Chilmark Tavern
$$$ • American, Vegetarian, New American Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout Chilmark Tavern
Customers' Favorites
Pan Seared Halibut with Summer Vegies
Fried Fish with French Fries
Ice Cream Sundae
Buffalo Brussels
Vegan Cassoulet
Poulet Frites
Tuna Tartare
Roast Chicken
Fish Chips
Carrots
Chilmark Tavern Reviews
169 ratings
Share your opinion about Chilmark Tavern
Great atmosphere friendly welcoming staff and love all your all the seafood 🦞 hugs to fluffy dog that hangs on the porch take out this year was very good come here every year
I love the Chilmark Tavern. Jenna and her staff are fantastic, and so is the food! I look forward to checking out their menu every year. The buffalo brussel sprouts live rent free in my mind, and I'm always very excited to see what vegan option they have on the menu, as they knock it out of the park every time. Hands down one of my favorite places on the island!
I was able to dine at Chilmark Tavern twice this summer and both dinners were fabulous. I will look forward to going again next summer. Thanks for the great service.
Hours
| Monday | 5 - 9:30PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 5 - 9:30PM |
| Friday | 5 - 9:30PM |
| Saturday | 5 - 9:30PM |
| Sunday | 5 - 9:30PM |
Chilmark Tavern is a popular spot in Menemsha that offers a warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant serves a variety of dishes, including homemade fettuccine bolognese, fish dish, and spatzel, all of which receive high praise. The BYOB policy is a unique feature since Chilmark is a dry town, and there is a corking fee for wine bottles. Many reviewers note that while the prices can be steep, they believe it's worth the splurge. The special of the day, such as the chicken pot pie, is often highlighted, and the service is consistently friendly and helpful. Customers have enjoyed dishes like the squid, fish and chips, and Halibut, which is perfectly cooked. Guests also love the buffalo brussel sprouts, and the vegan options are always a highlight. The dining experience feels like enjoying a great home-cooked meal, making it a great choice for special occasions or casual nights out. Chef Jenna and her staff are fantastic, and the mussels, pate, and poulet are favorites among regulars. The outdoor patio and main dining room can fill up quickly, especially on busy nights, so reservations are a must in the summer. Overall, Chilmark Tavern provides a cozy, welcoming environment with delicious food, accommodating service, and a comfortable atmosphere, making it a standout choice on the island.