Buffy's Ice Cream
456 Main Street, Chatham
(508) 945-5990
Customers' Favorites
Cookie Bar
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My son and his fiancee wanted something different for the dessert at their wedding. They decided on the Chatham ice cream sandwich bars sold by Buffy's. We sampled all the flavors and narrowed it down to our two favorites: The Chatham Lighthouse Bar and the Great White Bar. While the regular size bars are yummy, we decided to get the minis. Buffy's delivered the bars in a freezer and had signs to let folks know what they would be eating. These ice cream sandwich bars...
Stopped into Buffy’s Ice Cream Café in Chatham and had an amazing experience! Nolan gave fantastic service and suggested I try the Salted Caramel Affogato—absolutely spectacular. The balance of the sweet ice cream with the rich espresso was perfect. Highly recommend—this place is a must-stop if you’re in Chatham!
Reviews said it was the best ice cream on the Cape and I am now a believer! Both sandwich and ice cream parts of our treats were amazing. Service was quick and friendly, outside setting is well kept and shady. Well worth the detour we took to enjoy Buffy’s sandwiches.
You May Also Like
Impudent Oyster - 15 Chatham Bars Ave
![]()
Seafood, Bar, Vegetarian
Aplaya Kitchen + Tiki Bar - 483 Main St
![]()
Tiki Bar, Filipino
Snowy Owl Coffee Espresso Bar - 483 Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee Roasteries, Bakery, Coffee, Pet Friendly