Great meal!! Highly recommend the ahi tuna entree. Pasta was wonderful as well.
Margaret
Very good service at the bar, the food was excellent. The sole and crab oscar was delicious and we also loved the clams casino and potstickers. Definitely go here if you are in town.
Victoria Choma
An delightful restaurant tucked inside an old church which was charming. Everything about this dining experience was perfect. I called a few weeks in advance to book a table for Father's Day. There were two options available: 5:15 or 8:30. I took the earlier seating that was available. Our waitress Melinda was wonderful. She was friendly and gave us outstanding service. Our food was simply delicious. The bread was warm with a savory rye flavor to it. I'm not a bread person but we couldn't stop eating it! The appetizer Oyster Rockefeller has such rich, delicious flavors, with a touch of lobster on top. I enjoyed the swordfish Rivera while my husband devoured each morsel in the Pesca Fra Diablo. Both meals were full of flavor and a good size portion. We passed on having dessert as unfortunately there wasn't anything that interested us. That part of the menu seemed to be lacking in comparison to the rest of the menu. The restaurant was very busy and all seats at the bar were taken. It's a place you definitely need to try... But remember to make a reservation in advance.
Craig Maser
The annual Pumpkins in the Park is something you should take in. After viewing the creations of some very talented people you can enjoy a nice walk around town and maybe even have lunch at the Impudent Oyster!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roll
Stephen Sampson
Wow this place was great! Super bartender and food was excellent. The place closes early and you need to get there as soon as they open because it’s super popular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Colleen Stevens
My favorite place for lunch in Chatham! We always sit at the bar (expect a wait to get a seat as it's first come/first serve) and love the atmosphere, bartender (Erica is amazing!), cocktails and food. Everything is really yummy but the Nantucket Scallop roll is a must try. Whether for lunch or dinner be sure to make a reservation. You're welcome. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nantucket, Chowder
Carmen Dajer
We had a wonderful dinner. The food was delicious and a very fun atmosphere. Only complaint is that we were rushed through our dinner. Food came very quickly after our appetizers. And after our meals and not wanting dessert, the bill arrived very promptly. Soon after placing the bill at at our table, our waitress grabbed it and asked if it was all set, even though it was obvious we hadn’t placed a credit card down. Her subtle way of telling us to pay. We had been sitting for less than an hour. Too expensive to be rushed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
John Grasso
Finally, after striking out twice in Chatham, we found a real winner. Terrific service, incredible selections, delicious food. Thank you, Inprudent Oyster!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Bennett
such a fun place to eat! really enjoyed the atmosphere, food & service. put our name in for lunch & waited about 15 minutes - it is a small waiting area & it does get crowded, i’d recommend putting your name in & pop into some shops around the corner to pass the time! the lobster roll was one of the best we’ve had & the onion rings are thin cut, crispy & delicious. cocktail menu is fun and fresh as well - we would absolutely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Berger
Great food, scallops were fabulous, potatoes salad fresh, very good, homemade. Keylime pie good w/ ginger snap crust
Came for oysters & happy we did. Excellent and super fresh from Wellfleet. Yum!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William “Will” Laplaca
Food is very good but also a little bit expensive, however, the portions are also very large.
The interior is a little smaller than anticipated but that is given the building size. There are two sections split by a staircase. The upper area has tables and booths. The bottom section has tables and the bar. The staff is friendly and polite too.
Parking: Parking lot on the property as well as several lots and parallel parking in the surrounding area. It can be harder to find parking on the weekend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Neil Hassett
We have been dining there for over 30 years and the place has gone downhill and finally hit bottom for us. I had the boulabaisse (sp?) and it was awful. The clams at the top were tough and the decorative mussels were well over 3 inches long (not delicate). The rather large oysters were not opened and could not be opened with either fork or butter knife (the only provided utensils - I am good at opening oysters). The fish and scallops were WAY overcooked to the point that I didn't try to eat much. Delicate was realized with the lobster claw - very small. To top it off was a large slice of bread with some type of mustard based fluid lined on it. Combine that with close tables and lots of noise and you have a very bad evening.
