49 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Yarmouth

“I had a roast beef sandwich and curly fries earlier this week. Both were outstanding. The roast beef was soft, tender and very flavorful. It was on a toasted onion roll. I asked for horseradish on the sandwich. It was fantastic. The curly fries could not have been better.“

“It was nice to be back and I loved the remodel. Most important, the food is still the best! Love me a toasted Italian cold cut sub with hots!“

“Decided to try another local spot for dinner. Checked out their menu a head of time and their daily special of chicken pie and other specials seemed like a winner. We ordered 2 chicken pie dinners which came with a garden salad and mashed potato and butternut squash. The pie was very flavorful with a light flaky shell. The butternut squash was flavorful without being overly sweet or spiced. The mashed potato’s were homemade and lacked a little spice. Also ordered the fried scallops which she said were very flavorful And tender. We’ll definitely be coming back here again. These prices were very reasonable. $55 for our 3 meals.“

“Crisp never lets me down. Excellent flatbreads and quick friendly service. Scallop and bacon and short ribs are the favorites but you can never go wrong at Crisp!!! Give it a try, it will become your new favorite place for takeout.“

“The young girl that answered the phone and working the counter is rude, and should not be working with the public. She’s the face of your restaurant, and you’re doing yourself a great disservice.

Love your pizza & salads though. You could just do better.“

“We head to the Cape fairly regularly during the summer and this is the only place that is a true MUST every time. Never had a bad meal or experience. Management and ownership really do a great job! Customer for life here“

“Pizza Barone catered our 20th Wedding Anniversary party! the pizza was fantastic and the Service was outstanding!! I highly recommend them!“

“Great little spot for pizza, meatball sub, darts, and pool. Food was great, staff were excellent! Highly recommend this place.“

“My family and I went here for Thanksgiving. It was such a wonderful experience and made a special day even better. Everything from the food to the service was impeccable. Thank you so much for a wonderful experience!“

“Anthony, Luna, and Jordan were extremely helpful with our large order. Everything was ready on time, prepared, well, down to the plates, napkins, and utensil. Would recommend for small or large groups. They are well equipped to handle crowds.“

“Wife & I bought a half tray of Chix-Parm for a dinner party...MEOW!!!! 'nuff food for 10...2 DIE 4..X-ra sauce 'n bread...again MEOW“

“Another great meal from Austin's Pizza in Dennis. We hopped on the special deal of 2 cheese pizzas and a order of wings for $20. We went with 2 orders. Everything was perfect. The pizzas were crispy and hot, the wings were juicy and flavorful, but not drowned in sauce. They were perfect! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!“

“Great fresh food, excellent service, relaxing, clean and beautifully designed atmosphere. Welcoming to celebratory experiences.“

“This place is incredible. Amazing pizza, fast service, 10/10. They even gave my daughter pizza tattoos 💕“

“Friendly staff and the pizza was delicious. Definately 5 out of 5 stars“

“It is out go to place when friends and family are in town because there is something for everyone and the food is consistently delicious. Our waitress this last visit was new to serving and she was really nice. Thank you for serving us Silviane.“

“Been going to The Shark for a year now, as usual, everything was perfect. Best pizzas we've ever had. Love the Aloha Reef pizza, good pineapple/ham ratio, great Wedge salad, too.Easy online ordering, nice counter service. Excellent 👌👌!!“

“We've had nothing but great service, food is excellent and it's just an overall fun time! We would highly recommend 👌“

“Best calazones on cape period and the roasted garlic and herb chicken fingers are best I’ve ever had ….“

“Must have new owners or something. People answering the phone barely understand English, nevermind speak it properly. Wait times are up and orders are frequently wrong. Food quality is getting questionable for example the steak and cheese sub is different. Very disappointed, was my favorite neighborhood market and deli. DO BETTER!!!“

“Great Food Great Service will definitely be back“

“Delicious pizza and the crust is very crunchy, got steak and cheese it was bomb! Great and friendly crew, highly recommended!����“

“The pizza was good. For a mall pizza place this pie was hitting good. I will say it reminds me of papa Gino’s Pizza tangy sauce, the cheese, the smell, even the dough reminded me of Papa Gino’s pizza. But it’s Regina Puzza and it was good. Looking for more reviews check out review time with Tim on YouTube.

