Carolyn's Cakes

12347 Burkholder Ln, Hagerstown
(301) 791-2469

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Melissa Coffey

My husband ordered 2 cakes from her today. It was last minute and she was able to do it. Cake was moist and delicious! We really appreciate both cakes. Made my moms and my birthday great. My husband said she was the sweetest lady! Ty

Lamar Wadel

Liked the cake and the loaf bread and the best customer service ever! Carolyn's Cakes is a great way for you to get your cake

Stacie Banzhoff

I ask for a Red Velvet for my wedding thank you Carolyn for get my wedding cake order fast before I got married best customer service ever . Deserves all 10,s

Suzanne Eck

Worse cake ive ever had made for my daughter! Not happy at all. Colors aren't even what were in picture. Were to be bright colors for a 17 girl. And there brown, yellow, orange. Dark colors! Icing is hard! Very unhappy!! Heading to store to buy a cake because im so upset!!

Leesia Poe

If u have allergies to food this is the bakery to use!! I called several bakeries & everyone said no. Carolyn was the only one willing to make a gluten free and dairy free cake. She charged a fair price, had it ready in time and not to mention it was delicious ?

L W

If u have allergies to food this is the bakery to use!! I called several bakeries & everyone said no. Carolyn was the only one willing to make a gluten free and dairy free cake. She charged a fair price, had it ready in time and not to mention it was delicious ?

Krista Wade

Carolyn made our wedding cake and we couldn't be more happy with how moist and delicious it was! We added the flowers but such a beautiful touch with the designs in the icing. Very nice older lady and was very reasonable with her prices!

Lmay Pwelte

If u have allergies to food this is the bakery to use!! I called several bakeries & everyone said no. Carolyn was the only one willing to make a gluten free and dairy free cake. She charged a fair price, had it ready in time and not to mention it was delicious 😋

Darlene Toms

Ordered a large single layer chocolate cake with peanut butter icing for my husband's birthday party. It was absolutely delicious. Very moist and the icing was had just the right amount of peanut butter. Thanks again!

Jessica Arnold

Delicious cakes!

Roger Snyder

She is a very nice lady and the cake was great! Highly recommend!

M H

Awesome cakes. Not only has Carolyn made birthday cakes for us but she also did a fabulous job on our wedding and grooms cake last summer. The cakes were beautiful and delicious - all our guests were pleased. Not a single slice was thrown in the garbage (reference the negative post). Yes, we picked up the cakes ourselves but we knew that when we ordered so not a problem.

Wendie Shives

Carolyn has been making cakes for our family for over 30 years! Our family can not wait for the next occasion to order a Carolyn Cake. It is always delicious! Though we always order large cakes, they "disappear" quickly. A very common question at our house, "Who ate all the Carolyn Cake?"

A Google User

Awesome cakes. Not only has Carolyn made birthday cakes for us but she also did a fabulous job on our wedding and grooms cake last summer. The cakes were beautiful and delicious - all our guests were pleased. Not a single slice was thrown in the garbage (reference the negative post). Yes, we picked up the cakes ourselves but we knew that when we ordered so not a problem.

Robin “Irish” Richardson

Used a Pillsbury or some other brand boxed cake mix (white) & used egg yolks to boot so it was a dingy white cake. I could not distinguish whether the frosting was a combination of real butter cream mixed with canned frosting or not but it was not traditional butter cream. I should know, I made, decorated, & sold cakes in the past myself on commission. The finished product was a 14 inch bottom & a 6 inch top sitting right on the bottom cake (no tiers) with thin piped frosting on the outer edges. The entire cake had to be picked up & transported by the bridge & groom & only cash payment was accepted. $120 cash. Please - the skill that went into preparing these cakes was negligible, we threw our slices in the trash the unappealing taste just wasn't worth the calories & sugar. If you are too tired to throw a box cake with oil, water & eggs added into a pan & bake & frost it, then go ahead and commission Carolyn to do it for you. Please temper your expectations, however.

Loading...