Goodnight Fatty
1 Washington Square, Salem
(978) 822-2277
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate and Vanilla Mixed Soft Serve Ice Cream with a Cookie
Cookies with Soft Serve Ice Cream
Assorted Gourmet Cookies
Reese’S Peanut Butter
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Mixed Swirl Ice Cream
S'Mores Cookie Vegan
Vanilla Soft Serve
Flight of Cookies
Nutella Bomb Fatty
Menu
Photos
+64 photos
+63 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I went with my omni husband and asked if they had a vegan cookie despite the menu showing none. To my surprise they did, so try asking if you ever stop by! It was a chocolate chip cookie with oreos on the top. I also got the hot apple cider, make sure to specify no caramel sauce!
Updated from previous review on 2025-11-01
Simple, delicious cookies! We loved the three flavors of the week and wish we could’ve tried more. Soft, rich, and perfectly baked — definitely a must-stop when you’re in Salem.
Cool concept, who doesn't like warm cookies with milk. They have limited options ( 3 cookie options when we visited). The flavors were unique ( Milky Way, Count Chocula, PB). They didn't have simple plain chocolate chip or sugar cookies. The cookies were average. You can purchase cookie flights!
They have a cute courtyard with outside seating (tables and chairs).
No vegan options available.
They also serve breakfast sandwiches,...
They have a cute courtyard with outside seating (tables and chairs).
No vegan options available.
They also serve breakfast sandwiches,...
You May Also Like
The Tavern - 18 Washington Square W
![]()
American, Pubs, Gluten-Free, Vegan
Olde Main Street Pub - 121 Essex St
![]()
Gastropubs, American, Pubs, Irish, New American
Nathaniel's Restaurant - 18 Washington Square W
![]()
American, Vegan