We enjoyed Brotherhood of Thieves. The food was great. Loved the Cisco Burger. The location, atmosphere and service were awesome. Our server was extremely friendly, attentive and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chrislene Tejeda
I would recommend this place over and over !!!!! First time here and the service was incredible! Every dish had a unique touch and the flavor was out of this world the drinks were really good as well ! Prices are fair can’t lie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Si na
We spent $200 for a family of 4. What we didn’t like was we were standing by the podium and the young girl did not acknowledge us. Inside, my husband and I ordered burgers, well done. Both our burgers were still bloody in the middle. I ate around the middle and told our waitress. No apology or tried to make it right by offering at least a desert. My husband got salad with his burger. The salad didn’t look washed and only had dressing on half of it. Considering our reservation was at 5:00pm- when they open, and the amount of money we paid, don’t think we’d ever return. Burrata appetizer was good- probably because it came out of a container.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
steeplechaser33
Loved it! What a menu, one of those places where you want to come back bc of the atmosphere and extensive menu that didnt look like it had a bad dish! Had the carribean buffalo chicken and the boom boom shrimp for appetizers and the salmon for entree. Wildly surpassed my expectations. Kudos to this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Justin Robinson
Very cool atmosphere. Service was fast and polite. The poke bowl, chicken cob salad, Cesar salad and spicy rigatoni were all great! The bar has local selections from Cisco brewery. I would definitely recommend eating here. Reservations are often necessary.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Blanton
We had a reservation for lunch at 1 pm. We arrived at 1230. Told our table would be ready between 1245-1 pm. As we waited, other people without reservations were coming up AND were seated. After another woman with a reservation at 1pm came up and was seated, I said something to the hostess, then we were seated. That was EXTREMELY frustrating when you are on the island for only a day! The wait staff was rude and inattentive. I will say the menu was diverse and everything we had to eat was good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Nikita Naidoo
Food was amazing !! Great atmosphere
Service on the other hand was not good at all But I’ve been here many times and I’ve always received good service So I guess this one time just spoilt it for me Overall it’s still my favorite place on the island
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
James Cape Cod
We were sat at the back outside section of the restaurant, which was nice. It was a beautiful day. Service was great. Drinks were yummy. I had a burger. That was delicious. Everyone else enjoyed their food. I would highly recommend and go back. I wish I took pictures, but I was so hungry I didn’t have.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Porter Stevens
Food was great. Fish was super fresh and the nigiri was fantastic. The crispy rice spicy tuna was incredible.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Donna Sugarman
Love it here. Sat at bar. Very friendly staff and patrons. Interesting menu. Poke bowl, lettuce wraps, burgers and great 🍸 🍹 🍸. I remember the cheddar cheese soup. Only serve in winter now
Had lunch here with my family during the busy 4th of July weekend. We only waited about 15–20 minutes for a table. Friendly staff, nice shaded outdoor patio with ceiling fans, and a great atmosphere. The lavender lemonade and lobster roll were delicious. No A/C was a bit of a bummer on a hot day, but we’d definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Videzza Navarro
The food was excellent, as always! The Boom Boom Shrimp is definitely one of the best and never disappoints.
It was my cousin’s first time visiting the island, and we chose to sit at the bar. Thomas provided outstanding customer service from the moment we arrived. He was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had a great experience.
Unfortunately, two of our orders were significantly delayed. Thomas politely checked with the food runner, Raquel, to follow up on our meals. While he was simply trying to ensure we received good service, Raquel responded with a tone and attitude that made us feel uncomfortable. It changed the atmosphere of what had been a wonderful evening.
I want to recognize Thomas for remaining professional throughout the situation. He genuinely cared about providing excellent service, and it showed. Keep up the great work, Thomas—you’re doing an amazing job!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Everything
Ken Schutt
Good for families and a number of dining options as far as cuisine go.
Andy Neubeck
Excellent place. Been here twice and both times it was excellent. Fried chicken sandwich and spicy rigatoni were what I got and I’d highly recommend giving it a try. Old historic atmosphere and excellent service. Highly recommended. Don’t miss the chocolate chip cookie sundae, simply amazing. :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Carr
Made a lunch stop here with 11 women for my sister in laws bachelorette weekend. We couldn’t have chosen a better spot. The food, drinks and service were all phenomenal (we all LOVED the raspberry lemon drop martini and the coconut margarita!) We were lucky enough to sit in the upstairs event room which was gorgeous, and our servers went over the top to give us a great experience, we spent all lunch laughing and enjoying the food/atmosphere. We will definitely be revisiting on our next Nantucket trip and highly recommend stopping in!!
