Service was great as was the food. Parking is challenging so leave extra time. Really need to make a reservation especially on weekends.
Amy
Food was fantastic! Squash soup was the best I've ever eaten. The short rib rigatoni is superb! Finishes with the heath bread pudding and it was delicious. Good service Very loud. People nearby were. Very obnoxious and we're allowed to carry on. Very annoying. Wish the staff would have asked them to tone it down a bit. Parking was a problem- took 20 min to find a place to park. And we arrived at 5:30! Early.
Brooke
Had to return steak twice but they were good about taking it off the bill. Otherwise nice experience
Tom
First time here. Waitress was great with recommendations! Was pretty noisy upstairs and hearing noise from below. Suggest finding ways to reduce noise.
Latoya
This was my first time experiencing the Baltimore Peninsula area and Rye Street Tavern. This experience was the best ever! And the food was really tasty.
Shatera
Our waitress was terrible (never checked on us, took forever to take our dinner order after we ordered/received our appetizers, someone else had to bring us the check because she just wasn't around, just generally inattentive) but the food was good.
Richard
Excellent Old Fashioned's and amazing food choices. It was my first time but I will be going back!!
Diane
The food was great and we've been several times previously. It is consistently good but it was so noisy and we could barely hear each other across the table. Also the service was a bit inconsistent and we would go large periods without anyone returning to the table with silverware etc after our food arrived.
Mary
Rye Street Tavern was recommend by a friend. We were not disappointed. We will be back. Bottom line, good service, good food, pleasant ambience. *****
Chris Kubay
The restaurant looks great. The atmosphere was what you'd want when going out for the night. However, the food didn't match the experience. Staff, friendly. Restaurant, clean. Service, fast. Food, underwhelming. Crab dip needed more seasoning. Rockefeller Oyster was bland. Which is hard to do because that dish carries distinct flavors. A little more seasoning will take this place over the top. The Calamari was good. Not enough peppers tho. But those Darn Cocktails were top notch. The Old Fashion was great. The Preakness was better.
The waiter was not engaged. We had to let him know we wanted drinks and dessert as he did not ask. We put on our reservation we were there for a birthday, no mention from any staff about that. We had to ask another staff member where our waiter was as he disappeared after we got appetizers, we had not ordered dinner. I'm not sure if he was having a bad day, we weren't his usual customer or the garunteed tip ment not much effort needed.
Otherwise the food was very good. We took home desserts (they could have put the cold ice cream seperate from the warm cobbler so we had soup when we got home) but the cobbler was still delicious the next day. Overall we had a lovely family dinner for my daughter's birthday who was home from college. My husband and I will visit again to enjoy the live music at the bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Andrew Sushkov
All the food was ordinary or even poor. The lump crab dip with bread smelled stale. The only thing worth the money I spent was the beer in the can.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
S Taylor
Service was slow. The servers were bickering amongst themselves, but loud enough for customers to hear. Bartender forgot I ordered a drink. They didn't want to serve us outside which is where we wanted to be. We ordered takeout and ate it outside and that was okay as long as they funny have to serve us.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Sean
Really nice place, service was great, food was great and the view is great. Sat outside and they have heaters for when the colder weather comes. Coming back for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Myra Hickman
Ordered the autumn salad, shrimp were severely over cooked. Salad has maybe 4 ingredients one of them being nuts. Nuts were missing. For a $27 salad I would expect more. My sister got the broccolini, super charred, inedible. Diet Coke was flat poured from a can. Pretty interior, nice servers, but was really disappointed in the food.
Service was great as was the food. Parking is challenging so leave extra time. Really need to make a reservation especially on weekends.
Food was fantastic! Squash soup was the best I've ever eaten. The short rib rigatoni is superb! Finishes with the heath bread pudding and it was delicious. Good service Very loud. People nearby were. Very obnoxious and we're allowed to carry on. Very annoying. Wish the staff would have asked them to tone it down a bit. Parking was a problem- took 20 min to find a place to park. And we arrived at 5:30! Early.
Had to return steak twice but they were good about taking it off the bill. Otherwise nice experience
First time here. Waitress was great with recommendations! Was pretty noisy upstairs and hearing noise from below. Suggest finding ways to reduce noise.
This was my first time experiencing the Baltimore Peninsula area and Rye Street Tavern. This experience was the best ever! And the food was really tasty.
Our waitress was terrible (never checked on us, took forever to take our dinner order after we ordered/received our appetizers, someone else had to bring us the check because she just wasn't around, just generally inattentive) but the food was good.
Excellent Old Fashioned's and amazing food choices. It was my first time but I will be going back!!
The food was great and we've been several times previously. It is consistently good but it was so noisy and we could barely hear each other across the table. Also the service was a bit inconsistent and we would go large periods without anyone returning to the table with silverware etc after our food arrived.
Rye Street Tavern was recommend by a friend. We were not disappointed. We will be back. Bottom line, good service, good food, pleasant ambience. *****
The restaurant looks great. The atmosphere was what you'd want when going out for the night. However, the food didn't match the experience. Staff, friendly. Restaurant, clean. Service, fast. Food, underwhelming. Crab dip needed more seasoning. Rockefeller Oyster was bland. Which is hard to do because that dish carries distinct flavors. A little more seasoning will take this place over the top. The Calamari was good. Not enough peppers tho. But those Darn Cocktails were top notch. The Old Fashion was great. The Preakness was better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
The waiter was not engaged. We had to let him know we wanted drinks and dessert as he did not ask. We put on our reservation we were there for a birthday, no mention from any staff about that. We had to ask another staff member where our waiter was as he disappeared after we got appetizers, we had not ordered dinner. I'm not sure if he was having a bad day, we weren't his usual customer or the garunteed tip ment not much effort needed.
Otherwise the food was very good. We took home desserts (they could have put the cold ice cream seperate from the warm cobbler so we had soup when we got home) but the cobbler was still delicious the next day. Overall we had a lovely family dinner for my daughter's birthday who was home from college. My husband and I will visit again to enjoy the live music at the bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
All the food was ordinary or even poor. The lump crab dip with bread smelled stale. The only thing worth the money I spent was the beer in the can.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Service was slow. The servers were bickering amongst themselves, but loud enough for customers to hear. Bartender forgot I ordered a drink. They didn't want to serve us outside which is where we wanted to be. We ordered takeout and ate it outside and that was okay as long as they funny have to serve us.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Really nice place, service was great, food was great and the view is great. Sat outside and they have heaters for when the colder weather comes. Coming back for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered the autumn salad, shrimp were severely over cooked. Salad has maybe 4 ingredients one of them being nuts. Nuts were missing. For a $27 salad I would expect more. My sister got the broccolini, super charred, inedible. Diet Coke was flat poured from a can. Pretty interior, nice servers, but was really disappointed in the food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Loading...