Katie's Homemade Ice Cream
568 Main St, Hyannis
(508) 771-6889
Customers' Favorites
Cape Cod Sand and Lavender Honeycomb Ice Cream
Peppermint Oreo
Waffle Cones
Cape Cod Mud
Butter Pecan
Coffee Oreo
Strawberry
Brownie
Coconut
Cookie
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My cousin and I ended up here because they were the only place open past 9 on a weeknight in September :) but it was a solid choice! I got the Cape Cod sand ice cream, which was delicious. The server was very weird about it, though - I asked what flavor it was, and he said he couldn't tell me because it was a secret. Like - I'm going to try it and figure it out, so that's not much of a secret :)
The ice cream is very good. Unfortunately they don't honor their own policies. We ordered a lavender milkshake that tasted so strongly of lavender it was like soap. I can understand how some people may like this but it was way too overpowering for us. We walked out the door for approximately a minute since there were a lot of people in the store. We did not even leave the porch area and walked right back in to ask for a new simple flavor. Since they boast customer satisfaction...
You May Also Like
El Mariachi Loco - 569 Main St
![]()
Mexican, Pet Friendly
Perry Lima Cafe - 573 Main Street &, 575 Main St
![]()
Breakfast, Coffee & Tea, Burgers
The Daily Paper on Main - 546 Main St
![]()
Breakfast, Vegan
We had to each try something we didn't really want so it wasn't the best experience. In the summer it is a great place for ice cream and we enjoy walking down Main Street Hyannis.