Menemsha Fish Market

Name: Menemsha Fish Market
Address: 54 Basin Rd, Chilmark, Massachusetts, 02535, US
Telephone: (508) 645-2282
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$ • Seafood, Pet Friendly

Hours:
54 Basin Rd, Chilmark
(508) 645-2282

About Menemsha Fish Market

Menemsha Fish Market is a seafood market and lunch spot that offers a variety of fresh seafood options. The building has a nostalgic sea shanty look and sits on the Menemsha Basin, with commercial boats docked out back. As a market, Menemsha Fish Market offers a wide range of fresh seafood, including live lobsters and a variety of prepared foods like Lobster Rolls. For lunch, the take-out menu is somewhat limited, but the prepared options, such as cold Lobster Rolls and Clam Chowder, are delicious. The staff is friendly, and the outdoor seating area, with its makeshift tables, offers a pleasant spot to enjoy a meal on a cold day. One of the most popular elements is enjoying fresh seafood on simple benches by the water, creating a true New England feel. Visitors often recall the delicious Lobster Rolls, which are served without mayo, just juicy lobster. The lobster bisque is also highly praised, with some customers returning for a second bowl. The menu features items like the "sunset special," which includes a full lobster, crab cake, and stuffed scallop, all prepared fresh and quickly, despite the busy atmosphere. The staff is friendly and accommodating, making each visit enjoyable. The fresh lobster is easy to eat and perfect for sharing, while the crab cakes are flavorful, with a light coating that lets the crab taste shine. The stuffed scallop has a bit of spice, adding a little extra kick. Menemsha Fish Market is also known for its iconic lobster roll, considered the best on the island, ideal for enjoying while watching the sunset at Menemsha Beach. Many visitors find it to be the best place in Menemsha and look forward to returning for more delicious seafood and friendly service.