Steel & Rye

95 Eliot St, Milton
(617) 690-2787

Recent Reviews

J R

Food and service was top notch.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joanne Mclean

First time at Steel & Rye, and it was great.Food was great, and the atmosphere was pleasant, but the service was outstanding!! Our waiter was excellent-he took really good care of us❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Kale Pizza, Steak

Sarah Mike Fortino

Another great meal at Steel and Rye, the pizza was amazing!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Ajith Vasudevan

Excellent American cuisine in this eatery with an industrial themed decor.We went for the almond bostock but sadly it was over. by the time we got there. Everything we had from the bakery was excellent but don’t let Anyone fool you into walking away after grabbing those.given that We did not get what we went all the way for, we then decided to stay for lunch and had excellent sandwiches and some very very good coffee. The malted milk mocha was worth mentioning in particular. The pizza oven looked very inviting, but we did not have anything from there. So that is definitely something to go back for. All said, excellent food and great service and ambience.Parking: Lots of parking on the street nearby and some near the restaurant itself in a small lot

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banh MI

Zelda Adams

My Favorite restaurant!! Always such a unique flavor to the food, it’s like eating a work of art! I love to split 2 meals with someone else to try some of each, they will split it for you. Drink- lavender latte. Entree- mushroom pappardelle pasta. Check out their bakery items too, amazing sourdough. Everything is great + service ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Justin T.

I finally got a chance to try out Steel & Rye! I was pleasantly surprised honestly didn't know what to expect. The food was great. I got the mussels which were huge and tasty and my friend and I shared a few items like the oysters and deviled eggs. All pretty good. The staff was also pretty friendly. I'd definitely go back.

Anthony L.

Always great!!! Always. Best cocktails!!! And best Cesar salad you'll ever have! Great spot for date night and with friends.

Samantha S.

Great menu, staff, and vibe. I go here all the time with my fiancé and it's a staple.

Michael P.

Excellent Great fun and atmosphere. Delicious food and drinks, great service. Great attitude. Definitely worth driving long distance for a great meal and a great experience

Miss the bread and butter. Brussel sprouts had an odd flavor that neither of us liked. Spinach gnudi were too large and I had had them before and loved them. Pineapple soda used to be served with a garnish and now seems simplified and not the same quality drink I had had in the past. Horrible smoke from the wood fired grill, my friend had to leave because she could not stop coughing. Used to be my favorite restaurant. Very disappointing.

KML1

Another perfect evening at Steel and Rye .... we have celebrated so many family events here and tonight was another one!! Thank you for being a part of our community and for all you do for our community!!

MelissaP

Was a busy Sunday there, our waitress was never around and took so long to get our pricey mimosas. The avocado toast has sliced avocados which i thought was strange but still good. An extra $2 per egg, seems like so much but this is what restaurants are doing now. The sour dough bread is phenomenal but also expensive, the cookies were delicious along with the coffee cake would go back but know its not cheap and service is slow

Nice place but service rushed us and delivered courses in the wrong order. Salad came after main dish. Server was confused when I asked for a menu of the store Rye selection, even though the name of the restaurant is Steel and Rye. My wife wanted another glass of wine but the server rushed us through so no time to order. Oh well.... Nice environment though.

Snowflake

We had not been to Steel & Rye for a couple of years. The decor and menu had changed in that time but the quality was still excellent. It is less formal and more comfortable but the food is presented beautifully and the quality is great! I hope to return many times.

Jordan P.

We go to this place so regularly they know us by name. The entire staff and food is so great. The environment is perfect for me and my fiancé to not only enjoy each other's company, but also get some accomplish some graduate school studies. We love this place so much.

Load More