Tenderoni's Pizza

100 High St Suite 22, Boston
(617) 425-6262

Recent Reviews

Nick Cataldo

I buy my lunch everyday and in general pay between 10, on the low end and up to approximately 20 for fast casual take out, sandwiches, burritos etc…That being said 8 dollars for a single slice of pizza here is absurd. So for a relatively light lunch of 2 slices of pizza and a bottled water they want roughly TWENTY DOLLARS. “And I like the pizza”Here’s a crazy idea…How about 2 slices for 10 dollars…Still seems like a premium price point, but fair

David Scott

If you enjoy paying $8 a slice for Ellio's with some dry cheese flakes on it, this is the place for you

Elliot Mortell

1. TIGER MAMA ?2. El Barrio3. Happy’s4 Burton’s5. Tenderoni’s

Holly K.

I was truly excited to find a place with deep dish pizza in Boston (a rare find); but I'm not sure how I feel about the pizza. I tried a slice of pepperoni pizza- which they reheat in the oven for you. I felt the crust was dried out and SO crispy it was almost burnt. I liked the fluffy dough of the pizza, and the crispy pepperonis. I do feel like if I came in the afternoon when the pizza is first made, I may have liked the pizza more (I felt mine had just been "sitting around" all day since I ate it after 8 pm). I would return to give it a second shot (hey, deep dish pizza is limited in Boston). Definitely needs to taste fresher to be worth the price ($8) though.

nik_chelli

A variety of restaurants to choose from with a bar. Varies from late night eats to breakfast options. Music and DJ playing late at night. A fun social place to go, especially of the group cant decide on what restaurant to eat at!

Alee L.

I kicked off my Friday by going to Tenderoni's at High Street Place for pizza. The pizzas are a cross between Detroit and Sicilian-style pizza. They are thick, square, cheezy, and crispy on the sides because of the extra cheese baked around the square of the pizza. The cheezy border is the one characteristic of the pizza I appreciated the most because I love eating the corners of brownies and lasagna. I'm not a fan of thick and bready pizza; I'm an NYC-style pizza gal. However, the pizza toppings are delightful, which makes for a tasty pizza. If I get a chance, I will try all the different toppings of pizza that are available. The pepperoni and mushroom were the ones I had, and they were good. These pizza slices are very filling; one of these squares can hit the spot. I had their Whoa Caesar salad, which was dry and needed more dressing. The My Pal Sal Grindah is the food item at Tendoroni's I truly liked eating. This Italian sub hits it for me. If I had to get a repeat item, it surely would be My Pal Sal.

Google user

I was in town for work and I tried this place because the pizza looked good. Unfortunately looks can be deceiving. The service was very mediocre with a lack of service and the pizza was tough and chewy, didn't have much flavor besides oiliness... had the \\\"Sausage \\u0026 Pepps\\\" and after one bite I was done and also had the \\\"Cheese Please\\\" and after a few bites I had abandoned it also... Save yourself the disappointment and try a different place.

Da Hun

I was in town for work and I tried this place because the pizza looked good. Unfortunately looks can be deceiving. The service was very mediocre with a lack of service and the pizza was tough and chewy, didn't have much flavor besides oiliness... had the "Sausage & Pepps" and after one bite I was done and also had the "Cheese Please" and after a few bites I had abandoned it also... Save yourself the disappointment and try a different place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza Cheese Pizza

Scott B.

I'd heard good things about this place and finally visited in May 2023 and was so disappointed. Pizza was barely warm and very expensive. 4 slices cost almost $40 with tip.I'm a big fan of Detroit style and even make it at home. These slices were tough to chew and the flavor wasn't anything special. I guess they warmed them up, but they were still cold in the middle. The sauce is spicy, which is fine, but even the cheese slice was way too spicy for my child.The place was full of people, and that's what I love about food halls, but the music was also extremely loud.Honestly a slice of pizza from Costco is better, and there are plenty of better Detroit style places in the Boston area. And of course, the old standby Pinnochio's, which is a different style, but we almost considered stopping there on the way home just so we weren't so disappointed.We won't be going back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pizza Cheese Pizza

K C

Big shouts to MJ, our wonderful server! Fantastic food! Looking forward to when they add a few vegan options. Great job with food allergies too!

Jonathan George

Great food, great service, and fun atmosphere!

Josh Greenberg

Really great vibe and awesome food!!!!Killer calamari fra diavolo and orfano caesar salad!! Also, the grilled italian beef sticks are amazing!! Drinks are a bit pricy tho!

Tess S.

We had an amazing experience served by MJ! We had delicious food, drink, and ambiance and loved the vibe! We had yummy mozz cakes, refreshing lemonades, and a delicious furry monster Sundae. Can't wait to come back and be served by our favorite gal - MJ :)

LillyBeeee

We came here twice it was sooo good. All the options - magnificent Highly recommend the cocktail bar and the Haley Jane's - Amazing sandwiches and real chicken nuggets The Burger joint is amazinggggg Champagne bar - a little pretentious but that's to be expected! Pizza was delicious Will def be back if given the chance

Frances Alsbrook

Amazing Detroit style pizza. The atmosphere is so fun. Service is fast and efficient. We will definitely be back!Dietary restrictions: Peanut allergy friendly

Load More