and I will RUN to Nicky's Pizza every time, even with their vintage tables and modest decor. It's clean and comfortable enough. So...First of all, the food is incredibly delicious and memorble. The pizza sauce is so amazing I want to go back for all of their pasta dishes. Everything is homemade, and I think they must be hiding an Italian grandmother back there somewhere, cooking up an authentic savory storm. The crust is fabulous, including their cauliflower crust. No pizza in the area even comes close to being this good on quality products (NO CANOLA EVER), taste, and preparation.Second, we tried the homemade clam chowder. Wow. If this is the example of New England chowder, it ROCKS.Third, this place gives family-owned and family-run a good name. Nicky hires his family. Tony, his son, and the spokesperson at the counter, couldn't be friendlier or more efficient. You feel like family even as a customer. He will chat, but his eye is always scanning, making sure every order is perfect. And by the time he introduced me to Giani, Pat, Enzo and problably someone i missed (maybe that grandmother), I was sure it was a happy family. It says something about a man whose relatives want to work with him.We haven't indulged in fried pickles, poutain, fried dough, or much else--but we will. I don't know why, other than the 8 mile drive, I don't go here more, but I will now that I have re-visited and recalled how good it all is--and very affordable!They only deliver in Agawam and Feeding Hills--not Enfield sadly, and they only take cash, so we imagine that is one reason their prices have stayed so low.Try Nicky's Pizza. It's a hands-down winner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5