Bennett's Sandwich Shop

1348 Boylston St, Boston
(857) 239-9736

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gary Parr

Tasty breakfast sandwich. Counter service only and pretty loud.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Daniel Ervin

portions are really big and taste pretty good but nothing insanely special. fun little spot and prices are fair considering the portion sizes. thumbs up bruv

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Michael Martinez

Normally a solid breakfast sandwich choice. There was a mix up on my order today where they forgot to add hot peppers onto the sandwich. I called to explain the mix up, and the gentleman apologized, but said he wouldn’t offer a credit for a future order. The hot peppers are the best part! Solid food, but poor customer service. They lost my business today.

Service: 1

Erin R

They don't read the delivery notes. It had happened multiple times. I am allergic to mushrooms and asked for no grilled vegetables yet both times they ignore that request. It also happened in person. They clearly don't listen or read what their customers ask for. I'm never ordering from them again.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michael McCarthy

Went for breakfast and hadn't heard Stegg Breakfast Sandwich. Absolutely delicious! Quick service too! I will definitely go back again. Moderately priced and ordered the smaller size Sandwich which was ample!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Boston's Underworld

Excellent service and quality food. The subs are the best in boston.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bernard 1

Famous steak and cheese is pretty good. Port fries were good. Not crazy about the Sriracha aioli, but it wasn't bad. Raspberry lemonade was good. Chocolate chip cookie was good. Kettle cooked BBQ chips are Cape Cod brand.

Sarah Yee

Great GFs subs! Arrived a bit soggy with DoorDash but likely a delivery issue.

B. M.

Excellent breakfast sandwiches. The coffee was not good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Alexis F Boyer

My colleague ordered catering from Bennett's for an event, and everyone was really impressed! Everything came packed up perfectly wrapped in boxes ready to go with mayo and delicious spicy mayo on the side. The condiments on the side were a real pro move! The sandwiches were packed dry (with no condiments) so they don't end up soggy. We had some leftovers, so I brought a sandwich home, and it was good even after being in the fridge for about 24 hours!

Food: 5

John Shimer

Bennett’s is class. I eat there because I love their chicken steak n’ cheese sub, but they also were very good to our men’s soccer Emanuel for a catering order.

Customer Service is outstanding!! Couldn’t recommend more for some looking for a great sandwich or if your organization needs a catering order!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashley Carey

absolute 10 out of 10. the food was so so good. the best Italian sub! the warm welcome and customer service was the cherry on top. wonderful experience. highly recommend and will be going back! NH location!

Robert

Horrible bread, is undercooked, need to find a better Bakery, may I suggest Piantedosi...?

Not a cheap sandwich, $13.99😳

Go around the corner to star market, for $8, you get a bigger sub and Boars Head meats.

1st pic is a Star Market sub
2nd is from here, see how the bread is as white as the paper (no filters used)

AA

I’m not sure why the rating is low, the place is excellent cashier and servers are polite and helpful (shout out to Brandin), food is yummy and the place is clean, I definitely recommend this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tabitha

I ordered a turkey blt online, for pickup. I asked for one condiment- mayo- and the sandwich had zero condiments, more lettuce than turkey, and turkey that was paper thin. I have no idea why this place has good reviews if they can’t even make a turkey sub. Given the quality of the turkey, I won’t be back. I tipped on this pickup order and ordered after the lunch hour.

Food: 2

Service: 2

Loading...