Basement has the feel of an old fashioned bar n second floor is classy whiskey bar. Fish n chips chicken caprice onion soup nachos all excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Giovanni
While in Nantucket, this was one of my favorite restaurants to dine at. The atmosphere is fantastic, with a charming theme throughout. The drinks were flavorful and well-crafted, and the food was absolutely delicious—a must-try when visiting Nantucket. However, it is on the pricier side.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Haag
Tasty and atmospheric. From reading other reviews we were pre warned that we might wait for our food, but it wasn’t as bad as I expected. Our waitress was diligent about notifying me of gluten cross contamination after I ordered a gf bun, which I appreciate. I also loved that they had mock-tail options. It seemed a little pricey, but honestly everything on the island is. My husband ordered clam chowder, but it never came out. He also ordered a burger medium, but it came dry and charred. Since it is off season, I wonder if they are having kitchen staffing issues. 🤷🏻♀️
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Anthony Haag
Unique place to visit when on the island. Food was okay…ordered a brotherhood burger, medium, came out charred and dry, also order a bowl of clam chowder that never arrived. Over all food was ehh. It’s off season so that could be part of it. Gluten free option for the veggie burger was great. Service by Sabrina (not sure if spelling is correct) was absolutely wonderful.
Vegetarian options: Veggie burger
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free bun for burgers was one of the best we have had.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Curly Fries
Kathleen Avino
This was the 2nd time I have been to Brotherhoods of Thieves and this year at Thanksgiving is was just as fun walking in the door. The drinks, food and service was superb. We look forward to a visit again FIVE
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Connor Peterson
I’ve been here before and it was always good but today, not so much. There was a large table with a loud older man that kept yelling out loud. He then walked creepily around the restaurant touching children. The worst was that this man kept loudly passing gas and the stain in the back of his trousers made everyone realize that he had defecated himself. Additionally, a younger man,maybe the older man’s son, was stealing the flatwear.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 3
J Malone
My wife and I enjoyed dinner last evening in this upbeat, vibrant setting. The food was delicious, the atmosphere relaxing but energized with lots of conversation, laughter, and live music! We loved our servers Catalina and Brook, and to top it off the manager Jack by to speak with us. We had such a good time, we’re going back today for their lunch menu!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christian Verville
Excellent dishes, excellent service...get ready to take out your Canadian wallet $$$$ 😉
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kristen Freed
The best 🦞roll I have ever had, and the biggest shrimp 🦐 (🍹) I have ever seen. They reminded me of the ones in the dining room scene in the first 🪲🧃movie, lol. And the Spicy Guavarita OMG! 5⭐️’s➕!!!
There were 12 of us in for lunch on Thursday, October 17th, 2024. We were in the upstairs dining area. The food was great, but our waitress was horrible. She got mad because we all asked for separate checks, and whenever she printed them off, she slammed them on the table. As we paid, she asked several of us if that is all the tip you're giving. She was just very rude and a terrible attitude.. Some of our friends went in that afternoon and had the same problems.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Ken Breivik
Most tables are close together, so no private conversations. Our server was amazing. She was very attentive and engaging. Our burger was overcooked. We ordered medium and it was well done. We ordered 2 appetizers. The chesesteak egg rolls were delicious but the lettuce wraps were unusual and not liking to our taste. It was a fun choice for our first experience at Nantucket but just a little disappointing and expensive.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mykhaylo Bokhenok
Very nice outgoing and friendly staff! Slava Ukraini!
Kid-friendliness: The staff was very kind to my daughters and gave them coloring sheets
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brotherhood, Burger
Andrew Davinack
I’ve been here twice, both in November during the offseason: once for a business visit and the other for recreational. Both times were great experiences: the food is good, the atmosphere is warm and inviting like you’d expect in a traditional tavern and the service was impeccable. By far my favorite restaurant on the island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
S R
One of the few chill but good options here. Cheesesteak egg rolls are 🔥
Solid pub for the off season, I’ll be back.
Basement has the feel of an old fashioned bar n second floor is classy whiskey bar. Fish n chips chicken caprice onion soup nachos all excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
While in Nantucket, this was one of my favorite restaurants to dine at. The atmosphere is fantastic, with a charming theme throughout. The drinks were flavorful and well-crafted, and the food was absolutely delicious—a must-try when visiting Nantucket. However, it is on the pricier side.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tasty and atmospheric. From reading other reviews we were pre warned that we might wait for our food, but it wasn’t as bad as I expected. Our waitress was diligent about notifying me of gluten cross contamination after I ordered a gf bun, which I appreciate. I also loved that they had mock-tail options. It seemed a little pricey, but honestly everything on the island is. My husband ordered clam chowder, but it never came out. He also ordered a burger medium, but it came dry and charred. Since it is off season, I wonder if they are having kitchen staffing issues. 🤷🏻♀️
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Unique place to visit when on the island. Food was okay…ordered a brotherhood burger, medium, came out charred and dry, also order a bowl of clam chowder that never arrived. Over all food was ehh. It’s off season so that could be part of it. Gluten free option for the veggie burger was great. Service by Sabrina (not sure if spelling is correct) was absolutely wonderful.
Vegetarian options: Veggie burger
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free bun for burgers was one of the best we have had.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Curly Fries
This was the 2nd time I have been to Brotherhoods of Thieves and this year at Thanksgiving is was just as fun walking in the door. The drinks, food and service was superb. We look forward to a visit again
FIVE
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been here before and it was always good but today, not so much. There was a large table with a loud older man that kept yelling out loud. He then walked creepily around the restaurant touching children. The worst was that this man kept loudly passing gas and the stain in the back of his trousers made everyone realize that he had defecated himself. Additionally, a younger man,maybe the older man’s son, was stealing the flatwear.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 3
My wife and I enjoyed dinner last evening in this upbeat, vibrant setting. The food was delicious, the atmosphere relaxing but energized with lots of conversation, laughter, and live music! We loved our servers Catalina and Brook, and to top it off the manager Jack by to speak with us. We had such a good time, we’re going back today for their lunch menu!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent dishes, excellent service...get ready to take out your Canadian wallet $$$$ 😉
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The best 🦞roll I have ever had, and the biggest shrimp 🦐 (🍹) I have ever seen. They reminded me of the ones in the dining room scene in the first 🪲🧃movie, lol. And the Spicy Guavarita OMG! 5⭐️’s➕!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
There were 12 of us in for lunch on Thursday, October 17th, 2024. We were in the upstairs dining area. The food was great, but our waitress was horrible. She got mad because we all asked for separate checks, and whenever she printed them off, she slammed them on the table. As we paid, she asked several of us if that is all the tip you're giving. She was just very rude and a terrible attitude.. Some of our friends went in that afternoon and had the same problems.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Most tables are close together, so no private conversations. Our server was amazing. She was very attentive and engaging. Our burger was overcooked. We ordered medium and it was well done. We ordered 2 appetizers. The chesesteak egg rolls were delicious but the lettuce wraps were unusual and not liking to our taste. It was a fun choice for our first experience at Nantucket but just a little disappointing and expensive.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Very nice outgoing and friendly staff! Slava Ukraini!
Kid-friendliness: The staff was very kind to my daughters and gave them coloring sheets
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brotherhood, Burger
I’ve been here twice, both in November during the offseason: once for a business visit and the other for recreational. Both times were great experiences: the food is good, the atmosphere is warm and inviting like you’d expect in a traditional tavern and the service was impeccable. By far my favorite restaurant on the island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
One of the few chill but good options here. Cheesesteak egg rolls are 🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...