The Ice Creamsmith

2295 Dorchester Ave, Boston
(617) 296-8567

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tammy Tadsaluk

Local Historical ice cream shop, delicious creamy ice cream.

Anthony Lorizio

Old school excellence! 6 stars

cathleen c

Depends on what matters to you…

Ice Cream. 4* …….if you’re willing to pay the high price.

Customer Service. 0* …..one girl specifically. However some are nice, respectful, and polite. (I’m old school with no tolerance for very poor customer service.)

Pricing 0*. Be wary
Every time i have gone- over a dozen + this year ( a lot bc my husband likes this ice cream), we get the same order (2 large with mixings side cone (pricing is always diff between $1-$2).
Tonight was $20 and change.

Question to owner, if customer waits up to 30mins for an order- most of which invlove mixins, why ex are jimmies ‘not allowed’ to be mixed in- Absurd! Ive ordered and recvd them mixed in multiple times. And several times recently Ive been told it is not allowed

Bottom Line. Customer service is more important than the ice cream here, because Brighams and Tillamook in your local grocery store are equally as good. Small business owner supporter- as long the service is appropriate. Ill spend my money elsewhere moving forward.

Brianna Mary

Great ice cream shop. Good service, very fresh batches! They mix ins toppings for you so they don’t just sit on top. Their regular flavors, monthly flavors, and one batch Wednesday flavors are always so good!! Had to stock up on this one batch horchata flavor, it was amazing!

Elizabeth S

Best homemade ice cream ever. They are located near the chocolate factory on Dorchester Avenue. Absolutely love their vegan ice cream. They make a new flavor about every week and a half. Lots of dairy flavors with all the candy sides! It’s a very small establishment best for parties of two or three people. sometimes I take my ice cream and sit outside on the bench that they have there.

Yan Courtois

The best ice-cream in the US. Possibly in the world! I know how it sounds. I stand by it!

Shona Pettiford

Delicious homemade ice cream with fast and friendly service!

Harte Dental

Always a fun selection of flavors and family owned and operated! They give back to the local community throughout the year. We love teaming up with them for our summertime Cavity Free Club! 🦷 🍦 They’re like the Mike’s Pastry of Lower Mills! Open late in the summer perfect for a dessert after dinner!

Barnett Walker

Standing in line at Ice Cream Smith lower mills...awesome ice cream! Fabulous service ... Check it out!!!

Jevon Shuler

It's always a pleasure getting ice cream here with my family. And make sure to try and guess the punchline to the joke of the day. You get a dollar off your next visit.

Mike S

Excellent

Isaac Balinski

Now THIS is an ice cream shop. Best quality, best mixins, best prices. I love you.

Mary Lou Snow

I usually have to tell them how to make an ice cream soda. Ice cream is very yummy!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Kewin Santos

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly size

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Pint

T J

Friendly service Ice cream is delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...