50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Yarmouth

“Crisp never lets me down. Excellent flatbreads and quick friendly service. Scallop and bacon and short ribs are the favorites but you can never go wrong at Crisp!!! Give it a try, it will become your new favorite place for takeout.“

“I had a roast beef sandwich and curly fries earlier this week. Both were outstanding. The roast beef was soft, tender and very flavorful. It was on a toasted onion roll. I asked for horseradish on the sandwich. It was fantastic. The curly fries could not have been better.“

“Friendly and efficient bar service, good pizza and wings, and a fun sports bar atmosphere!“

“This place was great! Pizza was delicious and service very kind and helpful. Prices were fair and the quality totally matched. We sat outside and the atmostphere was awesome! I recommend it for family or couples. It's a great spot to eat dinner on the Main st. I recommend!“

“I love sweet tomatoes, I've been visiting ever since I got a job that required me to travel around on the cape, I've been here over 50 times in the past 3 years and never once have I been disappointed with there fresh slices always ready and hot in less than 5 minutes perfect lunch for anyone on the go looking for a delicious lunch with plenty of verity“

“My husband and I have a cottage around the corner and discovered this gem! I’m a bit of a pizza snob and this is great bar room pizza! We regularly order the mushroom pizza and bacon pizza and love it. Highly recommend“

“We head to the Cape fairly regularly during the summer and this is the only place that is a true MUST every time. Never had a bad meal or experience. Management and ownership really do a great job! Customer for life here“

“Anthony, Luna, and Jordan were extremely helpful with our large order. Everything was ready on time, prepared, well, down to the plates, napkins, and utensil. Would recommend for small or large groups. They are well equipped to handle crowds.“

“Greatest pizza ever!! Service outstanding!!“

“My family and I went here for Thanksgiving. It was such a wonderful experience and made a special day even better. Everything from the food to the service was impeccable. Thank you so much for a wonderful experience!“

“Highly recommend! All employees are friendly and helpful and the ice cream is amazing!! And you can’t forget about the awesome merch they have, cannot wait to rep Pizza Shark in Florida!!“

“Decorations, service, food, atmosphere awesome as always!!!! thank you!“

“Best calazones on cape period and the roasted garlic and herb chicken fingers are best I’ve ever had ….“

“Best pizza on cape. It's fun standing in line waiting to lay for my pizza during the summer months because the line is usually full of tourists visiting the area. Whether they're from Connecticut, New York, Chicago, or California, they all talk about how the pizza tastes like home. Prices are great too, especially for the sizes they have! We usually get one monster size for our family of 4 and have a quarter left over for some awesome left overs.Sometimes they can be disorganized with order taking etc... But for the chaos and amount of business they get, they handle it well.“

“Friendly staff and the pizza was delicious. Definately 5 out of 5 stars“

“I don't often give reviews but I just had to give this place huge kudos. My first impression was how clean it is. The kitchen was spotless. No trash on the floor, no dirty tables. And the restrooms are so clean (that's a huge deal for me). So clean I had to mention it to the owner. You know if a restroom is clean, the the staff takes pride in their establishment. The staff is very personable. But the food for a pizza place was so good. The price is quite reasonable. The sub rolls were super fresh. The steak was not fatty (thank goodness). The salad was super fresh and the feta was amazing. I told my husband this is my sub shop. Thanks for the great service!“

“It was nice to be back and I loved the remodel. Most important, the food is still the best! Love me a toasted Italian cold cut sub with hots!“

“Great Food Great Service will definitely be back“

“The pizza was good. For a mall pizza place this pie was hitting good. I will say it reminds me of papa Gino’s Pizza tangy sauce, the cheese, the smell, even the dough reminded me of Papa Gino’s pizza. But it’s Regina Puzza and it was good. Looking for more reviews check out review time with Tim on YouTube.

