22 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Windsor

“Picked up an order of smoked wings and brisket tonight and let me tell you, everything was very delicious. The chicken was cooked to perfection and seasoned well. The brisket was flavorful and melted in your mouth.“

“My family just moved to the area, and Belisimos has kept us fed on multiple occasions when I didn't have the energy to cook. I wanted to leave a review because not only is the food good and the value excellent, but the customer service is wonderful. I just placed an order, and the gentleman I spoke to on the phone was incredibly kind. Then I realized that every time we have had an interaction with someone at Belisimos, it has been pleasant, so I might as well leave a review.“

“The pizza is amazing. Best I’ve had anywhere around here.“

“We just had our first Old Fashion pizza from Sergio’s…delicious! Our new favorite!😋“

“Let me start by saying I love Classico’s! Best pizza and subs! However the chicken tenders are frozen out of a bag, were over cooked and some burnt no taste. Not up to par with there other items. Over priced for overcooked Tyson chicken tenders 😞. Will stick to what I know is good.“

“We had dinner here last night and everything was incredibly delicious. I tried the Chicken Caesar Sub for the first time and I will definitely get it again. The sub roll was soft on the inside and lightly toasted crispy on the outside. The crab deviled eggs were amazing!!!! The bruschetta was tender and not chewy so the toppings never fell off as you took a bite. The cheese pizza was perfect and the Snake Dog IPA was ice cold. Denise was our server and she knew the menu in its entirety and provided impeccable service. The dining room was full and people were endlessly coming in to pick up their take out order. Can’t wait to go back!!!!! Highly recommend all the way around!!!! Thank you, Amante, for a fantastic experience!!!“

“My husband and I play golf at Westminster national and without a doubt every time we start heading home we put stuff off to our favorite pizzeria Roberto's we have never been disappointed we are driving all the way from elkridge it is so so delicious. Always fresh always good the cheese and the ingredients are superior if you're ever in the area whatever you do please stop in you won't be disappointed. Roberto's never disappoints!!“

“Love it.very Nice people“

“First time going to Original Pizza and it was amazing the owner and her crew were awesome we got to talking about a type of calzone that you fry instead of bake she said she knew what I was talking about but never made one well when our food was brought out the nice owner personally brought out her first attempt at a panzerotti and she knocked out the park hopefully this will be on her menu soon cause I can’t wait to go back 4/12/2025“

“Good service and great pizza. The current owners are great people“

“I visited this store blaze pizza with my family and it was amazing from the food to ambience everything was top notch. The staff was very friendly and supportive with all my concerns and also nonetheless the food was so delicious recommend this so much. A must visit place for everyone“

“We found this restaurant by accident, and we are glad we did. we got a veggie pizza and a chicken parmesan sub. The pizza is one of the best we have had - and we have had a lot! the crust is perfect, the cheese and toppings are fresh and very good and the sauce is perfect. The chicken parm was absolutely delicious. We will be trying more things on the menu now.“

“I've been ordering from you guys for a long time. I don't remember ordering your Mussels Marinara. Tonight I placed an order, including 2 orders of that. THEY WERE THE BEST MUSSELS MARINARA I'VE EVER HAD!!! Each mussel was plump, fresh and juicy. And the sauce was. AMAZING!!! In the 80s and 90s, I worked in Little Italy in Baltimore, and they were better than those!! All your food is great, but that was truly a wonderful experience 🥰“

“Our church has been ordering pizzas from Genova's (almost exclusively) for years now, and the quality, timeliness, and service is always on-point. Over the weekend, we had a large order, and the Genova's team was excellent! Keep up the great work & we'll continue to enjoy your great pizza here at Crossroads Church!“

“Ledo's Pizza is an absolute gem! From the moment we walked in, the ambiance was inviting and the aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air. Taylor, our server, provided exceptional service with a warm smile and thorough knowledge of the menu.

The food was beyond delicious; every bite bursting with flavor. Manager Rob ensured our experience was nothing short of perfection, checking in to ensure everything met our expectations.

With its cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and mouthwatering pizzas, Ledo's Pizza has become our go-to spot for a delightful dining experience. Highly recommend!“

“Best pizza around! Still! Keep up the good work!“

“Great pizza. Best pepperoni in town.“

“I will sometimes get the Wednesday pizza special. Never disappoints. I decided today I was going to also order a cheesesteak sub. I could only eat half of it because it was so big. I drove down from Taneytown and now I have my place for pizza and cheesesteak subs. You got me as a customer. Highly recommend“

“Best subs in town! Unfortunately all the other Little George's are gone, but this one lives on.“

“Raven, an assistant manager, made the best Philly cheesesteak pizza I've ever had. Some people go above and beyond and she certainly did. Thank you.“

“I ordered the mozzarella sticks ,steak sub with the homemade chips, and chocolate peanut butter pie and it was amazing. Bartender was very nice and the price was right on!“

“This is the first time i ordered extra pineapple and actually got extra pineapple. Thank you Cranberry Pizza Hut. So yummy.“