Brotherhood of Thieves
23 Broad St, Nantucket
(774) 325-5812
Customers' Favorites
Fried Chicken Sandwich with Curly Fries
New England Clam Chowder
Blackened Swordfish
French Onion Soup
Boom Boom Shrimp
Tuna Poke Bowl
Lobster Rolls
Fish and Chips
Veggie Burger
Steak Frites
Menu
Photos
+52 photos
+51 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
While in Nantucket, this was one of my favorite restaurants to dine at. The atmosphere is fantastic, with a charming theme throughout. The drinks were flavorful and well-crafted, and the food was absolutely delicious—a must-try when visiting Nantucket. However, it is on the pricier side.
Tasty and atmospheric. From reading other reviews we were pre warned that we might wait for our food, but it wasn’t as bad as I expected. Our waitress was diligent about notifying me of gluten cross contamination after I ordered a gf bun, which I appreciate. I also loved that they had mock-tail options. It seemed a little pricey, but honestly everything on the island is. My husband ordered clam chowder, but it never came out. He also ordered a burger medium, but it came dry...
Unique place to visit when on the island. Food was okay…ordered a brotherhood burger, medium, came out charred and dry, also order a bowl of clam chowder that never arrived. Over all food was ehh. It’s off season so that could be part of it. Gluten free option for the veggie burger was great. Service by Sabrina (not sure if spelling is correct) was absolutely wonderful.
Vegetarian options: Veggie burger
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free...
Vegetarian options: Veggie burger
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free...
You May Also Like
Ethos Wine Bar & Bistro - 18 Broad St
![]()
Wine Bar, Cocktail Bar, Lounges
The Corner Table Cafe - 22 Federal St
![]()
Cafe, American, Vegetarian
Born & Bread: Mercantile and Bakery - 35 Centre St
![]()
Bakery, Pet Friendly