Parking: Big mall parking lot

Kid-friendliness: Yes the kids will like this pizza

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it’s in a mall“

“Wife & I bought a half tray of Chix-Parm for a dinner party...MEOW!!!! 'nuff food for 10...2 DIE 4..X-ra sauce 'n bread...again MEOW“

“We have been coming here for years. Our orders are always correct, employees are friendly and the food is great. Tonight we had a problem with a gift card we gave as a Christmas gift. My husband went down to the store and the owners (I think) were very gracious and were quick to resolve the issue. We are very appreciative for their handling of our problem.“

“Friendly Staff. Good meals. Nice variety of food.“

“Everyone was very friendly polite and professional- but in a casual comfortable way!“

“Great fresh food, excellent service, relaxing, clean and beautifully designed atmosphere. Welcoming to celebratory experiences.“

“Pizza and quesidillas were delicious! Everyone was very friendly and the large order we placed was done in less than half an hour. A couple of issues...we never got a small order of Mexican rice but we were never charged for it. Also, the prices are higher than on the site.“

“Such a great find in Dennis! Fresh, creative ingredients packed with flavor. Will definitely be back to explore the rest of the menu.“

“First time trying and I will be back! I had a burger and it was perfectly cooked! I also loved the garlic sauce that came with the fries. Genius idea! My son tried the chicken Alfredo pizza and loved it!“

“I went to Domino's Pizza because of a special event they were running for take-out only,
The location is easy accessible with plenty of parking as it is in a strip mall on Station Ave. In South Yarmouth Massachusetts.
When I walked in I noticed the place was very clean and the employees behind the counter were very friendly and helpful.
The Pizza I ordered (on line) was a large mushroom and onion pizza with a orange soda,it was very tasty, but there wasn't enough extras on it to make it excellent and the extras that were on the pizza were closer to the crust and not distributed even.
This pizza shop could become a five star place if they used more condiments.“

“Big shout out to Maddie who was so friendly tonight, brought my pizza round back and was kind and professional on the phone and in person. You were raised well, girl, and you're a stellar human. You're going to go far in this world!“

“I've been going here for 10 plus years, and not a whole lot has changed, honestly. A pretty quick paced, very friendly small pizza joint. I've always gotten pizza from here and slowly shifted to subs. The subs have definitely gotten smaller over the years which is a big downfall for me because they're phenomenal obviously they have to raise prices to match the economy but the sizes shouldn't be going down otherwise I'd change my review.“

“We accidentally went to this restaurant. It was the best accident. Now I say we found it by luck. The workers are friendly and the food very good. We've gotten pizza, calzones, grinders and wraps. All were very good. Looking forward another visit on our next trip.“

“Great service , amazing lunch. The quiche, French onion soup, fries, salad, drinks, wine and bread were top notch. Can’t wait to come back. We took home Lots of bread too!! Sells out very quickly!!“

“Best Domino's I've ever had! The food was delicious, quick, and affordable! Very clean and friendly environment! The best part is their manager, Kirsten! She is the absolute icing on the cake to a consistent home run experience! Thank you Kirsten and the Hyannis team! Will always eat here!!!

Kid-friendliness: Very welcoming and family friendly!“

“Delicious pizza and the crust is very crunchy, got steak and cheese it was bomb! Great and friendly crew, highly recommended!����“

“Went for the first time last night. The employees were super friendly and the food was great. Pizza was just as good for breakfast this morning. definitely recommend“

“I can go over board with what I like at Paradise. Tried alot on the menu it's all been good.My favorite would have to be 1rst place goes to the veal.Weather it be a sub or a dinner . 2 nd place goes to the salads always a huge portion and so fresh. New on the menu 3rd place has to go to the Clam cakes so yummy. I can honestly say I have never in 6 years living in Dennis have I ever said this isnt good.“

“There were days this place was terrible and I had to fight seriously with the owner years and years ago. The owner changed and new stuff came and all turned amazing. I order pizza from here with no hesitation for my friends and family, it is always fresh, well cooked and it is always clean inside too. Maybe little improvement would be a plus inside for diners.