Parking: Big mall parking lot

Kid-friendliness: Yes the kids will like this pizza

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it’s in a mall“

“Great team, great service, great food. Excellent dining experience. Keep up the awesome!!“

“always awesome! I get a pie there weekly. the girls at the front desk are so friendly“

“Best pizza I have ever had!!! I couldn’t believe how quickly we got our pizza! My twins are very picky about pizza and couldn’t believe we have never heard of the is place! The owner said he has owned it almost 50 years! Definitely recommend it. I will only be going to this pizza place from now on!“

“Big shout out to Maddie who was so friendly tonight, brought my pizza round back and was kind and professional on the phone and in person. You were raised well, girl, and you're a stellar human. You're going to go far in this world!“

“Pizza and quesidillas were delicious! Everyone was very friendly and the large order we placed was done in less than half an hour. A couple of issues...we never got a small order of Mexican rice but we were never charged for it. Also, the prices are higher than on the site.“

“This is a great spot! We have only been twice ( so far) but both times = great! Food was yummy and the people are so nice!!! Truly! Looking forward to going back- highly recommend!“

“Top five pizza in Cape Cod. Outstanding“

“Friendly Staff. Good meals. Nice variety of food.“

“I know some people have not given this place very good reviews but we have only had good experiences here. We have only been twice, both times we were at the Cape. Visits were 3 years apart. But both times we were served a great pizza, cold beer, and the staff was friendly and efficient. We even talked with the owner ( both times) and he was so kind and appreciative for us coming in.
There is nothing that really stands out as far as atmosphere, but it was comfortable, and you do order and pick up your food at that counter.
We will always go back here whenever we are in town!!“

“Loved JP's Twisted BBQ. The ribs and brisket were so tender and seasoned so well. The pulled chicken was juicy and flavorful. Jay was so nice and personable when we met him. His dinner was the perfect meal for the last night of our girl's trip. Thanks Jay.“

“Great service , amazing lunch. The quiche, French onion soup, fries, salad, drinks, wine and bread were top notch. Can’t wait to come back. We took home Lots of bread too!! Sells out very quickly!!“

“The Shrimp Diavolo is amazing! The entire dish was prepared just right and the bread was also great. I highly recommend this restaurant when on the Cape.“

“Going down hill, pizza to me used to be good, I got a pizza the other day wasn’t cooked, hardly no meat on it, might be time to move on to a new place“

“I always love going to Tap City ! But this past Friday night they took things to another level of excellence. Friday of Labor Day weekend , we got lucky with the last outdoor table for two. We were in a rush to get to the show down the road. So when the waitress came up and asked if we would like anything to drink, I asked if it was at all possible to put in the whole order now so we could get going. Wow! They did not disappoint. Beers came out. With in 7-10 minutes the steak and cheese, and the beet salad came out Steak and cheese was delicious beet salad was second to none. The entire experience was 30 minutes . Which still gave me time to go across the road and buy a new hat I love this place. It’s my favorite place on Main Street.“

“τέλειο! ολλα οκ παντα καλά πολυ νοστιμα!“

“Best restaurant on Cape Cod.“

“Try Royal Pizza tonight and definitely they did not disappointed, we had a large pepperoni pizza, salad and wings… it was amazing, never mind to mention the customer service was excepcional… will go back for sure. Now I’m a loyal to royal.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕👍👍👍👍👍🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We have been regulars for years and we are all very satisfied with our orders from there. Tonight was great! Everyone ate everything!! A couple of us really like the pretzel bites and cheese!! Nachos were perfect 👌 I love how the menu has slightly changed to more of a variety of different foods. Great Job!!“

“We took our family of 8 for dinner. Host was very accommodating as I did not call ahead for a reservation of a large party. Once seated the service was impeccable. Host was very good with our 2 year old grandson. Food was absolutely amazing. Can’t say enough about Four Seasons. Thank you for a wonderful dining experience.“

“Great atmosphere for lunch and dinner! Great affordable prices and great food options! Definitely worth it to visit!“

“I had family staying at the resort so we thought we'd go have a drink and catch some live music here. I'm not sure this would be the place I'd go for a good dinner but the drinks were good and the bar service was attentive. The live music was good and the vibe was fun. The couple next to us got nachos that they said was very good. My sister and I order a side of fries to munch on but the order was super small. I'd go back for a drink but probably not to eat.“

“Wonderful place. Lovely live music. Probably the best place in the area to gather the family.“

“I have been to Montebello twice now. I sat at the bar with 3 other people both times. We all ordered various pasta dishes with chicken, and one other ordered pizza. All of us enjoyed the food! In addition, the complimentary bread and bread dip, were very good. Also, the side salads were small, but fresh and quite good! The bartender Nicholas was polite and very efficient! Drinks were very good as well! We all found the ambience of the bar and the room surrounding the bar quite nice! Based on our combined experiences at Montebello, I (we) would highly recommend it!“

“Best Pizza and Fastest Delivery!!!
Domino’s never disappoints! The pizza is always hot, fresh, and full of flavor. Their delivery is quick and reliable, and the app makes ordering super easy and with the prices better.Definitely one of my go-to spots for a satisfying meal🤩“

“Website says that staff are required to wear masks, no one was wearing. It took about 7 min just to start getting my order. Got my order and as soon as I arrived at my work, I noticed that they forgot to give me some itens. Call them back and ask for a refund since I cant get off of work for another 10 hours now. The excuse was that "they are too busy on Saturdays " even tho on the website shows that "not too busy at this time"! Anyways, quality on customer service is definitely worsening“