Great meal!!
Highly recommend the ahi tuna entree. Pasta was wonderful as well.
Very good service at the bar, the food was excellent. The sole and crab oscar was delicious and we also loved the clams casino and potstickers. Definitely go here if you are in town.
An delightful restaurant tucked inside an old church which was charming.
Everything about this dining experience was perfect.
I called a few weeks in advance to book a table for Father's Day. There were two options available: 5:15 or 8:30. I took the earlier seating that was available.
Our waitress Melinda was wonderful. She was friendly and gave us outstanding service. Our food was simply delicious. The bread was warm with a savory rye flavor to it. I'm not a bread person but we couldn't stop eating it!
The appetizer Oyster Rockefeller has such rich, delicious flavors, with a touch of lobster on top. I enjoyed the swordfish Rivera while my husband devoured each morsel in the Pesca Fra Diablo. Both meals were full of flavor and a good size portion.
We passed on having dessert as unfortunately there wasn't anything that interested us. That part of the menu seemed to be lacking in comparison to the rest of the menu.
The restaurant was very busy and all seats at the bar were taken. It's a place you definitely need to try... But remember to make a reservation in advance.
The annual Pumpkins in the Park is something you should take in. After viewing the creations of some very talented people you can enjoy a nice walk around town and maybe even have lunch at the Impudent Oyster!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roll
Wow this place was great! Super bartender and food was excellent. The place closes early and you need to get there as soon as they open because it’s super popular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite place for lunch in Chatham! We always sit at the bar (expect a wait to get a seat as it's first come/first serve) and love the atmosphere, bartender (Erica is amazing!), cocktails and food. Everything is really yummy but the Nantucket Scallop roll is a must try. Whether for lunch or dinner be sure to make a reservation. You're welcome. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nantucket, Chowder
We had a wonderful dinner. The food was delicious and a very fun atmosphere. Only complaint is that we were rushed through our dinner. Food came very quickly after our appetizers. And after our meals and not wanting dessert, the bill arrived very promptly. Soon after placing the bill at at our table, our waitress grabbed it and asked if it was all set, even though it was obvious we hadn’t placed a credit card down. Her subtle way of telling us to pay. We had been sitting for less than an hour. Too expensive to be rushed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Finally, after striking out twice in Chatham, we found a real winner. Terrific service, incredible selections, delicious food. Thank you, Inprudent Oyster!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
such a fun place to eat! really enjoyed the atmosphere, food & service. put our name in for lunch & waited about 15 minutes - it is a small waiting area & it does get crowded, i’d recommend putting your name in & pop into some shops around the corner to pass the time! the lobster roll was one of the best we’ve had & the onion rings are thin cut, crispy & delicious. cocktail menu is fun and fresh as well - we would absolutely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, scallops were fabulous, potatoes salad fresh, very good, homemade. Keylime pie good w/ ginger snap crust
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice place to visit if from out of town
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came for oysters & happy we did. Excellent and super fresh from Wellfleet. Yum!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is very good but also a little bit expensive, however, the portions are also very large.
The interior is a little smaller than anticipated but that is given the building size. There are two sections split by a staircase. The upper area has tables and booths. The bottom section has tables and the bar. The staff is friendly and polite too.
Parking: Parking lot on the property as well as several lots and parallel parking in the surrounding area. It can be harder to find parking on the weekend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been dining there for over 30 years and the place has gone downhill and finally hit bottom for us. I had the boulabaisse (sp?) and it was awful. The clams at the top were tough and the decorative mussels were well over 3 inches long (not delicate). The rather large oysters were not opened and could not be opened with either fork or butter knife (the only provided utensils - I am good at opening oysters). The fish and scallops were WAY overcooked to the point that I didn't try to eat much. Delicate was realized with the lobster claw - very small. To top it off was a large slice of bread with some type of mustard based fluid lined on it. Combine that with close tables and lots of noise and you have a very bad evening.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Great cocktails and bites.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...