I Love Italian Pizza

68 Newbury Ave, Quincy
(617) 770-5650

Recent Reviews

Sort by
emi chin

A neighborhood local joint that’s been here for 10 years. The portions are generous. Friendly welcoming workers.

Aaron Simons

God I miss this place. Hope you’re all doing well. Hope to visit sometime soon. Awesome buffalo chicken and blue cheese here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jonathan Chery

I cannot believe how good this pizza is. I was coming home from school and ordered 20 minutes before close and they made me 2 pizzas with no issues. I did not expect to have a thin perfect no flop crusted pizza with insane flavor. It was just close by! Have to put this place at #1 in Massachusetts.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Belcher

Got orders from here via Uber Eats twice with very different results depending on the items we got.

Barbecue chicken pizza was really good. Fish and chips also good. Fries are nothing to write home about but the fish was solid and the onion rings are very tasty.

Got pasta with chicken parm this time and the results were unfortunately similar to a lot of these kinds of Greek pizza places... Soggy, cheap ziti, with so little sauce that it's completely overtaken by the excess water from the pasta and it's like eating pasta in water. It tastes like they water down their sauce. Chicken is ok.. processed chicken as opposed to fresh, but ok as far as processed chicken goes. Really sdisappointing.

Hummus and falafel wrap had to be autopsied to find any trace of falafel... Tiny crumbs of falafel were barely even identifiable, and not even remotely tastable.

Unless we just really lucked out the first time we had it, this should be a solid choice for pizza, not I wouldn't bother with anything else on their menu.

There's got to be like 100 things on their menu, and the terrible quality reflects that.

Food: 3

Jessica L

I don’t understand the good reviews for their food. The slices of cheese were received were…gross. There is no other word I can give. I think the pizza must have been out all day & most likely warmed up for me. The tips of the slices have grease pooled on it- the pizza had a darker colored hue-like it had been out. It also looked for like Greek style pizza than it did Italian. I immediately threw them out. I wish I took a picture before I did so that I could show anyone who reads this. My first time in there & it will be my last. Nice atmosphere but gross food

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Lucy Alvarez

Good food I love Italian Pizza is the best in North Quincy I order the Sicilian veggeterian last week and it was delicious….

Justin W.

Perfect crust

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexander Erazo

I love italian pizza, its one of my favotites they make bafulo calzon and pizza the best in quincy ❤️❤️❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

crackofdon

The only pizza shop I order from. Never got a bad pizza. The best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kellen Hurley

Best slice I’ve had in Quincy. I just tried it for the first time and I’m thinking about going back and getting 2 more slices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony S

Disappointing with the size of the pizza, even though they told me they were large pies and salads were small for an order for 10 people. Ordered a few pies and the size of each was close to individual pizza pie.

Say it like I see it.

I have never gone to the south shore without stopping and getting food to take home. Everything here is absolutely awesome.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nic C

Great pizza and friendly owner.
I always wanted to go here and I’m glad I did!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Brito

First time grabbing a bite from here after walking by it so many times. Got some pineapple pizza that is delicious and doesn’t skimp on the pineapples. Wife got spaghetti and she enjoyed it. Rated it 4/5. I tried some and think it is pretty good, especially with the layer of cheese they put on the top. Solid spot and will be on my rotating list of lazy day food spots.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joe Sztenderowicz

Good food place a little run down

Loading...