New American Restaurants near Edgartown, MA

“Got here just in time ! Shops and restaurants are starting to open up for the season so we had the island all to ourselves. Although It was a bit nippy, we enjoyed the sunshine during our walks through the sleepy towns - spotted Rockfish and because I was craving a lobster roll - in we came ! The roll was delicious, my husband's fish and chips crunchy and flavorful- our gracious server was HCristina (think I spelled that right) from Serbia and she was just charming and fabulous! Great meal and wonderful service!“

“Absolutely beautiful restaurant with fantastic service and excellent food. We love going early and having one of their outstanding drinks in one of their living rooms. The food is always superb and the setting is so romantic. We always celebrate our anniversary here. Highly recommended.“

“After a long day of sightseeing I just wanted to sit on the beach and have dinnner with my toes in the sand and my eyes on the sunset. Picked up some tuna salad, noodles, and a gigantic cookie - and the cutest dish towel souvenir - and had the perfect ending to a fabulous day. Thank you, Black Sheep Mercantile!!“

“Bettini Restaurant at the Harborview Hotel is must if you're visiting Martha's Vineyard. Both the dinner and lunch menus have something for every palate. Each entree is delicious and we enjoy the chef's preparation whether it's a grilled chicken sandwich with avocado or boneless duck breast in a delectable sauce. Save room for dessert. Nick the bartender makes excellent cocktails! Dining at Bettini is not just eating a meal, it's a dining experience with a stunning backdrop of the lighthouse and harbor. Mary the hostess is so welcoming and gracious. Check out the menus. Bettini is highly recommended!!“

“Decided to make this our last supper while staying in Edgartown and we were happy with our choice! We started with the brussel sprouts caesar and meatball special which was an appetizer that came with three small meatballs in an Asian style bbq sauce with crispy onions and coleslaw. Both were very tasty and shared easily between four people. The Brussels sprouts in the Caesar could've been a little crispier but all in all it was a tasty dish. We also split truffle fries which were very good with the aioli it comes with. For entrees, we tried the blackened mahi mahi with crab risotto, the cheeseburger, and the roasted chicken. Everyone loved what they got and had no complaints. Spicy mango margs and pineapple mojitos were had too! Service was very attentive and the atmosphere was nice.“

“Atria is one of the high end restaurants on the Vineyard. The food is good just the prices are exorbitant. I had swordfish on my last visit and it was a good. They have a vast wine selection and the carrot cake was delicious. They also have a downstairs bar that reminds you of a speakeasy. You can order food and drinks there as well. Great ambiance, Great service from the staff.“

“One of only 3 places we could find open on a mid week spring afternoon. Nice atmosphere. Affordable and the burger was delicious. Seemed fire grilled. Server was clearly not thrilled to be working but who really is, right? I was pleased to have found it and met our needs perfectly that day.“

“I planned a trip to the vineyard last July for 20 people. We went to the Barn Bowl & Bistro one evening for dinner and bowling. We reserved three lanes, which was perfect -- plenty of room for bowling and food. I was nervous about ordering food for such a large group, but the staff did an amazing job. All the orders were correct and the food came out quickly. The staff was exceptionally friendly and professional and even offered to take a photo of our group, which was no easy task.“

“We really enjoy visiting Offshore Ale Company when we are on the Vineyard. We love its warm, casual and inviting atmosphere. The vegan options aren’t extensive, but there are enough. This time we had a great pizza which they veganized by leaving off the cheese. This is one of our favorite places.“

“This review is based on our experience having dinner in November 2023.The Sweet Life was a truly surprise, an amazing hidden gem in Oak Bluffs, MV. The kitchen is audacious, their dishes show a genuine desire to take risks and whoever is in charge is delivering.Portions are correct, enough. Every ingredient has a purpose, each one has its moment in the journey. The grilled octopus resembles an interpretation of the Spanish dish pulpo a la gallega. The ricotta cavatelli is like if you were eating pasta with a hint of key lime pie. The anchovies in the mafalde, shout here we are!, but just at the right moment. And then, at the very end, you think all is over, the chocolate budino blows your head off.The service is attentive, simple, gracious. The ambiance, just like you'd expect from a place like this in MV. There's a disconnection with the 3-star menu and the rest of the place (not a complaint! is more like a compliment). You don't need the up-scale snobby set-up to deliver a fantastic experience.“

“This is a standard brewpub with several tv screens all around to watch the ongoing matches (including golf). We went on a Friday night in mid-April (early in the tourist season) and were pleasantly surprised to not only see this place open but almost packed! For reference, most restaurants on the island and in oak bluffs are closed at that time. Surprisingly, there was no music or sports commentary being played inside the tavern. Despite that the place was buzzing with chatter and didn't feel quiet/boring at all. The staff, including the host and our server were friendly and warm. The server offered to get beer tasters when I was pondering over my choice of beer. I'll give a thumbs up to both the IPA and the brick red beer on tap. To eat, we opted for the beer battered fish & chips and the fish sandwich. Portion size is on the larger side and taste wise, the food is decent. They are quite generous with the sauces & dips. The location of this tavern is fantastic; it overlooks the East Chop Lighthouse and beach and is a couple minutes away from both the oak bluffs ferry station and the oak bluffs bus stop.“

“The best! Celebrated my birthday here. Got a late dinner reservation and had cocktails and a bunch of appetizers with my sis and cousin. Crab rolls to due for! Charred cabbage a must. Lamb meatballs yummy! Street corn, house fries, shrimp! On the nearby table someone ordered the bouillabaisse which looked spectacular. Will have the next time I'm there for sure. A must visit in MV.“