Pizza Restaurants near West Tisbury

“This is next to a great grocery market in the area (small "town") - bought a few years back (it's the old Fella's in West Tisbury) ; nestled in between the only grocery open year round close to up-island and next to the post office, also the only one in area that services this small town of mostly farm land. It was discovery of a coworker who was ranting about their bfast sandwiches- YEA - they are pretty spectacularly tasty!! I have had 4 items from this menu and today... I tried the pizza- I ATE THE CRUST - soft enough with a slight crunch - perfect dough, sauce was seasoned and is homemade- excellent. Best lil' spot to catch a quick bite. They are a slice app customer!!! Excellent!“

“So Laura and I stopped here last night after missing our ferry off the great island of Martha's Vineyard. It was a pleasant surprise as we both ordered a Caesar's Salad wrap with grilled chicken. Simply put it was the best Caesar's salad wrap I've ever had. We ordered the same exact wrap and they were very hearty wraps either a good proportion of lettuce and chicken. Lots of tasty grilled chicken and expertly wrapped. No spillage and quite satisfying. They have an adjacent bakery where they sell all kinds tasty looking sweets and also ice cream. Laura picked up a fresh French bread for our brunch today. Based on our impromptu visit last night I would recommend this great cafe. Salud!“

“Rocco's pizza is our favorite pizza restaurant on the vineyard. The veggie pizza is our favorite as well as the freshly made salads. The staff is so friendly, kind and pleasant. It's a great place to grab a slice at lunch or dinner, order pizzas and salad when you get together with friends, or sit outside and enjoy your food.Parking: There is plenty of parking. I have never had trouble parking when picking up pizza or eating it there.“

“Every time my wife and I visit the Island, we make sure to stop by Island Fresh. The food and service are top quality—best pizza and subs on the Island, hands down. Do yourself a favor and give them a try, you’ll be happy that you did.“

“My wife and I just passed by and we decided to try just because of the name. Turned out to be the BEST place we ate on our vacation. At first I thought the chowder was a little thin but once we dug in we found it to be the best chowder we had out of at least 10 places, it was so chunky and flavorful! This was the first place we tried a lobster roll and we fell in love with the place. We made it a priority to go back before we left the island! EAT HERE!“