22 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Windsor

“Picked up an order of smoked wings and brisket tonight and let me tell you, everything was very delicious. The chicken was cooked to perfection and seasoned well. The brisket was flavorful and melted in your mouth.“

“The very best pizza in Westminster! Great wings, as well! The very first time my husband brought it home I could smell it's deliciousness just as soon as he opened his car door!(in the garage with that door closed!) You can't ever go wrong...it's a crispy crust and not doughy. the cheese and sauce are delicious and any toppings we have tried, as well! Our newest FAVORITE place for pizza❤️“

“Large Portions @ great prices!“

“Absolutely the best cheese steak I've ever in my life and they are Absolutely perfect everytime!! Better than the chz steaks I've had in Philadelphia“

“My kids and I have become regulars at Tony's. I have a 1-year-old girl and a 3-year-old boy. We always order a large cheese pizza, which is absolutely delicious. Our regular waitress, Brandy, knows our order now and puts it in right as we're walking in, sometimes before we've even entered the building if she sees us in the parking lot. And last night she went above and beyond - she had a little stocking for each of my kids with little surprises tucked inside. Never have I ever had a waitress or waiter go out of their way like that. Brandy is fantastic. Now back to the pizza, it's delicious! And for $14.99, I can take my kids and I, and even one of their grandparents along with us, and we can all have dinner "on the cheap" , and give my kids a great experience of learning how to dine out.“

“We had dinner here last night and everything was incredibly delicious. I tried the Chicken Caesar Sub for the first time and I will definitely get it again. The sub roll was soft on the inside and lightly toasted crispy on the outside. The crab deviled eggs were amazing!!!! The bruschetta was tender and not chewy so the toppings never fell off as you took a bite. The cheese pizza was perfect and the Snake Dog IPA was ice cold. Denise was our server and she knew the menu in its entirety and provided impeccable service. The dining room was full and people were endlessly coming in to pick up their take out order. Can’t wait to go back!!!!! Highly recommend all the way around!!!! Thank you, Amante, for a fantastic experience!!!“

“I had great service and great food here at Lexi’s! I’ve always gotten Ledo’s pizza picked up and brought it home, but u recently came to sit in and it was a great experience. There seemed to be only two servers on and it was a bit busy so I ended up waiting for a bit before being greeted, but that wasn’t really an issue especially because the food came out great and our server was very nice.“

“My husband and I play golf at Westminster national and without a doubt every time we start heading home we put stuff off to our favorite pizzeria Roberto's we have never been disappointed we are driving all the way from elkridge it is so so delicious. Always fresh always good the cheese and the ingredients are superior if you're ever in the area whatever you do please stop in you won't be disappointed. Roberto's never disappoints!!“

“We found this restaurant by accident, and we are glad we did. we got a veggie pizza and a chicken parmesan sub. The pizza is one of the best we have had - and we have had a lot! the crust is perfect, the cheese and toppings are fresh and very good and the sauce is perfect. The chicken parm was absolutely delicious. We will be trying more things on the menu now.“

“Both guys behind the counter were super polite and helpful informing us of the specials and different types of foods and thanked us for being our first visit. The atmosphere is great with good music and a great lighting tone. 10 out of 10 will be back.“

“Let me start by saying I love Classico’s! Best pizza and subs! However the chicken tenders are frozen out of a bag, were over cooked and some burnt no taste. Not up to par with there other items. Over priced for overcooked Tyson chicken tenders 😞. Will stick to what I know is good.“

“Love it.very Nice people“

“Vinny’s Pizza has an awesome staffs and consistently delicious food. I recently tried their new addition—the Chicken Steak Wrap and fries—and it was incredible. Truly 5-star service and quality. It's a perfect spot to grab a bite in the TownMall of Westminster, especially being right next to the movie theater!“

“Used Genovas catering for my daughter's birthday party. Contacting them to place the order was easy and they were very helpful/responsive. On the day of, delivery was exactly when I wanted it, the delivery driver was very friendly/helpful, and all the food was delicious. Very happy and will definitely be using them again in the future.“

“we ordered pizza a salad and wings. pizza and wings were good. Salad was nothing like Tim's. it was Not packed down like tim used to do. for what you pay for a salad I think it should be more In the bowl. I can't have the pizza so I get a salad. very disappointed in the salad.“

“I will sometimes get the Wednesday pizza special. Never disappoints. I decided today I was going to also order a cheesesteak sub. I could only eat half of it because it was so big. I drove down from Taneytown and now I have my place for pizza and cheesesteak subs. You got me as a customer. Highly recommend“

“Thank you to Tony and the J&P staff who went above and beyond to make sure everything ran smoothly over the weekend for my grandfather's celebration of life. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was just right, and having a private space made the event feel personal and comfortable. We’re so grateful for their kindness and care during such an important day.“

“Best subs in town! Unfortunately all the other Little George's are gone, but this one lives on.“

“Raven, an assistant manager, made the best Philly cheesesteak pizza I've ever had. Some people go above and beyond and she certainly did. Thank you.“

“fast, friendly and courteous staff and driver! we appreciate the support! Placed an order today and it was right on time! didnt get the driver's name, but they were great! thank you!!!“

“I’ll be honest, I was both excited and skeptical about trying Wonder when it first opened. The whole concept seemed a little strange to me, and I wasn’t sure how it would actually work. Since they were offering 50% off for first time customers when I went, I figured it was worth a try.

We ordered a pizza from Alanza, a double cheeseburger from Burger Baby, and a Build Your Own Bowl from El Diez. Funny enough, the burger, which was the item I was least excited about based on how it looked, ended up being my favorite. It was honestly one of the best burgers I’ve had in a long time. The pizza was a little overdone, but I actually like my pizza that way, so no complaints there. The bowl was good too, though I felt like it was missing a little something. Maybe some extra lime or cilantro would have given it more of that fresh Mexican flavor.

I’d definitely come back and try some of the other restaurants they have. I also really liked the atmosphere. It was quiet, clean, and didn’t feel chaotic, which was nice. The kitchen area looked especially clean, which always leaves a good impression.

If you’ve been curious about Wonder and are looking to try something different, I’d say it’s worth checking out, especially while they’re offering 50% off for new customers. There’s a huge variety of food options, so it’s easy for everyone in your group to find something they’ll enjoy. Overall, I was pleasantly surprised and left more impressed than I expected to be.“

“This is the first time i ordered extra pineapple and actually got extra pineapple. Thank you Cranberry Pizza Hut. So yummy.“