Parking: It’s a plaza parking and always have space even during busy summer season

Kid-friendliness: It is fun for kids shopping here. Pizza is made in front of you like a showroom.

Wheelchair accessibility: Ground level with big doors“

“Wonderful place. Lovely live music. Probably the best place in the area to gather the family.“

“The Shrimp Diavolo is amazing! The entire dish was prepared just right and the bread was also great. I highly recommend this restaurant when on the Cape.“

“Top five pizza in Cape Cod. Outstanding“

“My husband and I loved it!! I had the braised ribs and he had the margarita pizza with mushrooms, cooked perfectly. The braised ribs were served on mashed potatoes with a mix of veggies that added to the dish. Cathy was our server and she was fantastic. we will definitely be back.“

“Went yesterday for his Wednesday Carolina Whole Hog Cookery ant Barnstable Brewing…. absolutely fantastic! Great beer and if you’ve never had a pulled pork sammich from an at least 6hr bbq’d piggie, get down there b4 the summer’s over.. tyvm JP…“

“Great food and fantastic staff. They truly made our daughters 12th birthday special.“

“Read the other reviews after dining and must agreed. Food fabulous, the staff we thought was Mexican maybe and the host (not sure if he was the owner) was the rudest.
Ordered the eggplant, asked for little sauce which they accommodated and it was the best I’ve had in a long time, ordered the fried artichoke for appetizer which was fabulous, my kids pizza was average and my husbands (chicken palm) was excellent. But everything came with no smile. While the staff was attentive and accommodating they never smiled. Did not order drinks - lemonade instead which the host seemed disgusted with us. If your looking for a great meal with no ambience I would recommend.“

“First time trying. We tried Cheese Pizza, loaded fries and fried Oreos. Everything was great! We will definitely be back!“

“After the movies last night, we were starving and needed a place that served food around 9 p.m., so thankfully, we found this place. The downside was that they only served appetizers after 9 pm. That was fine because at least they had food. Most bars stop serving all food around then. We got clam chowder, which was a bit salty, but it was okay. We also got three types of wings. We got Buffalo, BBQ, and a Garlic Parmesean dry rub on the tenders/boneless wings. Our waitress was very nice, but it seemed like she kept forgetting about us after giving us our food, so another guy had to check on us and grab our plates. My boyfriend also got sick from his chicken tenders, so yikes! But it was a very nice place overall.“

“Decided to try another local spot for dinner. Checked out their menu a head of time and their daily special of chicken pie and other specials seemed like a winner. We ordered 2 chicken pie dinners which came with a garden salad and mashed potato and butternut squash. The pie was very flavorful with a light flaky shell. The butternut squash was flavorful without being overly sweet or spiced. The mashed potato’s were homemade and lacked a little spice. Also ordered the fried scallops which she said were very flavorful And tender. We’ll definitely be coming back here again. These prices were very reasonable. $55 for our 3 meals.“

“Beautiful restaurant, nice views and wonderful food and cocktails.“

“Was late for lunch for us. Wanted a slice of pizza with my Mexican food so I was bummed I didn’t get any because they only do slices at lunchtime. The place is a combination pizza - sub shop and a Mexican restaurant. The atmosphere was nice and they even have one of the old Ms Pac-Man games which we have played for a few decades coming here. I got the Mexican sampler which was an enchilada and a burrito with sour cream and black olives and a soft taco I got the chicken but you can get whatever and if you prefer the hard shell you can get that too. We got chicken fingers they were really juicy and tender. Apps we got chips and salsa and Italian dip with is basically like garlic bread strips with mozzarella cheese dipped in a red sauce. Overall the place was quiet and super air conditioned. Today was 85 out and inside you would never guess. They have plenty of seating. Booth style but really comfy to sit and enjoy a meal. My mom had to eat here weekly when she was alive and that’s saying a lot. She was picky for food out at restaurants. My whole family loves it here and we have been eating here for decades. They do have a good selection of bottled beers too. It’s a 100% recommend.“