Fisichelli's Pastry Shop
$$ • Bakery, VegetarianAbout Fisichelli's Pastry Shop
Fisichelli's Pastry Shop Reviews
98 ratings
Share your opinion about Fisichelli's Pastry Shop
Wanted a cake for my daughter’s nautical themed baby shower and they made it perfect! It was the best rum cake ever, the frosting was not overly sweet but more like whipped cream, delicious!! Nina is a true professional listened to all our needs and followed through above our expectations.thanks to all at Fisichelli’s 😊
My husband and I used Fisichelli's for our wedding cake and could not have been happier with the whole process! Nina made it incredibly easy, specially considering that we are not local to the area. The tasting was easy and fun -- we settled on the white cake with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream. We ordered a small cutting cake and two sheet cakes for our guests, and everything was absolutely incredible. We still have people talking about how delicious the cake was!...read full review
First time there today. It doesn't look like much on the outside but, looks are very deceiving. They have the BEST Rum cake and Italian cookies EVER. And I am sorry I didn't catch her name, but the owner is very kind. Thank you and looking forward to our next visit 😀
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 8:30AM - 3PM |
| Wednesday | 8:30AM - 5PM |
| Thursday | 8:30AM - 5PM |
| Friday | 8:30AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | 8:30AM - 5PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Fisichelli's Pastry Shop is a beautiful, family-owned, old school Italian bakery that has been family-run since 1915. This warm and inviting shop offers a wide variety of fresh and delicious pastries and cakes, including their famous macarons and pastachorthas. Nina and her team carry on the decades long tradition so nicely, making cakes that are works of art. Customers mention that the taste today is the exact same as they remember from 60 years ago, with time-honored, tried and true recipes. It's a treat to come here to celebrate holidays, birthdays, or any day. Fisichelli's also offers mail-order services, shipping their baked goods anywhere in the country. With its nostalgic atmosphere and lovely owners, this bakery is a must-visit destination.