We enjoyed Brotherhood of Thieves. The food was great. Loved the Cisco Burger. The location, atmosphere and service were awesome. Our server was extremely friendly, attentive and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I would recommend this place over and over !!!!! First time here and the service was incredible! Every dish had a unique touch and the flavor was out of this world the drinks were really good as well ! Prices are fair can’t lie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We spent $200 for a family of 4. What we didn’t like was we were standing by the podium and the young girl did not acknowledge us. Inside, my husband and I ordered burgers, well done. Both our burgers were still bloody in the middle. I ate around the middle and told our waitress. No apology or tried to make it right by offering at least a desert. My husband got salad with his burger. The salad didn’t look washed and only had dressing on half of it. Considering our reservation was at 5:00pm- when they open, and the amount of money we paid, don’t think we’d ever return. Burrata appetizer was good- probably because it came out of a container.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Loved it! What a menu, one of those places where you want to come back bc of the atmosphere and extensive menu that didnt look like it had a bad dish! Had the carribean buffalo chicken and the boom boom shrimp for appetizers and the salmon for entree. Wildly surpassed my expectations. Kudos to this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very cool atmosphere. Service was fast and polite. The poke bowl, chicken cob salad, Cesar salad and spicy rigatoni were all great! The bar has local selections from Cisco brewery. I would definitely recommend eating here. Reservations are often necessary.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a reservation for lunch at 1 pm. We arrived at 1230. Told our table would be ready between 1245-1 pm. As we waited, other people without reservations were coming up AND were seated. After another woman with a reservation at 1pm came up and was seated, I said something to the hostess, then we were seated. That was EXTREMELY frustrating when you are on the island for only a day! The wait staff was rude and inattentive. I will say the menu was diverse and everything we had to eat was good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Food was amazing !!
Great atmosphere
Service on the other hand was not good at all
But I’ve been here many times and I’ve always received good service
So I guess this one time just spoilt it for me
Overall it’s still my favorite place on the island
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
We were sat at the back outside section of the restaurant, which was nice. It was a beautiful day. Service was great. Drinks were yummy. I had a burger. That was delicious. Everyone else enjoyed their food. I would highly recommend and go back. I wish I took pictures, but I was so hungry I didn’t have.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was great. Fish was super fresh and the nigiri was fantastic. The crispy rice spicy tuna was incredible.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Love it here. Sat at bar. Very friendly staff and patrons. Interesting menu. Poke bowl, lettuce wraps, burgers and great 🍸 🍹 🍸. I remember the cheddar cheese soup. Only serve in winter now
Restaurantji Recommends
Had lunch here with my family during the busy 4th of July weekend. We only waited about 15–20 minutes for a table. Friendly staff, nice shaded outdoor patio with ceiling fans, and a great atmosphere. The lavender lemonade and lobster roll were delicious. No A/C was a bit of a bummer on a hot day, but we’d definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was excellent, as always! The Boom Boom Shrimp is definitely one of the best and never disappoints.
It was my cousin’s first time visiting the island, and we chose to sit at the bar. Thomas provided outstanding customer service from the moment we arrived. He was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had a great experience.
Unfortunately, two of our orders were significantly delayed. Thomas politely checked with the food runner, Raquel, to follow up on our meals. While he was simply trying to ensure we received good service, Raquel responded with a tone and attitude that made us feel uncomfortable. It changed the atmosphere of what had been a wonderful evening.
I want to recognize Thomas for remaining professional throughout the situation. He genuinely cared about providing excellent service, and it showed. Keep up the great work, Thomas—you’re doing an amazing job!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Everything
Good for families and a number of dining options as far as cuisine go.
Excellent place. Been here twice and both times it was excellent. Fried chicken sandwich and spicy rigatoni were what I got and I’d highly recommend giving it a try. Old historic atmosphere and excellent service. Highly recommended. Don’t miss the chocolate chip cookie sundae, simply amazing. :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Made a lunch stop here with 11 women for my sister in laws bachelorette weekend. We couldn’t have chosen a better spot. The food, drinks and service were all phenomenal (we all LOVED the raspberry lemon drop martini and the coconut margarita!) We were lucky enough to sit in the upstairs event room which was gorgeous, and our servers went over the top to give us a great experience, we spent all lunch laughing and enjoying the food/atmosphere. We will definitely be revisiting on our next Nantucket trip and highly recommend stopping in!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...